Authored By: LUCY TUITAI
THE KENYA SCHOOL OF LAW
Case Name: DECRIMINALISATION OF ATTEMPTED SUICIDE IN KENYA: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF KENYA NATIONAL COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS & 2 OTHERS V ATTORNEY GENERAL & 2 OTHERS
Citation: Kenya National Commission on Human Rights v The Honorable Attorney General Constitutional Petition E045 of 2022 [2025} KEHC 6 (KLR)
Judgement delivered by the High Court at Nairobi on 9th of January 2025 by Justice Lawrence Mugambi.
Introduction
On 9th January 2025 the the High Court of Kenya confronted the constitutionality of criminalising attempted suicide under section 226 of the Penal Code. At the heart of the Petition was the question whether a person experiencing suicidal thoughts or attempting suicide should be treated as a criminal or as a person in need of medical, psychological and social intervention. Beyond the immediate question of whether attempted suicide should attract criminal liability, the case raises broader questions about the purpose of criminal law, the effectiveness of punishment as a deterrent, the stigma surrounding mental-health challenges and the ability of Kenyan law to evolve in response to contemporary social realities.
Facts of the case
The Petitioners instituted proceedings challenging the constitutionality of Section 226 of the Penal Code, as read with Section 36, which criminalized attempted suicide. They contended that the criminalization of attempted suicide violated various constitutional rights, including the rights guaranteed under Articles 27, 28, 43, 53 and 54 of the Constitution.
The Petitioners’ case was substantially found on the understanding that suicidal behavior is closely associated with mental-health conditions, psychological distress and various social and economic circumstances. They argued that instead of providing people experiencing suicidal thoughts with appropriate medical and psychological support, Section 226 subjected them to criminal punishment, thereby undermining their constitutional rights and further exposing them to stigma.
The First Petitioner further argued that the criminalization of attempted suicide was inconsistent with Kenya’s obligations under international human-rights instruments, including the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which Kenya had ratified. The Second Petitioner emphasized the stigmatizing effect of criminalization, arguing that the fear of prosecution could discourage persons experiencing mental-health difficulties from seeking professional assistance. The Third Petitioner relied on available research and reports on suicide to demonstrate the prevalence of the problem and argued that suicide is influenced by mental-health, psychological and societal factors. In his view, decriminalization would reduce stigma, improve access to mental-health services and create a more supportive environment for research and intervention.
The Respondent, together with the Fifth and Sixth Interested Parties, opposed the Petition. They challenged the jurisdiction of the High Court to determine the constitutionality of Section 226, arguing that the power to amend or repeal legislation belonged to Parliament. They further relied on the doctrine of separation of powers and pointed to previous attempts to amend the Penal Code as evidence that the issue had already been placed within the legislative process.
From the above background, the court identified the following principal issues for determination:
- Whether the Court had jurisdiction to determine the Petition, particularly considering: the doctrine of exhaustion of remedies; and the doctrine of separation of powers.
- Whether Section 226, as read with Section 36 of the Penal Code, was inconsistent with the Constitution.
- Whether the Petitioners were entitled to the reliefs sought.
Arguments
Petitioners’ arguments
The Petitioners argued that Section 226 was unconstitutional because it subjected people experiencing suicidal thoughts or attempting suicide to criminal sanctions instead of treating them as people requiring care and intervention. They contended that suicidal behavior is frequently associated with mental-health conditions and psychological distress and that criminalization consequently disproportionately affected persons with mental-health disabilities.
The Petitioners further argued that criminalization violated the right to human dignity under Article 28, the right to equality and freedom from discrimination under Article 27 and the right to the highest attainable standard of health under Article 43. They also relied on Kenya’s obligations under international and regional human-rights instruments, including the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
A further argument was that criminalization contributed to stigma. The Petitioners maintained that the possibility of arrest and prosecution could discourage individuals from disclosing suicidal thoughts or seeking medical and psychological assistance. Decriminalization, therefore, would facilitate access to healthcare, reduce stigma and enable greater research and public discussion on suicide prevention.
Respondents’ arguments
The Respondents challenged the Court’s jurisdiction to determine the matter. They argued that the Petitioners ought first to have pursued the legislative avenue available under Article 119 of the Constitution by petitioning Parliament to repeal or amend Section 226.
