Authored By: Nonkululeko Mathe
University of South Africa (UNISA)
- Case Citation and Basic Information
This is an application matter between Vodacom (Pty) Limited (hereinafter referred to as the Applicant) and Nkosana Kenneth Makate (hereinafter referred to as the 1st Respondent) as well as Shameel Joosub N.O (hereinafter referred to as the 2nd Respondent).
Neutral Citation: Vodacom (Pty) Ltd v Makate and Another {2025} ZACC 13
Coram: Maya CJ, Madlanga ABCJ, Majiedt J, Mthopo J, Mhlantla J, Rogers J, Seegobin AJ, Theron J, Tshiqi J.
Judgment: Madlanga ABCJ (unanimous)
Heard on: 21 November 2024
Decided on: 31 July 2025
- Brief Introduction
The 1st Respondent, Nkosana Makate, was employed as a trainee accountant by the Applicant. On or about 2000, the 1st Respondent was in a long-distance relationship, he could not be with his partner regularly. Until he conceptualized a service called “Please Call Me” which allowed a user with zero airtime to send a text request for someone else to call them back at no cost.
The 1st Respondent who was guided by his mentor, initiated the written idea and pitched it to Philip Geissler, Vodacom’s Director of Product Development and Management. The oral agreement concluded by Makate and Geissler was that Vodacom would test the product and should the product be commercially viable, then the 1st Respondent would receive a share of the proceeds, with terms of the exact compensation to be negotiated at a later stage.
On or about 2001, Vodacom launched the “Please Call Me” product, generating billions in revenue, but no compensation was rendered to the 1st Respondent. On or about 2008 to 2026, the 1st Respondent instituted legal actions and sued Vodacom after failed negotiations.
- Facts of the case
The 1st Respondent, Mr. Makate, was in a long-distance relationship and faced communication hurdles due to his girlfriend who could not afford airtime.
He designed a feature enabling users with no airtime to send a free automated text request prompting another user to call them back.
The 1st Respondent pitched the proposal to Vodacom’s former Director of Product Development, Philip Geissler, in terms of which the former Director proposed that he will communicate with his manager for advice. They therefore concluded an oral agreement in terms of which they agreed that Vodacom would trial the concept and negotiate a fair revenue share for Makate if the ‘Please Call Me” product proved successful.
- Legal Issues
The fundamental legal issue in the “Please Call Me” litigation revolves around contractual validity, prescription of debt, the limits of corporate execution discretion as well as procedural fairness in appellate judgments,
The key legal issues in the matter are as follows:
- Whether Vodacom’s former Director. Of Product Development had the actual or ostensible authority to bind the company to an oral agreement or rather a promise of compensation for an innovative idea.
- Whether Makate’s claim had expired under the three-year prescription limit.
- Whether the legal duty of the parties to negotiate reasonable compensation was in good faith and the bounds of the Vodacom’s CEO role as a dreadlock-breaker when negotiations failed.
- Arguments presented
Nkosana Makate’s arguments:
- Existence of a verbal agreement: Makate argued that he initiated the “Please Call Me” concept on or about 2000 when he was employed as a junior finance employee at Vodacom, he therefore concluded a verbal agreement with Vodacom’s former director of product development, Philip Geissler, who negotiated that a compensation would be awarded from the revenue.
- Breach of contract: The 1st Respondent asserted that Vodacom had breached the agreement concluded by refusing to negotiate compensation or honor the said deal after the “Please Call Me” product had generated massive commercial success.
- Revenue share duration and quantum: The 1st Respondent was initially entitled to a 5 percent share of the total revenue generated by the ‘Please Call Me” product. He argued that limiting compensation to a brief five-year period was arbitrary, as the product had generated revenue for nearly two decades.
Vodacom’s Arguments
- Lack of authority: Vodacom argued that the former director of product development had no actual or ostensible authority to bind the company to a revenue-sharing contract.
