Home » Blog » Pervez Elahi v. Election Commission of Pakistan, etc

Pervez Elahi v. Election Commission of Pakistan, etc

Authored By: Batool Rehman Qureshi

Beaconhouse College Programme

Case Name: Pervez Elahi v Election Commission of Pakistan (PLD 2024 SC 571)

Supreme Court of Pakistan

Date of decision: 26 January 2024

Bench Composition

  • Mr Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah
  • Mr Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail
  • Mr Justice Athar Minallah

Introduction

Pervez Elahi v Election Commission of Pakistan1 reached the Supreme Court on appeal from an order of the Lahore High Court dated 13 January 2024. Pervez Elahi had argued before the Lahore High Court that the rejection of his nomination papers for a seat in the Punjab Provincial Assembly was unfair. However, his writ petition (a formal written request made to a court to remedy a legal violation or enforce a fundamental right)2 was dismissed.

The case concerns the Elections Act 2017 and the law surrounding it. It is noteworthy because it established a strong “pro-enfranchisement” approach (referring to the granting of voting rights)3, which carries particular significance for political elections.

Facts of the Case

The petitioner, Pervez Elahi, filed nomination papers to contest the 2024 elections. On 30 December 2023, the returning officer (the official responsible for ensuring that elections are effectively administered)4 rejected his nomination papers. He appealed to the election appellate tribunal, but the appeal also failed. He then approached the Lahore High Court, where his writ petition (n 2) was dismissed by a full bench. Civil Petition No. 181 of 2024 was therefore filed in the Supreme Court, challenging that dismissal.

The Lahore High Court held that the rejection of the petitioner’s nomination papers was valid because they did not satisfy certain requirements of the Elections Act 2017. Two main grounds led to the rejection.

The first ground was based on Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(b), under which a candidate must open or designate an exclusive bank account solely for election expenses. A statement of that account, with all entries from a week before the election schedule, must be attached to the nomination paper.

The second ground was based on Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(d), under which the candidate must submit, along with the nomination form, a statement of the assets and liabilities of his family (himself, his spouse and his dependent children) as they stood on the most recent 30 June, in this case 30 June 2023.

Legal Issues

The Supreme Court had to decide whether Pervez Elahi’s nomination papers violated Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(b) and s 60(2)(d), and thereby whether the High Court’s decision was valid.

The first question before the Court was whether Pervez Elahi had failed to designate an exclusive bank account solely for election expenses. The second was whether the petitioner had failed to include all of his family’s assets and liabilities as required by Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(d).

Respondents’ Arguments

The respondents argued that, under Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(b), Elahi was required to open a separate bank account for each constituency, since he had submitted nominations for NA-64, NA-69, PP-32 and PP-34.5

Furthermore, the respondents argued that, under Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(d), the petitioner had failed to declare an asset, a 10-marla plot of land in Phalia, Mandi Bahauddin, Punjab, in his statement of assets. This failure to meet the statutory requirements, they said, justified the rejection of his nomination papers.

Petitioner’s Arguments

Pervez Elahi’s position was that Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(b) did not require a separate account for each seat, but one account dedicated to election expenses, regardless of the number of seats he was contesting.

As to the ground raised under Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(d) concerning the 10-marla property, the petitioner denied having purchased the property.

The Court’s Judgment

The judgment was delivered by Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah, who placed great emphasis on the importance of democracy, the purpose for which elections are held. A commitment to securing democracy through a pro-enfranchisement approach ran deep through the reasoning and outcome of the case. The aim was to ensure that voters have the greatest possible freedom to vote for whom they choose, which can only be achieved if nomination papers are not rejected excessively.

On the first ground, the Court held that Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(b) does not require separate accounts for each seat, but one account for all election expenses, regardless of the number of seats a candidate is contesting. The Court examined the purpose of the provision and found that it exists only to ensure compliance with Elections Act 2017, s 132(3), which fixes the maximum amounts that election expenses may not exceed. Such compliance can be controlled and monitored through a single dedicated bank account covering all seats. The Court therefore held this ground to be legally unsustainable.

On the second ground, the Court held, first, that the returning officer had conducted no summary inquiry into whether the petitioner actually owned the land, particularly after he had denied buying it. In any event, the 10-marla property was purchased on 30 November 2023, whereas Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(d) requires assets and liabilities to be stated as they stood on the preceding 30 June, that is, 30 June 2023. As the property was acquired after that date, it was not required to be included among the assets in Form B. The Court therefore held that this objection, too, was legally unsustainable.

