Home » Blog » Africa Climate Alliance v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy

Africa Climate Alliance v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy

Authored By: Tsholofelo Maliba

University of Limpopo

Case Citation and Basic Information

Full Case Name: Africa Climate Alliance, Vukani Environmental Justice Movement in Action, and groundWork Trust v. Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy, National Energy Regulator of South Africa, Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment, President of the Republic of South Africa, and Minister of Electricity and Energy

Citation / Case Number: High Court of South Africa, Gauteng Division, Pretoria, Case No. 59767/2021; [2024] ZAGPPHC (Judgment of 4 December 2024). Appeal pending before Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA).

Court & Jurisdiction: High Court of South Africa (Gauteng Division, Pretoria); Supreme Court of Appeal, Bloemfontein.

Date of Decisions: High Court Judgment – 4 December 2024; SCA Hearing – 19 August 2026.

Bench Composition: High Court: Hon. Judge Cornelius van der Westhuizen (Single-Judge Bench). Applicants: Africa Climate Alliance, Vukani Environmental Justice Movement in Action, groundWork Trust (represented by Centre for Environmental Rights).

Respondents: Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy; NERSA; Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment; President of South Africa; Minister of Electricity and Energy.

Introduction

The #CancelCoal case is South Africa’s first youth-led constitutional climate lawsuit.[1] challenging the government’s determination under the 2019 Integrated Resource Plan (IRP 2019) and the Ministerial Determination of September 2020 to procure 1,500 megawatts (MW) of new coal-fired electricity generation capacity. Brought by youth activists and environmental justice organizations, the case asserts that committing South Africa to multi-decadal new coal infrastructure severely infringes constitutional rights to an environment not harmful to health or well-being (Section 24), [2]the paramount best interests of the child (Section 28(2)), [3]and fundamental rights to life, dignity, and equality under the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act (PAJA). [4]The legal significance of the case lies in its groundbreaking integration of child-rights jurisprudence with climate change law, establishing that public administrative power in energy planning is strictly subject to constitutional oversight, mandatory environmental impact assessments, and empirical rational decision-making regarding cleaner renewable energy alternatives.

  1. Facts of the Case

South Africa relies heavily on coal for approximately 80% of its national electricity production, rendering it the 13th largest global emitter of carbon dioxide and the single largest contributor to greenhouse gas emissions on the African continent. This coal-intensive energy system has generated severe localized air pollution across industrial hotspots such as the Mpumalanga Highveld, causing over 2,200 premature deaths annually and inflicting thousands of cases of chronic bronchitis and pediatric asthma, at an estimated economic health cost exceeding R30 billion per year.[5]

In October 2019, the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy published the Integrated Resource Plan 2019 (IRP 2019), setting out the country’s electricity generation roadmap for the subsequent decade. The IRP 2019 allocated 1,500 MW of new coal-fired power capacity to be operationalized by 2030.[6] On 25 September 2020, the Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy, with the formal concurrence of the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (NERSA) pursuant to Section 34 of the Electricity Regulation Act 4 of 2006,[7] published a Ministerial Determination authorizing the procurement of this 1,500 MW new coal capacity, equivalent to three to four large utility-scale coal power plants.[8]

Civil society organizations, including groundWork, African Climate Alliance (ACA), and Vukani Environmental Justice Movement in Action (VEM), participated extensively in prior public consultation processes, arguing that any new coal procurement was unconstitutional, economically irrational, and incompatible with South Africa’s international climate commitments under the Paris Agreement.[9] When the Minister and NERSA failed to provide justifiable reasons or evidence that climate and health impacts had been evaluated, the applicants, represented by the Centre for Environmental Rights (CER), initiated constitutional proceedings in the High Court of South Africa (Gauteng Division, Pretoria) in November 2021.

