Authored By: Zandile Nhlapo
University of South Africa
- Case Citation and Basic Information
Full Case Name: Centre for Child Law v T.S. and Others
Citation: Centre for Child Law v T.S. & Others, [2023] ZACC 22, 2023 (6) SA 1 (CC), 2023 (9) BCLR 1027 (CC) (S. Afr.).
Case Number: CCT 157/22
Court: Constitutional Court of South Africa
Date of Decision: June 29, 2023
Judgment: Tshiqi J
Bench: Maya DCJ, Baqwa AJ, Kollapen J, Madlanga J, Majiedt J, Mathopo J, Mbatha AJ, Mhlantla J, Rogers J, and Tshiqi J.
Decision: Unanimous.
The recent and significant South African family law case Centre for Child Law v. T.S. and Others addresses problems of equality, child rights, parental obligations, and the constitutional protection of the family regardless of the parents’ marital status. Section 4 of the Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act 24 of 1987 (Mediation Act) was at issue in the case. Because it made it easier for married parents going through divorce to contact the Office of the Family Advocate, the Constitutional Court was asked to decide whether the law unfairly discriminated against parents who had never married and their kids.
The legislative discrimination was declared to be unconstitutional. It decided that it was discriminatory to deny married and single parents’ access to the Family Advocate. In order to give the legislature time to correct the constitutional flaw, the Court declared invalidity for a term of 24 months.
- Brief Introduction
The Constitution of South Africa fundamentally altered the country’s family law system. Some family law concerns in South Africa’s pre-constitutional democracy arose from traditional views on marriage, legitimacy, parenthood, and the distinction between children conceived in and out of wedlock. The Constitution introduced a new approach that placed equality, dignity, and children’s rights at the forefront. S. Afr. Const., 1996 §§ 9–10, 28
One example of South Africa’s constitutional reform is the case of Centre for Child Law v T.S. and Others. Centre for Child Law v. T.S. & Others, [2023] ZACC 22, 2023 (6) SA 1 (CC)
The case concerns the Office of the Family Advocate, which was established to assist courts with child-related cases. The Family Advocate investigates issues relating to parental rights and responsibilities and provides recommendations based on the welfare and best interests of the children concerned.
The issue was that the Constitution was created in 1996, while the Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act was enacted in 1987. The Office of the Family Advocate was easily accessible to married individuals involved in divorce proceedings. However, there was no legal provision allowing people who had never been married to access the Family Advocate’s office in the same manner. Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act 24 of 1987 § 4 (S. Afr.)
The question was whether this distinction was constitutional.
This case is important because it demonstrates that constitutional equality extends beyond formal equality. A law that disadvantages a particular group may, in certain circumstances, be unconstitutional. It also demonstrates the importance of children’s rights in South Africa.
- Facts of the Case
B.N. and T.S. were romantically involved. B.N. was a professional rugby player who lived and worked in France at the time, and T.S. relocated to France to live with him. Centre for Child Law, [2023] ZACC 22, ¶ 5
The couple had two children, who were born in 2009 and 2011. The couple never married.
In 2014, their relationship ended. T.S. and the children returned to South Africa, while B.N. continued providing financial support for the children. Id
The parties later disagreed about the children’s residence, contact, and other matters relating to parental responsibilities. In 2016, they entered into a parenting plan dealing with guardianship, residence, contact, and parental responsibilities. The parenting plan was subsequently made a court order.
After several years, T.S. married another man. The new family intended to relocate to Australia. B.N. stated that he would not consent to the children leaving South Africa because he opposed the proposed relocation. He indicated that he would prefer the children to live with him if they were to leave the country.
The disagreement concerning relocation resulted in High Court proceedings. The involvement of the Office of the Family Advocate became important because relocation of children is an issue requiring careful consideration of the children’s best interests.
The Office of the Family Advocate is intended to investigate circumstances affecting children and assist courts in making decisions concerning parental rights and responsibilities. However, the legal framework distinguished between parents who had never been married and parents who were married and involved in divorce proceedings.
