Home » Blog » Bajaj Auto Ltd vs. T.V.S. Motors Company Ltd 10 SCC 257

Bajaj Auto Ltd vs. T.V.S. Motors Company Ltd 10 SCC 257

Authored By: Chaitrali Sawant

University of Mumbai Law Academy

Bajaj Auto Ltd. Vs. T.V.S. Motors Company Ltd.

Case Citation: Bajaj Auto Ltd vs. T.V.S. Motors Company Ltd 10 SCC 257

Court: The High Court of Madras & The Supreme Court of India

Date of Decision: 4th October 2010

Bench:  Justice Elipe Dharma Rao, Justice K.K. Sasidharan

  1. Introduction

The case of Bajaj Auto LTD vs. T.V.S. Motor Company LTD (2010)[1] is a landmark case in the Intellectual Property Law. This case is based on the infringement of technology by the T.V.S Motors Company of the Bajaj innovative engine (DTS-i) technology. The Bajaj company filed suit for infringement of their patented technology in the Madras High Court in 2007 and appealed for a Temporary Injunction to stop further production and sales. The T.V.S company filed another suit against the Bajaj company stating the suit was filed on the “Groundless Threat”. The Bajaj company appealed to the Supreme Court. Later on, both the companies settled the matter outside the court in the year 2019.

  1. Facts:
  • The case of Bajaj Auto LTD vs. T.V.S. Motors Company LTD (2010) is a case where two motors companies got into the dispute over the infringement of the patented technology.
  • Bajaj Auto company innovated a Digital Twin Spark-ignition technology (DTS-i) used in 125-CC Flame motorcycles which was patented technology by them. Bajaj further notice that the T.V.S. Motors Company alleged infringed their patented technology.
  • Bajaj Company then filed a lawsuit against the T.V.S. Motor Company under Section 108 of the Patents Act 1970, which provide relief to the original patentees by granting injunction to the infringed patent technology or innovation. The Single Judge granted temporary injunction to the T.V.S Motors Company.
  • V.S. later challenged the Injunction order and filed counter suit under Section 106 of The Patents Act, 1970[2] against Bajaj Company for “Groundless/Unjustifiable Threats” and seeking relief provided under this Section such as declared the threat as invalid for patent infringement to the Division Bench of the High Court.
  • The Division Bench of the Madras High Court repealed the injunction order. Bajaj challenging the Division Bench of Madras High Court by appealing to the Supreme Court of India.
  1. Issued Raised
  • Whetherthe T.V.S. Motors Company infringed the patented technology of Bajaj?
  • Whether the innovation by the T.V.S company can be manufacture without infringing original patented innovation
  1. Arguments Presented:

Argument by the Plaintiff:

The Bajaj Company sued the T.V.S. Company claiming that the patented technology which was originally patented by the Bajaj Company infringed by T.V.S Company without prior consent and stole the key function of the Bajaj motorcycles, which help to improve efficiency and performance. Bajaj requested for the injunction order to prohibit T.V.S. Company from further manufacturing, additionally they claimed for the damages that occurred because of infringement.

Argument by the Defendant:

The T.V.S. Company filed the counter suit for the groundless threat by the Bajaj Company. They claimed that the Bajaj claim of originality is baseless as the Twin Spark technology was already existed in the US Honda engine technology which made the Bajaj claim “non-novel”. The T.V.S. Company also argued that there was no infringement of technology as there is a modification in the engine which vary it from the Bajaj technology. Considering all the defence the T.V.S. Company appeal the Division Bench of Madras High Court for the overturn of injunction order by single judge of Madras High Court.

  1. Court Reasoning & Analysis

Madras High Court:

The Single judge in this case evaluating the both the side arguments and the provided evidence granted the relief to the Bajaj Company by restraining Temporary injunction to the T.V.S. Company the main reason for this order is to avoid the threat and loss by the Bajaj Company due to infringement. On the other hand, the Division Bench of the high court focused largely on the modification repealed the temporary injunction order reasoning that the engine of the T.V.S. Company has been modified and they used the three-valve configuration while the Bajaj used two-valve configuration which create the difference between both the engine technology.

Supreme Court

The Supreme Court dismissed the Bajaj appeal as the cannot prove the patent infringement and ruled in favour of T.V.S. Company on the basis of the improvement in the technology and proved that the engine is not the legitimate copy of the Bajaj’s engine. The Supreme Court’s involvement in this case expressed the deep concern about the delay in the IP related matters and urgency of resolving the matter, which brought drastic change in the proceeding, timeline, and efficiency of resolving IP matter in India, considering the monetary loss, trust issues and other loss face by both the companies involve in the patent infringe related matter. In the case of M/s Shree Vardhman Rice and Gen Mills vs. M/s Amar Singh Chawalwala (2009)[3], the Supreme Court recognised that it is mandatory that the trial related to IP matter should be heard on daily basis and not to stuck till the interlocutory stage.

