Home » Blog » Donoghue v Stevenson

Donoghue v Stevenson

Authored By: Chukwukaima Vivian Fabian-Egun

University of Dundee

Case: Donoghue v Stevenson

Citation: [1932] AC 562

Court: House of Lords

Date: 26 May 1932

Area of Law: Tort Law – Negligence

Introduction

The case of Donoghue v Stevenson[1] is a landmark case concerning the law of negligence and the duty of care. The case was important because at that time the law of negligence was very narrow and included some kind of contractual relationship. The case considered whether there was a duty of care by Stevenson in the absence of any contractual relationship. The case became significant because Lord Atkin introduced the neighbour principle, which established that one must not injure one’s neighbour and must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which can reasonably be foreseen to injure another person. The case therefore helped develop the law of negligence and established that there does not need to be a contractual relationship for a duty of care to be established.

Facts of the Case

The case involved a dispute between Mrs Donoghue and Stevenson, the manufacturer of the ginger beer. On 26 August 1928, Mrs Donoghue’s friend bought her a bottle of ginger beer from Wellmeadow Café in Paisley. The ginger beer was contained in a dark, opaque glass bottle, meaning that the contents of the bottle could not be properly inspected from the outside.

Mrs Donoghue consumed approximately half of the ginger beer. When the remaining contents of the bottle were poured into a tumbler, the decomposed remains of a snail were discovered floating in the drink. Mrs Donoghue alleged that the discovery of the snail caused her shock and that consuming the contaminated ginger beer caused her to suffer from severe gastroenteritis and other consequences.

The ginger beer had not been purchased by Mrs Donoghue herself. Instead, it had been purchased for her by her friend. Therefore, Mrs Donoghue did not have a contractual relationship with Stevenson, the manufacturer of the ginger beer. This was important because, at the time, the law relating to negligence was closely connected with contractual relationships, and a person who was not a party to a contract could face difficulties in bringing a claim against a manufacturer.

Mrs Donoghue was also unable to bring a claim based on breach of warranty of contract because she had not entered into a contract with Stevenson. Her friend had purchased the ginger beer, while Stevenson was the manufacturer. As a result, Mrs Donoghue sought to bring proceedings against Stevenson in negligence.

The case therefore arose from the alleged contamination of the ginger beer and the illness suffered by Mrs Donoghue. The absence of a contract between Mrs Donoghue and Stevenson became an important part of the dispute because it raised the question of whether a manufacturer could owe a duty of care to a consumer even where there was no direct contractual relationship between them.

Legal Issues

Issue 1: Whether a manufacturer owes a duty of care in negligence to the ultimate consumer of a product where there is no contractual relationship between the manufacturer and the consumer.

Issue 2: Whether Mrs Donoghue could bring an action in negligence against Stevenson despite having no contractual relationship with him.

Issue 3: Whether the circumstances of the case were sufficient to establish a duty of care owed by Stevenson to Mrs Donoghue.

Arguments Presented

The Appellant

The appellants stated that the respondent should have ensured that a system was in place in order to ensure snails would not get into their packaged products, that is, an efficient system of inspection was there to conduct checks before the bottles were sealed.

According to the appellants, the respondents failed in both these duties and caused the accident. Since the respondent invited the public to consume a product they manufactured, bottled, labelled and sealed and offered no opportunity to the consumer to examine their contents, they owed a duty of care to the appellants to ensure nothing in the bottle would injure such a consumer.Moreover, the appellant sought the principle of res ipsa loquitur[2] was applicable in the present scenario. The fact that there was a snail in the bottle spoke for itself the negligence of the manufacturers.

The appellants cited the following:

George v Skivington (1869)[3] – This case held that ordinary care was owed to person using the product even in lack of a contractual relationship.

The case of Heaven v Pender[4] was also cited as it observed that whenever a reasonable person would foresee that harm would be caused if he did not use reasonable care and skill, he owes a duty in tort.