As a result, T.S. and B.N., who had never been married, did not have the same access to the Office of the Family Advocate as married individuals involved in divorce proceedings.
The distinction between married and unmarried parents was therefore challenged on constitutional grounds. The Centre for Child Law became involved in the matter and challenged the relevant provisions on the basis that they discriminated against unmarried parents and their children.
The Constitutional Court ultimately had to determine whether this distinction was consistent with the Constitution.
- Legal Issues
The following primary legal issues had to be determined by the Constitutional Court:
- Whether section 4 of the Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act 24 of 1987 discriminated between married and unmarried parents.
- Whether this differentiation amounted to unfair discrimination under section 9 of the Constitution.
- Whether discrimination based on marital status violated the right to human dignity protected by section 10 of the Constitution.
- Whether the Act violated section 28(2) of the Constitution, which provides that a child’s best interests must be of paramount importance in every matter concerning the child.
- Whether the unequal access to the Family Advocate unfairly disadvantaged never-married parents and their children.
- What constitutional remedy the Court should apply if the legislation was found to be unconstitutional.
- Arguments Presented
Applicant’s Arguments
The Centre for Child Law argued that the statutory distinction between married and unmarried parents was unconstitutional.
The applicant argued that never-married parents were required to approach a court before the Family Advocate could become involved, whereas married parents involved in divorce proceedings had comparatively easier access to the Family Advocate. The applicant considered this additional procedure to be an unnecessary burden on parents who had never been married.
The primary legal basis for the application was section 9 of the Constitution, which guarantees equality and prohibits unfair discrimination. Section 9(3) specifically identifies marital status as a prohibited ground of discrimination.
The applicant also relied on section 10, which protects human dignity. Differentiation based on marital status was regarded as undermining the equality and dignity of families affected by the distinction.
Most importantly, the applicant relied on section 28(2), which provides that a child’s best interests are paramount in every matter concerning the child. It was argued that the legislation was unconstitutional because it prevented certain children from receiving professional assistance in matters affecting them.
Respondents’ Arguments
The respondents acknowledged that the law distinguished between married and unmarried parents but disagreed about whether the distinction amounted to unlawful discrimination.
One justification for the distinction was that marriage and divorce have separate legal requirements. The statutory framework, including the Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act, had been created specifically in response to issues arising from divorce.
However, the Minister of Justice, who was responsible for the administration of justice, accepted that the legislation was outdated because it had been enacted before the Constitution. He agreed that legislative reform was necessary. The respondents were therefore unable to provide sufficient justification for maintaining the discriminatory distinction.
- Court’s Reasoning and Analysis
The Constitutional Court examined the relevant legislative framework. It noted that the Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act was enacted in 1987, before the Constitution and its protection of equality, dignity, and children’s rights. Consequently, the legislation had to be considered within the modern constitutional framework.
The Court first considered whether the law differentiated between certain groups. It concluded that it did. Id. ¶¶ 2–3
The legislation allowed married parents involved in divorce proceedings to access the Family Advocate through the procedures provided by the Mediation Act. Unmarried parents did not have the same access.
The Court then considered whether this distinction amounted to discrimination. Because marital status is one of the grounds listed in section 9(3) of the Constitution, discrimination based on marital status is presumed to be unfair unless it can be justified.
The Court emphasized that the effects of the distinction had to be considered. The issue was not merely discrimination against a particular category of parents. The distinction affected families’ ability to obtain professional assistance when disputes concerning their children arose.
The purpose of the Family Advocate is to protect children’s interests. The Office investigates circumstances affecting children and assists courts in making decisions concerning parental rights and responsibilities. Therefore, difficulties experienced by unmarried parents in accessing the Family Advocate could negatively affect the interests of their children.