The application was bolstered by comprehensive expert reports, including modeling by the University of Cape Town’s Energy Systems Research Group (ESRG). The ESRG report established that 1,500 MW of new coal was unnecessary for grid reliability, would add between R23 billion and R109 billion in excess costs compared to a least-cost renewable energy plan, and would release an additional 289 Mt CO2-equivalent in cumulative greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. [10]Furthermore, expert psychological evidence from clinical psychologist Dr. Garret Barnwell documented the profound mental health injuries and climate anxiety experienced by South African youth living on the frontlines of coal pollution.[11]

In December 2022, an interlocutory court order compelled the government to produce the complete Rule 53 administrative record of its decision. Inspection of the record revealed that neither the Minister nor NERSA had conducted any children’s rights impact assessment or evaluated public health harms prior to approving the procurement.[12] On 4 December 2024, Judge Cornelius van der Westhuizen of the Pretoria High Court delivered judgment declaring the 1,500 MW coal plan unconstitutional and setting it aside. The Minister of Electricity subsequently appealed the judgment to the Supreme Court of Appeal, with oral arguments heard on 19 August 2026.[13]

  1. Legal Issues

The High Court was called upon to determine three primary questions of law:

  • Issue 1 (Constitutional Rights): Whether the decision by the Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy and NERSA to allocate and procure 1,500 MW of new coal-fired power under the IRP 2019 and the Ministerial Determination of September 2020 unjustifiably limits the constitutional rights of present and future generations to an environment not harmful to health or well-being (Section 24), the paramount best interests of the child (Section 28(2)), and the fundamental rights to life (Section 11), human dignity (Section 10), and equality (Section 9) under the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996?[14]
  • Issue 2 (Administrative Rationality): Whether the Minister and NERSA breached mandatory statutory and constitutional duties of administrative rationality and procedural fairness under the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000 (PAJA) and Section 34 of the Electricity Regulation Act 4 of 2006 by failing to investigate, evaluate, and consider children’s rights impact assessments, public health risks, and environmental climate harms prior to taking the decision?[15]
  • Issue 3 (Limitation Clause): Whether the limitation of constitutional rights entailed by procuring new coal-fired electricity is reasonable and justifiable under Section 36 of the Constitution (the general limitation clause), in light of empirical evidence demonstrating that clean, renewable energy alternatives are feasible, lower-cost, and less harmful?[16]
  1. Arguments Presented

5.1 Applicants’ Arguments

The applicants contended that the decision to procure 1,500 MW of new coal power is an unconstitutional exercise of public power that fails basic standards of administrative law and fundamental rights protection:

  1. Constitutional Infringement: The applicants argued that coal-fired power generation emits heavy atmospheric pollutants and greenhouse gases that directly harm human health and accelerate climate change, violating Section 24. Crucially, under Section 28(2), the best interests of the child are of paramount importance in every matter concerning the child. Because children are biologically and socio-economically most vulnerable to toxic air pollution and climate breakdown, procuring new coal power places an unconstitutional burden on youth.[17]
  2. Procedural Unlawfulness and Absence of Impact Assessments: The applicants highlighted that the Rule 53 administrative record contained no evidence that the Minister or NERSA undertook any assessment of the decision’s impact on children’s health, environmental rights, or climate change. The complete failure to consider relevant factors rendered the determination procedurally unfair, irrational, and invalid under PAJA.
  3. Economic and Technical Irrationality: Drawing on the ESRG expert report, the applicants demonstrated that new coal procurement is economically unviable and technically unnecessary. Cleaner renewable energy (solar PV and wind) backed by storage is cheaper, faster to deploy, generates twice as many employment opportunities per megawatt, and avoids R23 billion to R109 billion in unnecessary financial costs while aligning South Africa with its fair share commitments under the Paris Agreement.[18]

5.2 Respondents’ Arguments

The government respondents (the Minister, NERSA, and the Minister of Electricity) defended the policy determination on the following grounds:

