Home » Blog » Bhe and others v Khayelitsha and others

Bhe and others v Khayelitsha and others

Authored By: Tshepang Shekgola

Stellenbosch University

  1. Case Citation and Basic Information

Full Case Name: Bhe and Others v Magistrate, Khayelitsha and Others

Citation: 2005 (1) SA 580 (CC); 2005 (1) BCLR 1 (CC)

Court: Constitutional Court of South Africa

Date of Decision: 15 October 2004

Bench Composition: Langa DCJ (majority), Ngcobo J (minority)

  1. Introduction

Bhe v Magistrate, Khayelitsha is a landmark South African Constitutional Court case that struck down apartheid-era succession laws which excluded Black women and children from inheriting property. The case challenged section 23 of the Black Administration Act 38 of 1927 and the customary law rule of male primogeniture, which only allowed the eldest male descendant to inherit. The Court found these laws violated the rights to equality and dignity under the Constitution.

  1. Historical Context

During colonial and apartheid South Africa, Black people were governed by segregatory laws which promoted subordination of black people holistically but also the inner workings of black tribes such as the regulation of the family structures. Indigenous Customary Law already had a informal foundation of patriarchy amongst African families however the Apartheid state regime cemented the unjust patriarchal system by legalising and entrenching patriarchy into South African Law.

Under African Customary Law the Principle of male primogeniture was upheld. This principle reiterates that when the family head dies the eldest son steps into his shoes inheriting all his property and control over the family in exclusion of women and extra-marital children. Further context to note is that women in customary family structures were called “perpetual minors” under the permanent guardianship of a male relative or husband.

The Apartheid system entrenched patriarchy through the passing of Laws such as the Black Administration Act 38 of 1927, Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987, Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965, Regulations for the Administration and Distribution of the Estates of Deceased Blacks and lastly the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998.

The primary rules fueling into the principle of primogeniture were laws that regulated intestate succession of black people. After apartheid, the Intestate Succession Act regulated intestate succession of all other races except black people who were subjected to the Black Administration Act. The BAA mandated that if a Black person died intestate their estate was to be regulated by African Customary Law. The rule of primogeniture fueled this as it barred women, extra-marital children and younger children from inheriting.

  1. Facts of the Case

Ms Bhe was in a life partnership with the deceased meaning they were unmarried and the deceased died intestate therefore the administration of his estate was regulated by section 23 of the Black Administration Act meaning under African Law and custom dominated by the principle of male primogeniture. This would mean the two female children (minors) of Ms Bhe and the deceased would be barred from inheriting as only male relative successors could inherit. As the deceased had no sons the allocation of succession worked up the family tree entitling his father to inherit the entire estate.

The father wanted to sell, without notice, the entire immovable property in order to pay for the expenses incurred due to the funeral. Ms Bhe and her children lived in this house and were indigent therefore the sale of this property would render them homeless. A point to note is that although the couple was unmarried even if they were married the two children and their mothered would still not inherit as barred by the Black Administration Act and the principle of male primogeniture.

Therefore to challenge these unjust laws Ms Bhe obtained two interdicts and argued the laws regulating and giving effect to Male primogeniture be it directly or indirectly were unconstitutional, violating the right to equality and dignity as entrenched in the Constitution.

She challenged section 23 of the Black Administration Act and Regulation 2(e) which made customary law the default law for intestate estate of black people and section 1(4)(b) of the Intestate succession Act which outed black people from Intestate Succession Act which regulated intestate estate of all other races in South Africa excluding black people.

  1. Legal Issues

Issue 1: Whether section 23 of the Black Administration Act, read with Regulation 2(e), is inconsistent with the Constitution?

Issue 2: Whether the rule of male primogeniture is inconsistent with the Constitution?

Issue 3: Whether section 1(4)(b) of the Intestate Succession Act is inconsistent with the Constitution?

  1. Arguments Presented

6.1 Applicants’ Arguments

The applicants argued that the laws were racist and sexist, violating equality and dignity rights under the Constitution. They perpetuated unfair discrimination on grounds of race, gender, and birth. The limitation on these rights could not be justified under section 36 of the Constitution. The rule of male primogeniture discriminated unfairly against women and extra-marital children.

6.2 Respondents’ Arguments

The Minister supported the challenge and conceded the laws were unconstitutional. The deceased’s father opposed but made no submissions. The Minister raised concerns about the appropriate remedy, particularly regarding polygynous marriages and the impact on customary law.

  1. Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

Majority Judgment (Langa DCJ)

The majority agreed and upheld Ms Bhe’s critiques declaring that the laws were indeed racist and sexist, violating the right to equality and dignity. These laws further subjected females into a status of subordination and did not uphold the best interests of the children. The limitation of these rights was also not justified under section 36 of the Constitution as this was not a reasonable and justifiable reason to limit rights.

The majority agreed that the provisions must be struck down however in this case the courts could not develop African customary law as it is living law and there was insufficient evidence on how it operates relating to such matters. Therefore to avoid a lacuna upon striking out the provisions the viable solution was through the legislature developing an entire statute to regulate such matters.