The judgment also criticised the Lahore High Court for exceeding its jurisdiction and for failing to consider Elections Act 2017, s 62(9). That provision states that a returning officer must not reject a nomination paper on account of a minor or technical defect, and that in such cases the candidate may be given an opportunity to correct it.

The Supreme Court thus rejected both objections after examining and interpreting the Elections Act 2017, and agreed with the petitioner’s arguments. The appeal was allowed and the necessary relief granted, as the shortcomings in Pervez Elahi’s nomination papers were considered minor and technical defects.

Ratio Decidendi

Three binding principles emerged from Pervez Elahi v Election Commission of Pakistan (PLD 2024 SC 571), forming the ratio decidendi of the judgment:

  1. One exclusive bank account is sufficient for multiple seats under Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(b).
  2. Under Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(d), the statement of assets must reflect the position as it stood on the preceding 30 June.
  3. In the case of a minor or technical error, the returning officer must give the candidate an opportunity to correct it so that the nomination can proceed, as provided by Elections Act 2017, s 62(9).

Analysis

The judgment placed incredibly strong emphasis on the rights of voters as well as those of candidates, linking back to fundamental constitutional rights such as the right to vote under Article 51(2) of the Constitution and the right to contest elections under Article 17(2) of the Constitution.

However, the decision on Elections Act 2017, s 60(2)(b) was reached by interpreting the words of Parliament. This is arguably not fully democratic, given that Parliament is the most democratic body, and the words of Parliament should therefore be read literally to prevent judicial law-making. On the other hand, as a matter of practicality, managing multiple bank accounts for the number of seats contested is very challenging and may lead to errors in details and handling, owing to the difficulty of monitoring each account.

Furthermore, the Court’s pro-enfranchisement approach is deeply democratic in nature, putting voters and the people first, as must be done in any well-functioning democracy.

An issue that does arise from this case, however, is the intervention of the judiciary not only in the executive sphere, since voting is directly linked to politics and government, but also in the legislative sphere, through its interpretation of Parliament’s words, which is now binding on all future cases. The case therefore raises the question of separation of powers and whether it truly exists in Pakistan.

Further, I believe the main issue was whether electoral integrity should take precedence over electoral inclusion. Courts must safeguard the integrity and transparency of elections, but at the same time they must ensure that voters have a wide choice through the inclusion of the maximum number of nominees. The biggest question, then, is whether the Court managed to pass a judgment that preserves both electoral integrity and electoral inclusion.

I believe the Court’s decision may have favoured electoral inclusivity, by securing the pro-enfranchisement approach and keeping democracy alive through prioritising the rights of voters and of those taking part in the election. As regards electoral integrity, many points of contention may pass under the label of mere technical defects, creating a higher chance of potential unfairness. On a wider scale, however, multiple sections of the Elections Act 2017 exist solely to ensure and preserve fairness and transparency, so electoral integrity is not compromised by this decision.

Conclusion

This landmark judgment in Pervez Elahi v Election Commission of Pakistan (PLD 2024 SC 571) fundamentally reshaped an important aspect of the nomination of candidates for elections by promoting an extremely beneficial pro-enfranchisement approach. By holding that one account suffices for multiple seats, that assets are to be declared as at the preceding 30 June, and that minor or technical defects must be curable, the Court gave priority to electoral inclusion while, in my view, leaving electoral integrity largely intact. The decision nevertheless leaves open important questions about the limits of judicial interpretation and the separation of powers in Pakistan.

Footnote(S):

1 Pervez Elahi v Election Commission of Pakistan (PLD 2024 SC 571)

2 College AL, ‘Asian Law College’ (Asian Law College) <https://alc.edu.in/blog/what-is-writ-petition-how-can-you-file-one-in-the-court> accessed 31 August 2026

3 ‘What Is Enfranchisement? Simple Definition & Meaning’ (LSD.Law) <https://definitions.lsd.law/enfranchisement> accessed 31 August 2026

4 Electoral Commission, ‘Returning Officer – role and responsibilities’ (Guidance for Returning Officers administering a Senedd election, 30 April 2026) https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/guidance-returning-officers-administering-a-senedd-election/returning-officer/returning-officer-role-and-responsibilities accessed 31 August 2026

5 ‘Parvez Elahi out of Election Race, Wife Gets Go-Ahead for Polls’ (Geo News, 13 January 2024) <https://www.geo.tv/latest/526883-parvez-elahi-thrown-out-of-election-race-qaisara-given-go-ahead-for-polls> accessed 31 August 2026.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top