The Respondents

The respondents claimed that the allegations of injury to the appellant were exaggerated and not as a cause of the alleged snail but due to existing health problems. Hence, they were irrelevant and insufficient to constitute a proper ground for a summons.They also sought to prove that the appellants had no legal basis for the given claim by citing these cases:

Mullen v AG Barr & Co Ltd (1929)[5]

It was held that no duty of care could arise in the absence of a contractual relationship. This was similar to the case except dead mice were discovered instead of a snail. However, the Scottish Sessions Court dismissed the case due to the absence of a contractual relationship and used the same precedent to dismiss this case as well.

Winterbottom v Wright[6]: In this case, the issue of contention was whether the manufacturer owed any duty of care to a third party and the judgment was given in negative.The respondents contended that although most of the relevant precedents dealt with non-food items, there was no logical reason why they would not apply to food items as well.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considered the existing law on negligence and whether a manufacturer could owe a duty of care to a consumer when there was no contract between them.The Court had to consider whether the earlier approach in Mullen[7] meant that manufacturers generally owed no duty to consumers where there was no contractual relationship. The Court considered the earlier decision in Mullen[8] where the issue of a manufacturer’s responsibility to consumers had also arisen. The Court examined whether the principle from that case should prevent Mrs Donoghue from bringing a claim against Stevenson.

Therefore, Lord Atkin considered that the law should recognise a duty of care between people who are sufficiently closely and directly affected by another person’s actions. He developed the neighbour principle, under which a person should take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which could reasonably be expected to cause injury to another person who is closely and directly affected by those actions.

In this case, Stevenson manufactured the ginger beer knowing that it would ultimately be consumed by consumers. Because the bottle was opaque and sealed, the consumer could not reasonably inspect the contents before drinking it. Therefore, the manufacturer was in a position where harm to the consumer could reasonably be contemplated.The Court therefore rejected the idea that a contractual relationship was always necessary before a duty of care could arise. The relationship between the manufacturer and the ultimate consumer was sufficiently close for a duty of care to exist. This allowed Mrs Donoghue to establish a cause of action in negligence despite not having a contract with Stevenson.The concept of the case was concerning the law of negligence which at that time was very narrow and included some kind of contractual relationships and where there was a duty of care by Stevenson in absence of any contractual relations, contrary to the case law of Mullen.

Judgment and Ratio Decidendi

The House of Lords allowed Mrs Donoghue’s appeal and held that she had a valid cause of action against Stevenson. The Court recognised that a manufacturer could owe a duty of care to the ultimate consumer of a product even where there was no contractual relationship between the manufacturer and consumer.

The ratio decidendi of the case is not straightforward, but rather that a manufacturer owes a duty of care to the ultimate consumer where the product is intended to reach the consumer in the form in which it leaves the manufacturer, without a reasonable possibility of intermediate examination, and where the manufacturer can reasonably foresee that a lack of reasonable care could cause injury to the consumer.The principle was expressed through Lord Atkin’s neighbour principle which established that a person must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which can reasonably be foreseen as likely to injure a neighbour.A neighbour is classified as a person who is so closely and directly affected by an individual’s acts that it ought reasonably to have them in contemplation as being so affected, when directing one’s mind to the acts or omissions when called in question.Mrs Donoghue had therefore proved her assertions that she had a cause of action in law.

Critical Analysis

One of the legal implications of the case followed that the case law of Donoghue and Stevenson, crucial principles required to establish liability such as the duty of care and the neighbour principle got introduced.

One of the glaring aspects Uzodinma[9] noted was the stark contrast between the judgment of Lord Atkin and Lord Buckmaster. In these two judgments, there was a collision of the two principles, the law and justice, and we can see the rising complexities and which one comes first when it comes to protecting the rights of citizens and justice taking the “front seat”[10] instead of law emphasised that justice always wins even when contradictory to law.The decision had an important impact on the development of the law of negligence because it established that a duty of care could arise even without a contractual relationship. It also meant that manufacturers could owe a duty of care to consumers who used their products.

