Authored By: Vaidehi Pandey
University of Nottingham
Case Name: Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala
Citations: [ 2019] 11 SCC 1
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Justice R.F. Nariman, Justice A.M. Khanwilkar, Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, and Justice Indu Malhotra
Date of Judgement: 28 September 2018
Relevant statutes:
- Article 14: Equality before the law
- Article 15: Prohibition of Discrimination
- Article 17: Abolition of Untouchability
- Article 19: Protection of Freedom of Speech
- Article 21: Protection of Life and Liberty
- Article 25: Freedom of Conscience and Religion
- Article 26: Freedom to manage religious affairs
Brief Facts
The Sabarimala temple is a significant temple to the Hindu community. The landmark case is the legal battle in India regarding the ban on women between the ages of 10 and 50 from entering the temple or the grounds because they are in the menstruating age group. Lord Sabrimala (Ayyappa) is considered celibate (Naishtik Bramahari) and, traditionally, should not be touched or worshipped by women in that age group. This rule was to be enforced upon the devotees on the grounds of Rule 3(b) of the Kerala Hindu Places of Public Worship (Authorisation of Entry) Rules, 1965 – which permit exclusion of women from public places primarily based on customs.
When the case reached the High Court of Kerala, it was concluded that the state government has no power to interfere in the day-to-day administration of the temple. Furthermore, it was also decided that only the “priests” can make decisions regarding historical rituals. Over 50 review petitions were presented to the Supreme Court, bench of CJI Misra, on the grounds that this rule is discriminatory and a fundamental wrong towards a particular gender.
Issues involved
- Is the decision to exclude women from worshipping their god in Sabarimala a violation of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution?
- What does this practice constitute? Is it discrimination based on sex and/or is it contrary to the constitutional prohibition of untouchability under Article 17
- Do the devotees of Lord Ayyappa constitute a separate religious denomination with its own rules that are different from the broader Hindu public? If they are not a separate entity, they cannot claim immunity from general entry laws that are followed across India. Does that entitle them to protection under Article 26?
- Does the exclusion of women from worship constitute an essential religious practice (ERP) protected by Article 25?
- How valid is Rule 3(b)? Is this specific rule a violation of the parent act (which aims to open temples to all classes) itself, and is this practice constitutional under gender equality?
- Should a restriction based on a biological attribute of a particular gender be considered valid legal reasoning to exclude an individual? Does that conflict with the constitutional morality regarding justice, liberty and equality that was instilled within the system?
- Arguments
Petitioners’ Arguments (Indian Young Lawyers Association):
- The petitioners argue that the exclusion ultimately discriminates against women based on sex. The petitioners also argued that the practice views sex/ menstuation as a disability. The ban is a blanket rule set upon a factor that women have no control over. A patriarchal notion such as “Purity” or tradition cannot be allowed to claim a status higher than the basic concept of equality, as affirmed in the case by Chief Justice Dipak Misra. Males and females both have the right to preach their god and be free from discrimination.
- Sabrimala is a public place of worship. To deny entry based on sex is a violation of Article 15(1): the State shall not discriminate against anybody on the grounds of religion, caste, race, sex, place of birth or any of them. It is also a violation of Article 15(2), which forbids discrimination against any person in public places on the same grounds.
- The practice has been placed because, in Hindu traditions, menstruation has been viewed as “dirty” or “Polluted”, and a location like Sabarimala aims for “purity”. However, these terms were often used to describe untouchability, which is constitutionally prohibited.
- Women have the constitutional right to freely profess and practice their religion. Is the ban established in Sabarimala not a breach of fundamental rights?
- The petitioners argued that it is not a requirement in Hinduism to exclude any individual from the worship of god, so why is this rule being established at a location so relevant to every Hindu?
- Respondents Arguments
- The respondents argued that the restriction is being placed based on the nature of the god (Lord Ayyappa) in the temple. Due to his nature, all religious practices associated with him also need to be altered.
- The respondents argue that under Article 26, Ayyappa devotees constitute a distinct religious denomination, which gives the temple the right to manage their own affairs without any intervention.
- Priests argue that the exclusion is fundamental to the traditional and religious beliefs of devotees of Ayyappa Swamy. Due to his celibate nature, this restriction is set to honour his identity.
- The court does not have power over religious decisions.
- The argument regarding Lord Ayyappa Swamy’s celibate nature is enough to dismiss women from worshipping the lord.