The Court emphasized the importance of section 28(2) of the Constitution. The best interests of children are given paramount importance. This does not mean that the best-interests principle will always favour one parent. Rather, it means that the legal system must be structured in a manner that protects children.
The Court found that legislation creating unequal access to an institution specifically intended to protect children did not satisfy this requirement.
The Court also considered human dignity. The Constitution requires the dignity of every person to be respected and protected. A distinction suggesting that children or families of unmarried parents are less deserving of institutional protection may undermine their dignity.
For these reasons, the statutory distinction constituted unfair discrimination.
It is important to note that the Court did not regard marriage as a sufficient reason for granting certain family’s special access to the Family Advocate. Children are entitled to protection regardless of their parents’ marital status. The constitutional rights of children of unmarried parents are equal to those of children of married parents.
The Court’s reasoning therefore supports the broader constitutional principle that children’s legal protection should not depend on whether their parents are married.
After finding the legislation unconstitutional, the Court considered the appropriate remedy. Instead of immediately invalidating the relevant provision, the Court suspended the declaration of invalidity for 24 months to allow Parliament an opportunity to correct the constitutional defect.
The Court also employed an interim reading-in remedy.
- Judgment and Ratio Decidendi
The Constitutional Court unanimously upheld the declaration that the relevant provisions of section 4 of the Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act were unconstitutional insofar as they unjustly denied never-married parents and their children equal access to the Family Advocate.
The declaration of invalidity was suspended for a period of 24 months to provide Parliament with an opportunity to correct the constitutional defect.
The Court also provided a temporary remedy by reading additional provisions into the legislation. This ensured that the constitutional rights of affected parents and children were protected while Parliament considered legislative changes.
The central ratio decidendi of the case is that legislation cannot unfairly discriminate between families on the basis of the parents’ marital status where the distinction disadvantages never-married parents and their children.
The case further demonstrates that equal access to a statutory mechanism designed to protect children cannot be determined solely by the marital status of their parents. The ruling therefore reinforces the constitutional requirement that children’s best interests be protected regardless of whether their parents are married.
The judgment also demonstrates the remedial powers of the Constitutional Court. In order to balance constitutional rights with Parliament’s institutional responsibility, the Court may suspend a declaration of invalidity and provide an interim remedy.
- Critical Analysis
The judgment is significant because it demonstrates how the Constitution has transformed South African family law.
First, the judgment recognizes the complexity of modern family structures. Families in South Africa cannot be viewed only as married heterosexual couples with children. Families may include married parents, unmarried parents, single parents, and blended families. A legal system may become disconnected from social reality if it treats people differently solely because of their marital status.
Second, the Court appropriately considered the interests of the children rather than focusing only on the parents. Although the dispute involved two parents who disagreed about relocating their children, the children themselves were directly affected by the legislation. This approach is consistent with section 28(2) of the Constitution, which emphasizes the paramount importance of the child’s best interests.
Another important aspect of the judgment is the Court’s recognition that procedural inequality can produce substantive inequality. At first, requiring an unmarried parent to follow additional court procedures before accessing the Family Advocate may appear to be merely a procedural difference. In practice, however, court proceedings may involve significant legal costs, delays, emotional strain, and uncertainty.
The judgment therefore illustrates that equality must be considered both formally and practically.
Finally, the Court’s approach to the remedy is significant. Rather than immediately invalidating the relevant provision, the Court allowed Parliament 24 months to introduce the necessary legislative changes while providing affected families with a temporary solution.
There are, however, some possible limitations to the decision.
One limitation is that the solution depends largely on Parliament taking the necessary legislative action. Equal statutory access to the Family Advocate does not necessarily result in equal access to justice for all families. Difficulties relating to information, distance, and financial circumstances may continue to affect access to legal assistance.
Therefore, although the judgment addresses one form of discrimination, it does not eliminate every inequality within the South African family law system.