The neighbour principle therefore became an important principle in establishing liability in negligence. The interaction between manufacturers and consumers was no longer based only on contractual relations, as the relationship could also give rise to a duty of care.However, critics argue that the judgment may have expanded the concept of negligence too broadly, imposing a heavy burden on business and increasing potential liability of manufacturers.[11] However, manufacturers should be held responsible for the safety of their products.Although Uzodinma praises Donoghue and Stevenson in its advancement on the law of negligence,[12] Hutchinson[13] questions its importance. This is a wider societal viewpoint and speaks on the development of the law and conveys that even without Donoghue and Stevenson, the law of negligence would still have developed with the help of society,[14] although it is questionable if it would have developed in the way of the law or justice.

Smith and Burns[15] go further in emphasising the concept that negligence law would have developed anyway and describe the case as “liability to the law of negligence”[16] because of the Court’s reliance on the principle, particularly Lord Atkin’s neighbour principle, and that extending it to situations where the defendant merely failed to prevent harm has made negligence law too broad and unpredictable.Therefore, the interaction between law and justice becomes even more complex and they point out that here perhaps the use of justice in this case has softened the law.

Conclusion

The case of Donoghue and Stevenson is an important case in the development of the law of negligence. The case established that a contractual relationship does not always need to exist for a duty of care to arise. Mrs Donoghue was able to bring a claim against Stevenson even though she did not have a contract with him.

The primary outcome of this case was the neighbour principle coined by Lord Atkin, which summarised that the common rules of loving one’s neighbour applies too in law. Therefore, one must not injure one’s neighbour and must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which can reasonably be foreseen would be likely to injure a neighbour.The case therefore had an important impact on the development of negligence law and the concept of duty of care. However, the case also raises questions about whether the law of negligence became too broad and unpredictable. The interaction between law and justice remains important because the case demonstrates how the law can develop when there is a need to protect individuals from harm.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Table of Cases

Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562

George v Skivington (1869) 157 ER 448

Heaven v Pender (1883) 11 QBD 503

Mullen v AG Barr & Co Ltd (1929) SC 461

Winterbottom v Wright (1842) 10 M & W 109

Journal Articles

Hutchinson AC, ‘Some “What If” Thoughts: Notes on Donoghue v Stevenson’ (2014) 51(2) Osgoode Hall Law Journal 701

Smith JC and Burns P, ‘Donoghue v Stevenson: The Not So Golden Anniversary’ (1983) 46 Modern Law Review 147

Online Sources

Uzodinma E, ‘A Critical Analysis of the Tort of Negligence: A Case Study of Donoghue vs Stevenson’ (Legal Ideas Forum, 9 December 2023) https://legalideasforum.com/a-critical-analysis-of-the-tort-of-negligence-a-case-study-of-donoghue-vs-stevenson.html accessed 1 September 2026

[1] Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562.

[2] Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562,622.

[3] George v Skivington, (1869) 157 ER 448.

[4] Heaven v Pender (1883) 11 QBD 503.

[5] Mullen v AG Barr & Co Ltd (1929) SC 461.

[6] Winterbottom v Wright (1842) 10 M & W 109.

[7] Mullen (n5).

[8] Ibid.

[9] Emmanuel Uzodinma, ‘A Critical Analysis of the Tort of Negligence: A Case Study of Donoghue vs. Stevenson’ (Legal Ideas Forum, 9 December 2023) https://legalideasforum.com/a-critical-analysis-of-the-tort-of-negligence-a-case-study-of-donoghue-vs-stevenson.html accessed 1 September 2026.

[10] ibid

[11] ibid

[12] ibid

[13]  Allan C..Hutchinson “Some “What If” Thoughts: Notes on Donoghue v Stevenson.” Osgoode Hall LawJournal 51.2 (2014) : 701-712.

[14] ibid

[15] Smith, J. C., and Peter Burns,“Donoghue v. Stevenson: The Not so Golden Anniversary.” The Modern Law Review, vol. 46, no. 2, 1983, pp. 147–63. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/1095489. Accessed 1 Sept. 2026.

[16] Ibid

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top