Home » Blog » Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors

Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors

Authored By: Tamarauemomoemi Emmanuel Egbebo

Niger Delta University, Wilberforce Island Bayelsa state

I. CASE CITATION AND BASIC INFORMATION

Full Case Name: Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors

Citation: Appeal No. SC/CV/899/2025

Court: Supreme Court of Nigeria (Holden at Abuja)

Date of Decision: Friday, 20th February 2026

Bench Composition (Seven-member panel): Kudirat M.O. Kekere-Ekun, CJN; John Inyang Okoro, JSC; Helen Moronkeji Ogunwumiju, JSC; Adamu Jauro, JSC; Jummai Hannatu Sankey, JSC; Obande Festus Ogbuinya, JSC; Stephen Jonah Adah, JSC (lead judgment).

Nature of Proceeding: Constitutional Reference under Section 295(3) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended).

II. INTRODUCTION

Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors is a landmark constitutional reference decision of the Supreme Court of Nigeria, delivered in February 2026. It definitively resolved a jurisdictional conflict between State High Courts and the National Industrial Court of Nigeria (NICN) regarding defamation claims in employment contexts.1

For years, different divisions of the Court of Appeal had delivered conflicting judgments on whether the NICN possessed exclusive jurisdiction over defamation claims connected with labour and employment matters. At least thirteen decisions of the Court of Appeal had addressed the issue, with seven adopting a restrictive approach and six adopting a liberal interpretation of Section 254C of the Constitution.2 The Supreme Court was, thus, called upon to provide authoritative guidance on the proper interpretation of Section 254C, which confers exclusive jurisdiction upon the NICN in civil causes and matters relating to labour, employment, trade unions, and industrial relations.3

The case involved a defamation claim arising from communications made by a former employee and her spouse following the end of her employment. The central question before the Court was whether such a claim fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of the NICN or remained justiciable before the State High Court.4

III. FACTS OF THE CASE

The 1st Appellant, Emma Elegbe, was employed by the 1st Respondent, HP International Schools Limited (operating as Hampton Preparatory School in Ikoyi, Lagos), and served as Head of School until her resignation on 1st May 2020.5 The 2nd Appellant, Lou Elegbe, is her husband, and their children attended the 1st Respondent’s school. The 2nd to 4th Respondents were directors of the 1st Respondent.6

Following the end of her employment, the 1st Respondent circulated an email to parents on 2nd May 2020, informing them of the 1st Appellant’s resignation and alleging that she had resigned “as a result of an ongoing investigation.” The 1st Appellant, aggrieved by what she considered a damaging insinuation against her character, sent an email dated 4th May 2020 to the same parents, explaining the circumstances surrounding her resignation. The 2nd Appellant, who was never employed by the 1st Respondent, also communicated with some parents via WhatsApp on 2nd May 2020 in response to enquiries arising from the 1st Respondent’s email.

Consequent upon these events, the Respondents commenced Suit No. LD/ADR/5052/2020 at the High Court of Lagos State, seeking declarations that the publications were defamatory, orders for retraction, a perpetual injunction, and costs.

Upon being served, the Appellants challenged the jurisdiction of the trial court, contending that the suit ought to have been commenced before the NICN, as the defamation claim was inextricably linked to the 1st Appellant’s employment relationship. In a ruling delivered on 24th September 2024, the trial court dismissed the objection and assumed jurisdiction. Aggrieved, the Appellants appealed to the Court of Appeal. Faced with conflicting decisions from various divisions of the Court of Appeal on the jurisdictional question, the Appellants invoked Section 295(3) of the Constitution, and the Court of Appeal referred three questions to the Supreme Court for authoritative determination.7

IV. LEGAL ISSUES

The Supreme Court was called upon to determine three questions referred by the Court of Appeal:8

Issue 1: Whether, by virtue of Section 254C of the Constitution, the jurisdiction of the High Court of Lagos State is affected or excluded in respect of a claim in defamation arising from, relating to, or connected with labour and employment.

Issue 2: Whether, having regard to Section 254C, the mere termination of an employment relationship is sufficient to vest the High Court of Lagos State with jurisdiction to entertain a claim in defamation arising from or connected with labour and employment.

Issue 3: Whether an alleged defamatory publication emanating from an employee’s work relationship, but made by a person who is not an employee, can properly be entertained by the High Court of Lagos State, having regard to Section 254C.

