Home » Blog » Gloster Limited v Gloster Cables Limited & Ors

Gloster Limited v Gloster Cables Limited & Ors

Authored By: Chaithanya N

Ramaiah Institute of Legal Studies

1. Case Citation and Basic Information

Case: Gloster Limited v Gloster Cables Limited & Ors

Citation: 2026 INSC 81

Civil Appeal Nos: 2996 of 2024 and 4493 of 2024

Originating proceedings: CA(IB) No 713/KB/2019, NCLT Kolkata; Company Appeal (AT)(Ins) No 1343 of 2019, NCLAT

NCLT order: 27 September 2019; NCLAT judgment: 25 January 2024

Bench: J B Pardiwala J and K V Viswanathan J; judgment by Viswanathan J, Pardiwala J concurring.

Subject: IBC, NCLT jurisdiction, resolution plans, trademark title, preferential/undervalued transactions and natural justice.

2. Introduction

The case concerns the scope of the National Company Law Tribunal’s (‘NCLT’) jurisdiction under section 60(5)(c) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016 (‘IBC’). The dispute arose during the corporate insolvency resolution process (‘CIRP’) of Fort Gloster Industries Limited (‘FGIL’) and involved competing claims over the ‘Gloster’ trademark. The Supreme Court considered whether the NCLT could conclusively determine a pre-existing and disputed question of trademark title merely because the trademark became relevant to the CIRP. It also considered whether the NCLT could make findings concerning preferential and undervalued transactions without following the applicable statutory procedure and requirements of natural justice.

3. Facts of the Case

FGIL was the Corporate Debtor undergoing CIRP. A section 9 application filed by Jayant Panja was admitted on 9 August 2018. Gloster Limited became the Successful Resolution Applicant (‘SRA’). Its resolution plan was approved by the Committee of Creditors (‘CoC’) and the NCLT. The plan referred to the ‘Gloster’ trademark, recorded the SRA’s belief regarding FGIL’s ownership and acknowledged competing claims.¹

The dispute concerned Trade Mark Registration No 690772 in Class 9. FGIL and Gloster Cables Limited (‘GCL’) had entered into agreements concerning the mark. A Technical Collaboration Agreement dated 2 May 1995 permitted GCL to use the mark for electric cables. A Trademark Agreement dated 29 July 2004 granted GCL an exclusive licence and first right to purchase the trademark for ₹3 crore and annual royalty.²

In 2006, GCL advanced a loan of ₹10 crore to FGIL and relied upon a related security arrangement concerning the trademark. A Supplemental Trademark Agreement dated 15 July 2008 contemplated assignment of the trademark to GCL for ₹10 lakh. The effectiveness of the assignment was disputed in light of the BIFR proceedings.³

After the BIFR proceedings abated, FGIL and GCL executed a Deed of Assignment dated 20 September 2017. GCL’s own pleadings contained different effective dates: its counter-affidavit referred to 1 December 2016, while the Deed referred to 28 May 2017. GCL also continued paying licence fees for FY 2017–18. Gloster Limited relied upon these facts to challenge GCL’s assertion concerning the effective date.⁴

After commencement of CIRP, GCL was recorded as proprietor of the trademark in September 2018. GCL filed CA(IB) No 713/KB/2019 before the NCLT seeking protection of its rights and exclusion of the trademark from the resolution process. The NCLT, by order dated 27 September 2019, treated the trademark as an asset of FGIL and made findings concerning the assignment and sections 43 and 45 of the IBC.⁵

GCL had also filed CS No 43 of 2019 before the Commercial Court, Secunderabad, seeking an injunction concerning the trademark. The suit was dismissed; the Telangana High Court upheld the decision on 14 February 2022, and the Supreme Court dismissed the SLP on 12 May 2022.⁶ The NCLAT, by judgment dated 25 January 2024, set aside the NCLT’s title-related conclusion. Both parties appealed to the Supreme Court.⁷

4. Legal Issues

  1. Whether the NCLT had jurisdiction under section 60(5)(c) of the IBC to conclusively determine ownership of the disputed ‘Gloster’ trademark.

  2. Whether the NCLT could treat the trademark as an asset of FGIL and thereby confer rights over it upon the SRA when the resolution plan recognised competing claims.