  1. Executive Discretion in National Energy Security: The respondents submitted that national energy policy and technology allocation fall within the exclusive policy prerogative of the executive. They argued that procuring 1,500 MW of coal power was a rational and necessary measure to alleviate South Africa’s severe electricity supply deficit and mitigate chronic load shedding.[19]
  2. Utilization of Domestic Natural Resources: The state argued that South Africa possesses vast domestic coal reserves, and that continuing to exploit coal is essential for base-load power reliability, economic stability, and energy sovereignty.
  3. Rejection of Mandatory Child Impact Assessment: The respondents contended that general macro-economic energy planning determinations under the Electricity Regulation Act do not constitute a ‘matter concerning the child’ under Section 28(2) of the Constitution and therefore did not legally require specific children’s rights impact assessments prior to administrative determination.[20]
  4. Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

In a comprehensive judgment handed down on 4 December 2024, Judge Cornelius van der Westhuizen of the Pretoria High Court ruled entirely in favour of the youth applicants, establishing crucial principles regarding executive compliance with constitutional rights during energy transitions.

Constitutional Control of Ministerial Determinations: The Court affirmed that administrative determinations issued under Section 34 of the Electricity Regulation Act do not enjoy unfettered executive immunity. They constitute exercises of public power that must strictly conform to the Bill of Rights and the principle of legality under Section 1(c) of the Constitution. The Court held that energy policymaking cannot bypass constitutional human rights imperatives.[21]

Failure to Consider Mandatory Relevant Factors (Section 28 & Section 24): Upon evaluating the Rule 53 record, the Court found a fatal procedural defect: the Minister and NERSA had completely omitted any consideration of the health, environmental, and climate harms of coal power, specifically failing to assess the impact on children. Judge Van der Westhuizen held that Section 28(2) of the Constitution imposes an affirmative obligation on decision-makers to explicitly evaluate children’s best interests when taking macro-environmental decisions that will shape the living environment of young people for decades. The complete absence of children’s impact assessments in the administrative record rendered the decision procedurally invalid and unlawful.[22]

Rejection of the Energy Crisis Défense & Rationality Standard: The Court decisively rejected the state’s defence that national load shedding justified procuring new coal. The Court noted that the government produced no empirical or technical evidence demonstrating that 1,500 MW of coal was necessary or superior to renewable energy. On the contrary, the uncontradicted expert evidence established that renewable energy alternatives could be deployed far more rapidly, at lower cost, and without inflicting severe environmental and health damage. Consequently, the Court held that the decision to commit public resources to high-cost, polluting coal power lacked administrative rationality and could not be saved by Section 36 limitation analysis.[23]

  1. Judgment and Ratio Decidendi

7.1 The Decision

The High Court of South Africa (Gauteng Division, Pretoria) ruled as follows:

  1. The decision of the Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy of 25 September 2020 under Section 34 of the Electricity Regulation Act 4 of 2006 to procure 1,500 MW of new coal-fired power capacity is declared unconstitutional, unlawful, and invalid, and is set aside.2. The concurrence of NERSA in the Ministerial Determination of 25 September 2020 is declared unconstitutional, unlawful, and invalid, and is set aside.3. The Integrated Resource Plan 2019 is declared unconstitutional and invalid to the extent that it provides for the procurement of 1,500 MW of new coal-fired power.4. The First and Second Respondents (the Minister and NERSA) are ordered jointly and severally to pay the applicants’ costs of the application, including the costs of two counsel.[24]

7.2 Ratio Decidendi

Ratio Decidendi: An administrative determination by the executive to procure fossil-fuel energy capacity that generates substantial greenhouse gas emissions and toxic air pollution is unconstitutional, irrational, and invalid if the decision-maker fails to investigate, evaluate, and explicitly weigh its impacts on environmental rights (Section 24) and the paramount best interests of children (Section 28(2)), particularly where empirical evidence demonstrates that cleaner, less harmful, and lower-cost renewable energy alternatives are readily available.