Law interpretation

The Patent Act, 1970

Section 48: Right to Patentees: This section gives special right to the patentees, which prevent others the act of using the patented technology or innovation without the prior permission of the original patent owner. In the above case the Bajaj Company u/s 48 registered their engine technology which prohibit other party to use the technology without original company’s prior consent.

Section 106: Power of court to grant relief in cases of groundless threats of infringement proceedings: This section provide relief to the party who were sued for infringement on the groundless threats, the threats which are not proven and unjustifiable by the other party during the inquiry. The T.V.S. Company filed suit against the Bajaj Company for groundless threat of infringement, which the Bajaj Company failed to prove the infringement.

Section 108: Relief in suits for infringement: This section provide relief through granting injunction and penalties or any other relief requested by plaintiff. The Bajaj company seek the primary relief through the suit while seeking injunction against T.V.S. Company.

Doctrine of Equivalents known as (Doctrine of Pith & Marrow): The Doctrine of Equivalents is used when the Patent infringement done by the third party is not exact but somehow give the similarity through function, process and outcome and due to even small amount of infringement the original patent party can claim for the infringement. In the above case the Baja discovered that the T.V.S. Company had copied their Twin Spark Technology which is not the literal infringement but gave the same result.

Order 39 Rule 1 (Code of Civil Procedure): This is the legal provision used for the temporary injunction to prohibit one party to use the patented technology. This injunction granted by the court only if the three conditions are fulfilled: 1. Prima Facie, 2. Irreparable loss due to infringement, 3. Balance of Convenience. The Madras High Court order Injunction in this case under this rule of CPC to prevent the further manufacturing and selling of the engine technology.

          6. Judgement

The Hon’ble Supreme Court had provided guidelines to the lower courts and tribunals for the trial of patent, copyright and trademark cases during the pendency of a suit for Permanent Injunction. The Court set aside the interim order issued by a single Bench and remanded the matter for further discussion regarding the respondents’ right to continue selling their product, for which they had to maintain an adequate account of all India and export sales, for which a receiver has been appointed. The Court also pointed out that any claim of improvement would have to be made at a proper price for the use of their improvement, which would be the same as paying to plaintiff for their use of their design.

The Court also decried the practice of prosecution of cases with regard to infringement proceedings, where proceedings went on for the most part to secure an interim injunction. It noted that there were a lot of aspects which need to be taken into consideration in matters related to infringement on IP rights and that the time spent on these matters should be kept to a minimum, with hearings to be held on a day-to-day basis and cases to be decided within two to three months. In this context directions were issued that all lower courts and tribunals “strictly comply with and adhere to these guidelines and do so promptly and in good faith.

  1. Critical Analysis
  • Proper allocation of the Burden of Proof – A Substantive Safeguard: The most important change made by the court is the switch in the burden of proof, which was to say that the party alleging infringement had the initial burden to establish a prima facie case. This was established because, by withholding the defendant’s right to defend himself/herself, the judge does not allow procedure to defeat substantive justice. It correctly recognizes the burden of proof as a substantive anchor, rather than as a tool to be played with in an intricate IP litigation.
  • Impact on Indian Patent Law – Procedural weaponisation: It brings clarity into IP litigation and helps to discourage the patent owner from making defensive disclosures in response to pre-mature directions. This is salutary for both true innovators and legitimate competitors, safeguarding them from the abuse of procedure. The judgment effectively links the evidentiary process to the burden of proof and puts an end to the strategic manipulation of evidence in an area where technical facts matter and are extremely complex.
  • The Supreme Court’s decisions on the speedy trials: The Hon’ble court order to dispose of IP issues within 2-3 months and hearing the issues day-to-day, is good intention, but creates some serious concerns. Although it is intended to reduce unnecessary adjournments and delays in the court, the rigid schedules in the absence of adequate institutional capacity, such as case backlogs, may negatively affect the quality of the adjudication in complex cases.
  1. Conclusion:

The Supreme Court evaluating the technology and it’s function they concluded that the T.V.S. Company did not infringe the technology, as they found the modification in the T.V.S. modified engine, the Bajaj Company used the dual spark plug which is two-valve configuration, whereas the T.V.S. Motor Company used three-valve configuration. The Supreme Court in this case dismissed the Bajaj Company’s appeal and affirmed the High Court’s Division Bench decision of removing the injunction order and allowing the T.V.S. Company to manufacture and sell their motors.

The Supreme Court addressed that the cases related to the Intellectual Property Law should significantly improves the efficiency and should be heard on day-to-day basis and to be resolve within the 4 months from the day of filing infringement related suits, The case of Bajaj Auto LTD vs. T.V.S. Motors company LTD become a landmarks case in the Intellectual Property law which brought impact on the principle of infringement and how the fast and efficient procedure for IP related cases analysing the important and the damage which company might faces due to injunction order during the trials.

Reference(S):

[1] Bajaj Auto LTD vs. T.V.S. Motors Company LTD (2010)

[2] The Patents Act, 1970

[3] M/s Shree Vardhman Rice and Gen Mills vs. M/s Amar Singh Chawalwala (2009)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top