- Originality and Ownership: The Applicant had contested the originality of the ‘Please Call Me” idea, suggesting that the concept was similar to certain patent features and further that any work done by an employee during employment belonged to the company.
- Reasonableness of compensation: This follows the Constitutional Court’s directive to negotiate in good faith, the Applicant’s CEO determined that an award of 47 million was a reasonable compensation, which the Makate had rejected claiming to be a tiny fraction of the total revenue generated.
- The Applicant further argued against the perpetual or inflated revenue models by maintaining that the high demands lacked proper contractual or equitable basis.
- Court’s Reasoning and Analysis
In the July 2025 Vodacom v Makate judgment, the Constitutional Court made reasoning based on the basis that the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) had committed a total failure of justice by failing to properly consider evidence, substitute its own order without a cross-appeal as well as violating procedural fairness.
The Core Reasoning of the Constitutional Court (2025)
- Failure to assess evidence: The Constitutional Court reasoned that the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) had failed to provide adequate reasons for its judgment, disregarded or became unaware of certain material facts and issues in its presence and failed to assess evidence that was adduced by the parties.
- Uncritical acceptance: The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) had accepted Makate’s submissions without acting within the scope of its authority and subsequently failed to offer a proper legal explanation or justification of doing so.
- Lack of jurisdiction for substitution: The Constitutional Court (CC) held that since Mr. Makate had failed to file a cross-appeal against the High Court’s order, then the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) lacked the legal jurisdiction to substitute its own new order in favor of the 1st
- Violation of fair hearing rights: The SCA’S refusal and incomplete reasoning deprived Vodacom of a fair hearing and breached the rule of law, leading the Constitutional Court to uphold Vodacom’s appeal and remit the matter back to the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) for a complete rehearing by a different panel.
Background on the 2016 merits:
In the 2016 fundamental judgment, the court’s reasoning mainly focused on contract and agency:
- Binding agreement: It ruled that an oral agreement to agree had existed between Mr. Makate and Mr. Geissler, who both had ostensible authority to bind the company.
- Compensation mechanism: The Court ordered Vodacom to negotiate a reasonable compensation amount in good faith or grant the CEO an opportunity to determine if they reached a deadlock.
- Judgment and Ratio Decidendi
In the Vodacom v Makate case, the Ratio Decidendi refers to the key legal principle or reasoning behind the court’s decision. The court found that Vodacom was liable to compensate the 1st Respondent, Mr. Makate, for the “Please Call Me” product, in terms of which he claimed to have invented and proposed to Vodacom. The court also held that Vodacom had breached an agreement with Mr. Makate to act in good faith and that the 1st Respondent was entitled to a reasonable compensation for the product he initiated.
The court further held that Vodacom had implemented the “Please Call Me” service based on Makate’s proposal and that Vodacom had failed to compensate the 1st Respondent adequately for the service he proposed. As a result of the above reasoning, the court had ordered that Vodacom should enter into a binding agreement and negotiations with Mr. Makate, to determine a reasonable compensation amount. The court further set a precedent for the protection of intellectual property rights and the obligation of companies to fairly compensate individuals for their innovations and contributions.
- Critical Analysis
The Makate v Vodacom (Pty) Ltd judgment centered on ostensible authority as well as the conclusion that a valid agreement between Mr. Makate and Vodacom to negotiate compensation existed and had been breached. Mr. Makate had initiated the “Please Call Me” product in which Vodacom had never introduced or was unaware of it. He initiated the product in terms of which he aimed to ensure correspondences between individuals who are distant from each other and who cannot afford to have airtimes to use the product at a zero fee. Vodacom had generated a total revenue of billions but failed to compensate Mr. Makate for launching his own idea. With the abovementioned points, a breach of agreement to compensate and to act in good faith was made.
- Conclusion
The appeal was upheld in favor of the 1st Respondent, Mr. Makate.
The court ordered Vodacom to negotiate with Mr. Makate in good faith to determine a reasonable amount of compensation.
- Reference(S):
SAFLLI