  3. Whether the NCLT could make findings concerning preferential or undervalued transactions under sections 43 and 45 without proper statutory procedure, pleadings, notice and opportunity of hearing.

5. Arguments Presented

5.1 Gloster Limited

Gloster Limited argued that the trademark was an asset of FGIL and that the dispute had a sufficient connection with CIRP to fall within section 60(5)(c). It relied upon the contractual history, BIFR proceedings, assignment documents and subsequent registration of GCL as proprietor. It challenged the validity and timing of the assignment and submitted that the transaction could be examined under the IBC provisions concerning preferential and undervalued transactions.⁸

It also relied upon the inconsistent effective dates stated by GCL and its continued payment of licence fees during FY 2017–18. It raised issues concerning the post-CIRP registration of the trademark and the moratorium under section 14.⁹

5.2 Gloster Cables Limited

GCL contended that its application sought protection of its claimed trademark rights and did not invite the NCLT to finally adjudicate title. The dispute arose from pre-existing agreements and assignment documents and therefore existed independently of insolvency. Its relevance to the CIRP did not, by itself, create jurisdiction under section 60(5)(c).¹⁰

GCL further argued that the resolution plan recognised competing claims and did not constitute a judicial declaration that FGIL owned the trademark. It submitted that the SRA could not obtain rights beyond the approved plan. It also challenged the findings under sections 43 and 45 because no proper avoidance proceeding had been instituted and the necessary procedural safeguards had not been followed.¹¹

5.3 Resolution Professional

The Resolution Professional (‘RP’) made a distinct submission. The RP relied upon FGIL’s balance sheets and BIFR filings, which treated the trademark as an asset of FGIL. The RP stated that the 2008 Supplemental Trademark Agreement was disclosed only in April 2019, after the forensic audit report had been submitted on 10 April 2019. The RP therefore contended that the absence of a formal avoidance application could not simply be attributed to RP negligence.¹²

6. Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined section 60(5)(c) and the words ‘arising out of or in relation to’. Relying on Embassy Property Developments Pvt Ltd v State of Karnataka, Gujarat Urja Vikas 11Nigam Ltd v Amit Gupta and Tata Consultancy Services Ltd v Vishal Ghisulal Jain, Resolution Professional, SK Wheels Pvt Ltd, the Court held that NCLT jurisdiction is broad but not unlimited.¹³

The Court distinguished disputes intrinsically connected with insolvency from independent disputes which merely become relevant during CIRP. Applying this distinction, it held that the trademark-title dispute depended upon pre-existing agreements, assignment, registration and competing claims of title. Its relevance to the Corporate Debtor’s value did not itself confer jurisdiction upon the NCLT to finally determine ownership.¹⁴

The Court examined the resolution plan and noted that it recorded the SRA’s belief and understanding concerning ownership while acknowledging rival claims. The plan therefore did not amount to an adjudication of title. Relying on SREI Multiple Asset Investment Trust, Vision India Fund v Deccan Chronicle Marketeers, Ebix Singapore Pvt Ltd v Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions Ltd and Kalyani Transco v Bhushan Power & Steel Ltd, the Court reaffirmed the sanctity of an approved resolution plan.¹⁵ The NCLT could not use an incidental application to confer upon the SRA rights not conclusively provided by the plan.

The Court also considered the NCLT’s findings under sections 43 and 45. It held that allegations of preferential or undervalued transactions require the appropriate statutory process and cannot be determined indirectly without proper pleadings and material.¹⁶ The affected party must receive notice and a meaningful opportunity to contest the allegation. Otherwise, natural justice would be violated.¹⁷ The reasoning is consistent with Anuj Jain, Interim Resolution Professional for Jaypee Infratech Ltd v Axis Bank Ltd, concerning the procedural requirements governing avoidance proceedings.¹⁸

The earlier commercial suit was also relevant to the Court’s conclusion that the underlying title question should remain available for determination before the competent forum. The Court therefore avoided using the insolvency proceeding to finally adjudicate an independent title dispute.¹⁹

7. Judgment and Ratio Decidendi

The Supreme Court set aside the NCLT’s finding that the ‘Gloster’ trademark was an asset of FGIL and rejected the title-related conclusions of the lower tribunals. Importantly, it did not declare either Gloster Limited or GCL to be the owner. The question of title was left open for determination before the competent forum, uninfluenced by the observations made in the insolvency proceedings.²⁰

The Court also rejected the NCLT’s approach to sections 43 and 45 where the statutory procedure and natural-justice requirements had not been followed.²¹

The ratio decidendi is that section 60(5)(c) confers wide but contextually limited jurisdiction on the NCLT and does not permit it to conclusively determine an independent and pre-existing trademark-title dispute merely because the dispute becomes relevant during CIRP. Further, findings concerning preferential or undervalued transactions must be made through the applicable statutory procedure and in accordance with natural justice.