  1. Critical Analysis

8.1 Significance of the Decision

The #CancelCoal judgment marks a historic milestone in climate jurisprudence across Africa and the global South. [25]As the continent’s first successful youth-led climate lawsuit, it firmly embeds intergenerational equity and children’s rights into administrative law. By ruling that macro-energy planning must account for children’s rights under Section 28(2), the court effectively dismantled the traditional legal doctrine that economic policymaking is shielded from human rights scrutiny.

8.2 Implications and Impact

The practical and policy impacts of the ruling are far-reaching. Legally, it sets a binding precedent requiring state decision-makers to conduct formal Child Rights Impact Assessments (CRIAs) and comprehensive climate risk assessments for all future energy and infrastructure determinations. Politically, the ruling directly influenced subsequent energy policy revisions, such as the draft Integrated Resource Plan of 2025, which excluded new coal procurement allocations. [26]Furthermore, it reinforces South Africa’s Just Energy Transition (JET) framework by legally prioritizing investments in socially owned renewable energy and green jobs over legacy fossil fuels.

8.3 Critical Evaluation

Strengths of Reasoning: The judgment is exceptionally robust in its constitutional grounding and integration of multi-disciplinary expert evidence. By placing the evidentiary burden on the state to justify why polluting coal was chosen over cheaper renewables, the Court effectively countered state claims of administrative necessity. The principled application of Section 28(2) provides a powerful legal shield for youth against long-term environmental degradation.

Potential Criticisms & Future Challenges: While legally sound, the state’s decision to appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court of Appeal highlights ongoing institutional resistance within government departments. Critiques from state-aligned actors argue that judicial intervention in energy mix selection risks overreaching into executive economic policy during energy supply emergencies. However, the High Court correctly emphasized that executive emergency responses cannot supersede constitutional rights.

  1. Conclusion

The #CancelCoal case represents a watershed moment in South African constitutional law, proving that youth activism backed by rigorous legal strategy can hold government accountable to its constitutional promises. By declaring the procurement of 1,500 MW of new coal-fired power unconstitutional, the High Court established that energy security and economic development must be pursued through sustainable, human-rights-compliant pathways.

The single most critical takeaway from this litigation is that children’s rights and environmental protection are not passive policy considerations—they are mandatory constitutional constraints on state power. As the Supreme Court of Appeal considers the government’s appeal following oral arguments in August 2026, the foundational principles established in the High Court judgment will continue to shape the trajectory of environmental justice, public health, and clean energy governance across Southern Africa for decades to come.

  1. Reference(S):

Primary Legal Authorities & Legislation:

Afr. Const., 1996, §§ 9, 10, 11, 24, 28(2), 36, 195.

Africa Climate Alliance and Others v. Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy and Others (Case No 59767/2021) [2024] ZAGPPHC (High Court of South Africa, Gauteng Division, Pretoria, 4 Dec. 2024).

Electricity Regulation Act 4 of 2006, § 34 (S. Afr.).

Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000 (PAJA) (S. Afr.).

Department of Mineral Resources and Energy, Integrated Resource Plan 2019, Gov. Notice 1360 in Gov. Gazette 42784 (18 Oct. 2019).

International Treaties, Expert Reports & Secondary Sources:

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, Paris Agreement, art. 2(1)(a), Dec. 12, 2015, T.I.A.S. No. 16-1104, 2193 U.N.T.S. 84.

Energy Systems Research Group (ESRG), Assessment of New Coal Generation Capacity Targets in South Africa’s 2019 Integrated Resource Plan for Electricity (University of Cape Town, 2021).

Dr. Garret Barnwell, Expert Affidavit on the Psychological and Mental Health Consequences of Climate Change in South Africa (Presented in High Court Case No. 59767/2021, 2021).

Centre for Environmental Rights (CER), #CancelCoal Case Fact Sheet: Youth-Led Climate Challenge (Cape Town, CER 2021).