They also invoked the doctrine of separation of powers, arguing that the responsibility for changing legislation lay with Parliament and not the Judiciary. The existence of previous attempts to amend the Penal Code was relied upon to demonstrate that the issue was one properly belonging to the legislative process.
Jurisdiction: The doctrine of Exhaustion of Remedies and Separation of Powers
In determining whether it had jurisdiction, the Court relied on Article 165 of the Constitution, which sets out the jurisdiction of the High Court. Article 165(3)(d)(i) grants the High Court jurisdiction to determine the question of whether a right or fundamental freedom in the Bill of Rights has been denied, violated, infringed or threatened.
The Court also considered the meaning and limits of jurisdiction, including the principles discussed in R v Karisa Chengo & 2 Others [2017] eKLR. Since the Petition principally concerned the constitutionality of Section 226 of the Penal Code, the Court found that determining the constitutional validity of legislation fell within its jurisdiction.
The Court further considered the argument concerning exhaustion of remedies. The Respondents had argued that the Petitioners ought to have approached Parliament under Article 119 of the Constitution before approaching the Court. However, the Court considered evidence that the Ministry of Health had previously constituted a Mental Health Taskforce whose recommendations included the repeal of Section 226. The recommendation had not resulted in repeal of the provision.
Against this background, the Court found that requiring the Petitioners to pursue the same legislative avenue would not provide an effective alternative remedy. The objection based on exhaustion therefore failed.
The Court also rejected the argument based on separation of powers. Although Parliament has the legislative mandate to enact, amend and repeal laws, this does not prevent the Judiciary from exercising its constitutional mandate to determine whether legislation is consistent with the Constitution. The Court was therefore entitled to examine the constitutional validity of Section 226.
Constitutionality of Section 226
In determining the constitutionality of the impugned provision, the Court began with the constitutional approach to interpretation under Article 259. The Constitution is required to be interpreted in a manner that advances its purposes, values and principles, promotes the rule of law and contributes to good governance.
The Court recognized that constitutional interpretation requires a broad and purposive approach rather than the narrow interpretation ordinarily applied to legislation. It also considered the established principle that legislation enjoys a presumption of constitutionality and that the burden rests upon the party challenging the legislation to demonstrate its inconsistency with the Constitution.
The Court therefore considered both the purpose and effect of Section 226.
In examining the right to equality and freedom from discrimination under Article 27, the Court considered the position of people experiencing mental-health difficulties and the relationship between mental health and suicidal behavior. The Court also drew upon international human-rights instruments, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights.
The Court ultimately found that criminalizing attempted suicide had a discriminatory effect on people experiencing mental-health difficulties. It further found that the provision violated the constitutional protection of human dignity and the right to the highest attainable standard of health.
Final determination of the court
Section 226 of the Penal code was declared unconstitutional by the court, for violating Article 27, 28 and 43 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
Critical analysis of the case
The significance of the judgment extends beyond the repeal of a single criminal provision. It represents an important shift in the legal understanding of suicide in Kenya. The World Health Organisation (WHO) does not classify suicide itself as a mental-health disorder; however, it recognises that persons experiencing mental-health difficulties are at greater risk of suicide. Suicide therefore remains an important consideration in discussions on mental health. The WHO Mental Health Action Plan 2013–2020 envisions a world in which mental health is valued, promoted and protected, persons affected by mental disorders are able to exercise their human rights and access appropriate health and social care, free from stigmatisation and discrimination.[1] One of its policy recommendations was to “decriminalize suicide, suicide attempts and other acts of self-harm.”[2] This supports the broader shift reflected in the judgment from punishment towards protection and care.