The immediate solution was that section 1(4)(b) of the Intestate Succession Act, which had previously excluded Black estates from its application was struck out meaning Intestates estates of black people could be regulated by the Act like everyone else. This Act was gender neutral therefore excluded male primogeniture. Section 1 of the Act regulating the order of inheritance puts the spouse and the descendants of the deceased whether marital or extra-marital as the primary heirs.

Minority Judgment (Ngcobo J)

The minority agreed with the striking out of section 23 and all the laws enabling the rule of primogeniture as unconstitutional but objected the remedy of striking out the customary law through application of common law and the Intestate Succession Act.

They wanted customary law to be developed as per section 39(2) of the Constitution to remove gender discrimination instead of being struck out by the Intestate Succession Act. They wanted both Customary Law and the Intestate Succession Act to operate simultaneously therefore giving the family a choice in systems regulating administration of intestate estate and the Magistrate on a case by case basis deciding which system is fairer considering the Constitution, assets, contributions, the best interests of the children and the family structure.

They argued that the Intestate Succession Act is based on a nuclear family structure therefore not made for polygomous and extended family structures practiced amongst African people. They upheld that the Act does not impose duty to support dependants as customary law does and may destroy the family unit and that most African people wanted this structure and lastly that customary law itself is evolving.

Ngcobo J further argued that the Constitution expressly guarantees the survival of an evolving customary law. He noted that people who live by indigenous law and custom are entitled to be governed by indigenous law. He was concerned that the application of the Intestate Succession Act only would lead to the obliteration of customary law, which would be contrary to the constitutional protection of customary law. He proposed that the Magistrate should hold an inquiry to determine which system was fair, just, and equitable in the circumstances of each case.

  1. Judgment and Ratio Decidendi

The Decision

  1. Section 23 of the Black Administration Act was declared unconstitutional and invalid.
  2. The Regulations were declared invalid.
  3. Section 1(4)(b) of the Intestate Succession Act was declared unconstitutional and invalid.
  4. The rule of male primogeniture was declared unconstitutional as applied to inheritance.
  5. The Intestate Succession Act applies to all estates formerly governed by section 23.
  6. Nonkululeko and Anelisa Bhe were declared the sole heirs.
  7. Charlotte Shibi was declared the sole heir.

Ratio Decidendi

Section 23, Regulation 2(e), Section 1(4)(b) and the rule of primogeniture are struck down as unconstitutional due to violating the rights to equality, dignity and the best interest of the children and they were declared an unjustifiable limitation of rights under section 36 of the Constitution. The provisions of the Black Administration Act were not holistically struck out however the provisions in Bhe were struck out and the remaining sections were repealed under the Repeal of the Black Administration Act and Amendment of Certain Laws Act 28 of 2005.

  1. Critical Analysis

9.1 Significance

Bhe is one of the most significant South African constitutional decisions. It dismantled apartheid-era succession laws that had survived the transition to democracy. The judgment affirmed that the Constitution applies to all law, including customary law.

9.2 Implications

Women and extra-marital children could now inherit equally. The judgment protected vulnerable families from homelessness. The immediate interim remedy was the Intestate Succession Act until the permanent legislative remedy was passed in 2010, the Reform of Customary Law of Succession Act. The new Act subjected all intestate customary estates to the Intestate Succession Act and stretched its scope to include extended and polygymous family structures through being inclusive to polygomos spouses, a child’s portion including all descendants, and including structures such as woman-to-woman marriages and child bearing unions (seed raisers).

9.3 Critical Evaluation

From observation of the minority rule I would say they indirectly wanted to uphold the rule of Primogeniture through application of customary law and the elective process. In a Patriarchal system the head of the house or rather male relative’s voices are often louder and due to economic and financial dependency of women and children it becomes difficult to go against the male and communities where these discriminatory values are entrenched. Although the Magistrate should elect a fair decision on a case by case basis this becomes clumsy and risks precedent being set. Courts are not fortune tellers therefore what is considered right today might have sour effects in future.

  1. Conclusion

Bhe v Magistrate, Khayelitsha struck down apartheid-era succession laws that excluded Black women and children from inheriting property. By declaring section 23 of the Black Administration Act, Regulation 2(e), and section 1(4)(b) of the Intestate Succession Act unconstitutional, and by striking down the rule of male primogeniture, the Constitutional Court affirmed the supremacy of the Constitution. The immediate remedy applied the Intestate Succession Act to all estates, while the 2009 Reform of Customary Law of Succession Act provided a permanent legislative framework. The case remains a powerful reminder of the Constitution’s commitment to equality, dignity, and the protection of vulnerable groups.

Bibliography 

Case law 

Bhe and Others v Magistrate, Khayelitsha and Others 2005 (1) SA 580 (CC).

Legislation

Black Administration Act 38 of 1927.

Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987.

Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965.

Regulations for the Administration and Distribution of the Estates of Deceased Blacks GN R200 of 1987.

Reform of Customary Law of Succession and Regulation of Related Matters Act 11 of 2009.

Repeal of the Black Administration Act and Amendment of Certain Laws Act 28 of 2005.

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top