Sabin Center for Climate Change Law, Climate Change Litigation Database: Africa Climate Alliance et al. v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy et al. (Columbia Law School, 2025). 

[1] Africa Climate Alliance and Others v. Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy and Others (Case No. 59767/2021) [2024] ZAGPPHC (High Court of South Africa, Gauteng Division, Pretoria, 4 Dec. 2024), para. 1.

[2] S. Afr. Const., 1996, § 24 (“Everyone has the right to an environment that is not harmful to their health or well-being…”).+

[3] S. Afr. Const., 1996, § 28(2) (“A child’s best interests are of paramount importance in every matter concerning the child.”).

[4] Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000 (PAJA) (S. Afr.).

[5] Centre for Environmental Rights, #CancelCoal Case Fact Sheet: Youth-Led Climate Challenge (Nov. 2021).

[6] Department of Mineral Resources and Energy, Integrated Resource Plan 2019, Gov. Notice 1360, Gov. Gazette 42784 (Oct. 18, 2019).

[7] Electricity Regulation Act 4 of 2006, § 34 (S. Afr.).

[8] Ministerial Determination under Section 34 of the Electricity Regulation Act 4 of 2006, Gov. Notice 1015 (Sept. 25, 2020).

[9] United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, Paris Agreement art. 2(1)(a), Dec. 12, 2015, T.I.A.S. No. 16-1104, 2193 U.N.T.S. 84.

[10] Energy Systems Research Group (ESRG), Assessment of New Coal Generation Capacity Targets in South Africa’s 2019 Integrated Resource Plan for Electricity (Univ. of Cape Town, 2021).

[11] Dr. Garret Barnwell, Expert Affidavit on the Psychological and Mental Health Consequences of Climate Change in South Africa, High Court Case No. 59767/2021 (2021).

[12] Africa Climate Alliance v. Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy [2024] ZAGPPHC, para. 28 (noting disclosure of Rule 53 record).

[13] Centre for Environmental Rights, Government Appeals Landmark Youth Climate Court Victory as #CancelCoal Case Returns to Court (Aug. 13, 2026).

[14] S. Afr. Const., 1996, § 11 (Right to life); id. § 10 (Human dignity); id. § 9 (Equality).

[15] Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000, §§ 3, 6 (S. Afr.); Electricity Regulation Act 4 of 2006, § 34 (S. Afr.).

[16] S. Afr. Const., 1996, § 36.

[17] S. Afr. Const., 1996, § 28(2); see also UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, General Comment No. 26 (2023) on children’s rights and the environment.

[18] Energy Systems Research Group (ESRG), Assessment of New Coal Generation Capacity Targets in South Africa’s 2019 Integrated Resource Plan for Electricity (Univ. of Cape Town, 2021), pp. 14–22.

[19] Respondents’ Answering Affidavit, Africa Climate Alliance v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy, Case No. 59767/2021 (2021).

[20] Respondents’ Answering Affidavit, Africa Climate Alliance v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy, Case No. 59767/2021 (2021).

[21] S. Afr. Const., 1996, § 1(c); see also Fedsure Life Assurance Ltd. v. Greater Johannesburg Trans. Metro. Council, 1999 (1) SA 374 (CC) (S. Afr.).

[22] Africa Climate Alliance v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy [2024] ZAGPPHC, paras. 42–50.

[23] Africa Climate Alliance v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy [2024] ZAGPPHC, paras. 55–62.

[24] Africa Climate Alliance v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy [2024] ZAGPPHC, Order paras. 1–4.

[25] Sabin Center for Climate Change Law, Climate Change Litigation Database: Africa Climate Alliance et al. v. Minister of Mineral Resources & Energy et al. (2025).

[26] Department of Mineral Resources and Energy, Draft Integrated Resource Plan 2025 (Govt. Notice 2025).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top