It is also important to note that the judgment does not mean that marriage has no legal significance. South African law continues to attach various legal consequences to marriage. Instead, the judgment recognizes that marital status cannot be used to create unequal access to a mechanism whose primary purpose is the protection of children’s interests unless there is a constitutional basis for such differentiation.
The judgment can therefore be regarded as an important example of constitutional interpretation.
- Conclusion
T.S. and Others v Centre for Child Law, [2023] ZACC 22, 2023 (6) SA 1 (CC), is an important recent South African family law case demonstrating how the principles of the Constitution have transformed the treatment of families and children within the legal system.
The case concerned a provision that gave married parents involved in divorce proceedings greater access to assistance from the Office of the Family Advocate than parents who had never been married.
The provision was found to be unconstitutional because it unfairly discriminated against unmarried parents and, more importantly, their children.
The conclusion was supported by three important principles contained in the South African Constitution. Section 9 prohibits unfair discrimination, section 10 recognizes and protects human dignity, and section 28(2) emphasizes the importance of children’s rights and their best interests.
The Court emphasized that the effects of discriminatory legislation cannot be assessed only from the perspective of parents. The central consideration is also whether children whose interests are affected may suffer as a result of the legal provision.
The most important implication of the case is that it challenges the idea that the level of legal protection available to a family should depend on the marital status of the parents. Children should not receive less legal protection merely because their parents are unmarried.
The decision also demonstrates how the South African Constitutional Court can respect the separation of powers while providing effective remedies for unconstitutional legislation. In this case, the Court used a temporary reading-in remedy and suspended the declaration of invalidity to allow Parliament to address the constitutional defect.
In conclusion, Centre for Child Law v T.S. and Others is a significant case in South African family law. It makes clear that the Constitution requires children’s rights to be protected regardless of their parents’ marital status and recognizes the existence of different family structures.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Case Law
Centre for Child Law v T.S. & Others, [2023] ZACC 22, 2023 (6) SA 1 (CC), 2023 (9) BCLR 1027 (CC) (S. Afr.).
B v S, 1995 (3) SA 571 (A) (S. Afr.).
Fraser v Children’s Court, Pretoria North & Others, 1997 (2) SA 261 (CC) (S. Afr.).
Gory v Kolver NO & Others, 2007 (4) SA 97 (CC) (S. Afr.).
Harksen v Lane NO & Others, 1998 (1) SA 300 (CC) (S. Afr.).
Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie, 2006 (1) SA 524 (CC) (S. Afr.).
Bhe v Magistrate, Khayelitsha & Others, 2005 (1) SA 580 (CC) (S. Afr.).
Ex parte Critchfield & Another, 1999 (3) SA 132 (W) (S. Afr.).
Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996.
Children’s Act 38 of 2005.
Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act 24 of 1987.
Divorce Act 70 of 1979.
Books
Heaton, Jacqueline. South African Family Law. 4th ed. LexisNexis, 2015.
Robinson, J.A., and A.M. Robinson. Family Law and the Law of Persons. 7th ed. LexisNexis, 2020.
Sinclair, J.D. The Law of Marriage. Juta & Co., 1996.
Van Heerden, B., A. Skelton, and A. Du Toit, eds. Boberg’s Law of Persons and the Family. 2nd ed. Juta & Co., 1999.
Constitutional and Legal Materials
Constitutional Court of South Africa. Centre for Child Law v T.S. and Others. Constitutional Court Judgment, 2023.
Republic of South Africa. Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996.
Republic of South Africa. Children’s Act 38 of 2005.
Republic of South Africa. Mediation in Certain Divorce Matters Act 24 of 1987.
Secondary Sources
Boezaart, T. Child Law in South Africa. 3rd ed. Juta & Co., 2017.
Clark, B. Family Law: Service and Practice. 4th ed. Juta & Co., 2012.
Skelton, A. “Children’s Rights and the Constitution.” South African Journal on Human Rights.
Van Heerden, B. “The Constitutionalisation of Family Law in South Africa.” South African Law Journal.