Judicial procedure
The court tackled multiple questions during its procedure
- Is Sabarimala a separate Religious Denomination
- The court applied a 3 tier from the case Acharya Jagdishwaranand (Ananda Marga). There are expectations of a collection of individuals with a common system of beliefs, a common organisation, and a designated distinctive name. While Ayyappa followers are fundamentally Hindus and have the same belief system, they do not have a distinct faith or a separate sacred text that separates them from their Hindu identity. Hence, the court did not approve their qualification as a religious denomination.
- Did this practice qualify under the Essential Religious Practices [ERP]
- The court concluded that excluding women from religious settings is not an essential requirement, but rather a traditional and historic debate. The court relies purely on textual evidence and morally ignores living, organic traditions. The court could not find enough evidence stating the same; hence, the claim was denied.
- Discrimination against women based on an analysis of Article 25 and Article 15
- According to Article 15 (prohibition of discrimination), the court rejected the claim regarding the exclusion based primarily on sex. Menstruation is a phenomenon that all women naturally encounter. For the temple to exclude women based on a factor that is outside of their control. It is discrimination on a natural factor, which is condemned by law.
- According to Article 25(1), freedom of conscience and religion guarantees freedom of conscience and religion to all individuals equally. The court believes that this practice might be appropriate under customs; however, it is a breach of an individual’s own rights. Furthermore,
Ratio decidendi and Judgement
In the judgement, the court decided that
- The exclusion of women between the ages of 10-50 is unconstitutional
- Women could not be denied entry based on old customs.
- The Ayyappa devotees were not a separate religious denomination
- The practice was not an essential religious practice
- Rule 3(b) was unconstitutional to the extent that it permitted such exclusion
An equation of 4:1 judgement was passed, which denied the decision to approve the ban on women from entering Tirumala. The majority’s ratio was that excluding women of menstruating age is discrimination based on biological characteristics and is a violation under Articles 14 and 15. The court prioritised every individual’s fundamental constitutional rights over customs and traditions, as the scope of traditions did not align with the legal system’s idea of equality and justice. Hence, the court gave priority to constitutional morality. Finally, the court decided to strike down the statutory rule, Rule 3(b) of the Kerala Hindu places of public worship (Authorisation of Entry) Rules, 1965, which permitted the exclusion of women based on customs, therefore concluding that removing women was unconstitutional.
Critical analysis
The judgement challenged the idea of women’s bodies deciding which public religious space they have permission to enter. The court took the right decision by ensuring that women’s constitutional rights were put over customs and traditions. Furthermore, the judgement recognised women as more than just members of a religious community. The decision to ensure women’s rights were not decided by a community but instead by law was commendable. Finally, a crucial distinction that the case outlined was that tradition is not as important as rights and cannot be used as a defence for discrimination.
However, there are some criticisms one can draw upon reading the case. Religion is a very private affair to every individual in India, so is it right for judges to be the decision-makers of what is or isn’t essential to one’s religion? Furthermore, the fact that Indu Malhotra was the only judge on the bench who dissented to the decision is interesting. Her justification for the dissent stems from the fact that she believes the courts should be cautious when making decisions that are matters of faith, and the courts should exercise greater restraint towards such factors.
Bibliography:
Statute:
- Constitution of India, 1950: https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/19150/1/constitution_of_india.pdf (Accessed 28 August, 2026)
Case law:
- Acharya Jagdishwaranand Avadhuta v. Commissioner of Police, Calcutta (1983) 4 SCC 522
Secondary sources:
- Background: Kantaru Rajeevaru v. Indian Young Lawyers Association (Supreme Court Observer) https://www.scobserver.in/cases/kantaru-rajeevaru-indian-young-lawyers-association-sabrimala-review-background/ [Accessed 12 September 2026]
- ‘Case Comment: Indian Young Lawyers Association & Ors v State of Kerala & Ors [2019] 11 SCC 1’ (IJLLR) https://www.ijllr.com/post/case-comment-indian-young-lawyers-association-ors-v-state-of-kerala-ors-2019-11-scc-1 [ Accessed 13 September 2026]
- GKToday, ‘Indian Young Lawyers Association v State of Kerala (Sabrimala Case)’ (GKToday) https://www.gktoday.in/indian-young-lawyers-association-v-state-of-kerala-sabarimala-case/ [ Accessed 13 September 2026]
- Lex Humana https://seer.ucp.br/seer/index.php/LexHumana/article/view/2666 [Accessed 13 2026]
- NLUD Centre for Communication Governance, ‘Indian Young Lawyers Association and Ors vs The State of Kerala and Ors’ (Privacy Library) https://privacylibrary.ccgnlud.org/case/indian-young-lawyers-association-and-ors-vs-the-state-of-kerala-and-ors [ Accessed 14 September 2026]