There are, however, opposing views on whether criminalisation serves as a deterrent or whether it ultimately aggravates the problem. One argument in favour of criminalisation is that the threat of punishment may discourage individuals from attempting suicide. A qualitative study on perspectives towards suicidal behaviour in Kenya similarly found that some participants considered the possibility of serious legal consequences capable of discouraging an individual from attempting suicide.[3] However, this argument assumes that a person contemplating suicide is necessarily making a rational and calculated assessment of legal consequences. Where suicidal behaviour occurs in the context of severe psychological distress, the fear of prosecution may be outweighed by the individual’s perception of their circumstances. Criminalisation may therefore deter some individuals while simultaneously discouraging others from seeking assistance because of the fear of arrest or prosecution.[4]
The WHO further notes that criminalisation can perpetuate an environment of blame and stigma towards persons who attempt suicide while failing to adequately recognise the social, economic and cultural factors associated with suicide and suicide attempts[5]. Criminalisation may also make it more difficult to collect accurate data and plan appropriate interventions because individuals may not seek help, while families or healthcare providers may be reluctant to report suicide attempts.[6] This raises a broader question about the purpose of criminal law. If its objective is ultimately to protect life, it is necessary to consider whether punishment advances that objective. A person experiencing suicidal distress may benefit more from immediate medical, psychological and social intervention than from the threat of imprisonment.
Suicide is also linked to multiple and intersecting social, economic, cultural and psychological factors, including stressful life events, loss of livelihood, work or academic pressure, relationship breakdowns, discrimination and other life crises.[7] These challenges affect people across different backgrounds and circumstances. Regardless of whether a person’s distress arises from circumstances beyond their control or from experiences to which they may have contributed, they remain entitled to dignity, care and an opportunity to recover.
This is particularly relevant in the context of the social pressures of modern life. Individuals increasingly navigate economic pressures, professional expectations and personal difficulties without meaningful spaces in which they can express vulnerability. Behind these expectations, however, remain human beings with emotions, fears and limitations. Psychological suffering should therefore attract the same compassion extended to other forms of human suffering. Society readily recognises that a person suffering from a physical illness requires treatment and that someone facing financial hardship may require assistance. There is no logical reason why psychological suffering should receive less compassion, particularly when no reasonable person chooses to be physically, financially or psychologically unwell.
The judgment is therefore significant not only because it removes criminal liability for attempted suicide, but because it creates greater space for suicide to be addressed through healthcare, awareness and social support. Decriminalization can contribute to reducing stigma and encouraging individuals to seek help without fear of legal consequences. It also aligns with the broader recognition of mental health within international human-rights and development frameworks, including the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, which recognize health and well-being as development priorities.[8]
CONCLUSION
Ultimately, the judgment represents an important shift in the role of law in responding to suicide. Rather than treating a person experiencing suicidal distress primarily as an offender, the law is better positioned to recognise that person as someone in need of protection, care and support. However, decriminalisation should not be viewed as an end in itself. Its meaningful impact will depend on whether it is accompanied by greater awareness, accessible mental-health services, social support and effective suicide-prevention measures. The judgment is therefore not simply a departure from criminalisation, but an opportunity to reconsider whether the law is serving the people and circumstances it was created to govern.
REFERENCE(S):
Table of Cases
Kenya National Commission on Human Rights & 2 Others v Attorney General & 2 Others [2025] KEHC 6 (KLR)
R v Karisa Chengo & 2 Others [2017] eKLR
Table of Legislation
The constitution of Kenya, 2010
Penal Code (Cap 63)
Bibliography
Ongeri L and others, ‘Perspectives on Reasons for Suicidal Behaviour and Recommendations for Suicide Prevention in Kenya: Qualitative Study’ (2023) 9 BJPsych Open e38, doi:10.1192/bjo.2023.7
United Nations, Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (2015).
World Health Organization, Comprehensive Mental Health Action Plan 2013–2030 (WHO 2021).
World Health Organization, WHO Policy Brief on the Health Aspects of Decriminalization of Suicide and Suicide Attempts (2023).
[1] World Health Organization, Comprehensive Mental Health Action Plan 2013–2030 (WHO 2021) <https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240031029 > accessed 13 September 2026
[2] ibid
[3] Linnet Ongeri and others, ‘Perspectives on Reasons for Suicidal Behaviour and Recommendations for Suicide Prevention in Kenya: Qualitative Study’ (2023) 9 BJPsych Open e38 < https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/D90D7351683653A4D834CDDD6134E6CB/S2056472423000078a.pdf/div-class-title-perspectives-on-reasons-for-suicidal-behaviour-and-recommendations-for-suicide-prevention-in-kenya-qualitative-study-div.pdf > accessed 13 September 2026.
[4] ibid
[5] World Health Organization, WHO Policy Brief on the Health Aspects of Decriminalization of Suicide and Suicide Attempts (2023)
[6] ibid
[7] ibid
[8] United Nations, Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (2015).