V. ARGUMENTS PRESENTED

The parties and the amici curiae took sharply divergent positions on the proper reach of Section 254C, as set out below.

5.1 Appellants’ Arguments

The Appellants contended that the Respondents’ entire claim was confined within the four walls of the 1st Appellant’s employment, and that Section 254C must be interpreted literally to include any cause or matter arising from, relating to, or connected with labour and employment.9 They argued that defamation arising from an employment relationship constitutes a distinct species of tort rooted in the workplace context, and that the NICN possesses jurisdiction even where the employment relationship is no longer subsisting.10 Regarding the 2nd Appellant, they argued that jurisdiction under Section 254C is a matter of subject-matter competence, and that the class of claims contemplated therein includes defamation arising from employment, even where such claims involve persons without a direct employment relationship.11

5.2 Respondents’ Arguments

The Respondents argued that a literal construction of Section 254C would introduce ambiguity and distortion into the allocation of judicial powers, undermining the carefully demarcated jurisdiction of the superior courts.12 They maintained that a rigid literal interpretation would inevitably result in an influx of general civil claims into the NICN, diluting its specialised character as a court established to determine labour and employment disputes.13 The Respondents contended that the claim was one founded in defamation, a tort injurious to reputation, and not a claim arising from any contract or condition of employment.14 They further argued that a defamatory publication does not automatically fall within the jurisdiction of the NICN merely because it references a person’s former employment.15

5.3 Arguments of Amici Curiae

The Court invited four amici curiae to address the questions. Abimbola Akeredolu, SAN, submitted that the NICN is a specialised court and its jurisdiction is not a “catch-all” jurisdiction capable of accommodating every claim merely because it arises from or is connected with labour or employment. Inam Wilson, SAN, urged the Court to employ the ejusdem generis rule, contending that the construction of Section 254C(1)(a) should be limited to core labour and employment matters which can only be resolved by having recourse to labour or employment-related statutes or principles. Dr. Oladapo Olanipekun, SAN, expressed a diverging view, submitting that where defamation arises squarely from, is connected with, or is incidental to labour, employment, or workplace relations, jurisdiction should vest in the NICN. Prof. Emmanuel A. Kenen, Esq., also advocated for the application of the ejusdem generis rule, arguing that the tort of defamation does not fall within any of the matters expressly enumerated under Section 254C(1)(a)-(m) of the Constitution.

VI. COURT’S REASONING AND ANALYSIS

The Supreme Court delivered a unanimous decision, with the lead judgment authored by Stephen Jonah Adah, JSC.16 The Court’s reasoning proceeded in seven stages.

6.1 Constitutional Interpretation: The Court reaffirmed that the Constitution, being the grundnorm, is sui generis and must be interpreted in line with principles suitable to its spirit and character.17 A liberal and purposive approach should be adopted, giving words their ordinary grammatical meaning unless a narrower interpretation would better carry out the Constitution’s objects and purposes.18

6.2 Historical Context of the NICN: The Court undertook a detailed historical analysis, tracing the NICN’s evolution from the Trade Disputes Decree No. 7 of 1976 through to its elevation to a superior court of record by the Third Alteration Act No. 3 of 2010. The Court held that the effect of the Third Alteration was to properly situate the NICN as a superior court of record, but it was not the intention of the legislature to expand its jurisdiction to include any civil wrong that could, however remotely, be related to or connected with labour or employment.

6.3 The Ejusdem Generis Rule: A central pillar of the Court’s reasoning was the application of the ejusdem generis rule of interpretation.19 The Court held that the comprehensive list of items set out in sub-paragraphs (1)(b)-(m) provides the specifics of the NICN’s jurisdiction, and that the words in subsection (1)(a), “labour, employment, trade unions, industrial relations and matters arising from workplace”, must be interpreted in the context of the entire provision.20 The construction of these words should be limited to core labour and employment matters which can only be resolved by having recourse to labour or employment-related statutes or principles.