8. Critical Analysis

The judgment appropriately preserves the jurisdictional boundaries of the NCLT. An unlimited interpretation of section 60(5)(c) could allow independent contractual, property or intellectual-property disputes to be brought before the NCLT merely because one party is undergoing insolvency. The Court’s approach prevents such jurisdictional expansion.

The decision also balances speedy insolvency resolution with procedural fairness. Although the IBC seeks time-bound resolution and value maximisation, these objectives cannot justify conclusively determining disputed title without proper adjudication. The Court’s emphasis on notice, pleadings and opportunity of hearing strengthens natural justice within insolvency proceedings.

The protection of the approved resolution plan is commercially significant. A resolution plan may identify disputed assets and claims, but it cannot itself operate as a judicial declaration of ownership. However, the judgment creates a practical difficulty where a disputed trademark materially affects valuation. Leaving title to another forum may cause additional litigation and uncertainty. Resolution plans should therefore expressly identify disputed assets and allocate the consequences of pending title litigation.

Overall, the judgment is best understood as a fact-sensitive clarification of NCLT jurisdiction rather than a general exclusion of intellectual-property disputes from insolvency proceedings. Its principal contribution is to ensure that insolvency efficiency does not become a basis for deciding an independent title dispute through an inappropriate or procedurally deficient process.

9. Conclusion

Gloster Limited v Gloster Cables Limited & Ors is significant at the intersection of insolvency and intellectual-property law. The Supreme Court clarified that the broad jurisdiction under section 60(5)(c) must remain connected to the insolvency process and cannot be used to conclusively determine an independent and pre-existing trademark-title dispute merely because the trademark becomes relevant during CIRP.

The Court reaffirmed the sanctity of an approved resolution plan and the necessity of following statutory procedure and natural justice before making findings concerning preferential or undervalued transactions. Most importantly, it left ownership of the ‘Gloster’ trademark open for adjudication by the competent forum. The decision therefore establishes an important boundary between insolvency adjudication and independent commercial or intellectual-property title disputes.

10. OSCOLA Footnotes / Authorities

  1. Gloster Ltd v Gloster Cables Ltd & Ors 2026 INSC 81 (SC) paras 4–4.1.

  2. ibid para 4.2(ii), (vi).

  3. ibid para 4.2(vii).

  4. ibid paras 7.3–7.6.

  5. ibid paras 4.3–4.5.

  6. ibid para 9.8.

  7. ibid paras 4.8–5.

  8. ibid paras 7–7.8.

  9. ibid paras 7.2–7.7.

  10. ibid paras 9–9.1.

  11. ibid paras 9.1, 9.6–9.7.

  12. ibid paras 8–8.9, 43–44.

  13. Embassy Property Developments Pvt Ltd v State of Karnataka (2020) 13 SCC 308; Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd v Amit Gupta (2021) 7 SCC 209; Tata Consultancy Services Ltd v Vishal Ghisulal Jain, Resolution Professional, SK Wheels Pvt Ltd (2022) 2 SCC 583; Gloster (n 1) paras 25–31.

  14. Gloster (n 1) paras 37, 40.

  15. SREI Multiple Asset Investment Trust, Vision India Fund v Deccan Chronicle Marketeers (2023) 7 SCC 295; Ebix Singapore Pvt Ltd v Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions Ltd (2022) 2 SCC 401; Kalyani Transco v Bhushan Power & Steel Ltd 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2093; Gloster (n 1) para 36.

  16. Gloster (n 1) paras 42–43.

  17. ibid para 45.

  18. Anuj Jain, Interim Resolution Professional for Jaypee Infratech Ltd v Axis Bank Ltd (2020) 8 SCC 401; Gloster (n 1) paras 42–49.

  19. Gloster (n 1) paras 50–52.

  20. ibid paras 50–51.

  21. ibid paras 42–52.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top