6.4 Determining Jurisdiction from the Claim: The Court reaffirmed that jurisdiction is determined by the claimant’s claim as disclosed in the Writ of Summons and Statement of Claim, and not by the defence. Examining the Respondents’ Statement of Claim, the Court found that their cause of action was founded squarely on defamation, a tort injurious to reputation.21 The mere fact that the alleged defamatory publication made reference to the 1st Appellant’s resignation did not, without more, transmute the claim into a labour or employment dispute.22

6.5 Main Claim versus Ancillary Claim: The Court drew a crucial distinction between cases where defamation is the principal claim and cases where defamation arises as an ancillary claim to a labour or employment dispute.23 The Court held: “Defamation, it should be noted remains a distinct tortious cause of action, historically and jurisprudentially rooted in the general law of tort. The mere fact that an allegedly defamatory statement is made in the context of employment ordinarily, does not without more transmute such a claim into a labour or employment dispute.”24

The NICN may assume jurisdiction over a defamation claim only where the defamation arises as an ancillary claim to a labour or employment matter and is “inextricably tied or bound up with the main claims.”

6.6 The Proper Test: The Court held that the decisive consideration is the proper characterisation of the cause of action.25 The controlling inquiry is whether the claim arises directly from the exercise of rights and obligations under a contract of employment or pertains to matters within the narrowly defined scope of labour relations, employment rights, and working conditions as envisaged under Section 254C.

6.7 Policy Considerations: The Court held that to subsume general tortious claims under the exclusive jurisdiction of the NICN would occasion an unwarranted influx of civil causes into a specialised labour forum, diluting its character and converting it into a court of general civil jurisdiction, contrary to the constitutional design.26

VII. JUDGMENT AND RATIO DECIDENDI

7.1 The Decision

The Supreme Court resolved the constitutional reference as follows:27

Question 1: Whether, by virtue of Section 254C of the Constitution, the jurisdiction of the High Court of Lagos State is affected or excluded in respect of a claim in defamation arising from, relating to, or connected with labour and employment.

Answer: NO. The Supreme Court held that the High Court of Lagos State retains its competence. Jurisdiction is not stripped merely because a defamatory statement has a factual connection to labour or workplace dynamics.

Question 2: Whether, having regard to Section 254C, the mere termination of an employment relationship is sufficient to vest the High Court of Lagos State with jurisdiction to entertain a claim in defamation arising from or connected with labour and employment.

Answer: NO. The single act of termination does not automatically settle the jurisdictional question. Courts must analyse the true substance and character of the lawsuit rather than looking at the employment status alone.

Question 3: Whether an alleged defamatory publication emanating from an employee’s work relationship, but made by a person who is not an employee, can properly be entertained by the High Court of Lagos State, having regard to Section 254C.

Answer: YES. The National Industrial Court’s exclusive jurisdiction does not extend to non-employee third parties. The State High Court is the proper forum to entertain claims involving outside actors.

7.2 Ratio Decidendi

The binding legal principles established by this landmark decision may be stated as follows:28

  1. Jurisdiction is determined by the substance of the claim: The court must examine the nature of the principal claim and the reliefs sought to determine the appropriate forum.
  2. Defamation as a principal claim: A claim founded on defamation, being a distinct tortious cause of action, does not fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the NICN merely because it bears some factual connection to employment.
  3. The “inextricably intertwined” test: The NICN may assume jurisdiction over a defamation claim only where the defamation arises as an ancillary claim to a labour or employment matter and is inextricably tied to the main claim.
  4. Application of the ejusdem generis rule: The words in Section 254C(1)(a) must be interpreted in the context of the entire provision and limited to core labour and employment matters.
  5. Termination of employment is not dispositive: The decisive factor remains the proper characterisation of the cause of action.
  6. Non-employee third parties: A defamatory publication made by a person who is not in an employment relationship with the claimant falls outside the exclusive jurisdiction of the NICN.

The Court ordered that the parties shall bear their respective costs and commended the amici curiae for their well-researched contributions.

VIII. CRITICAL ANALYSIS

8.1 Significance of the Decision

This decision represents a watershed moment in Nigerian jurisprudence, definitively resolving a long-standing jurisdictional conflict that had plagued the administration of justice.29 The case is significant for several reasons. First, it settles the conflict between the two lines of Court of Appeal decisions, the restrictive approach and the liberal approach, by adopting a balanced, purposive approach that distinguishes between principal and ancillary claims.30 Second, the decision reinforces the constitutional architecture that establishes specialised courts with defined jurisdictions, preserving the integrity of the specialised labour court system while maintaining the general jurisdiction of State High Courts.31 Third, the “inextricably intertwined” test articulated by the Court offers a clear framework for determining the appropriate forum for claims that touch upon both employment and tort law.32

8.2 Implications and Impact

8.2.1 For Litigation Practice: The decision provides certainty for litigants and their counsel, reducing the likelihood of preliminary jurisdictional battles that delay the determination of substantive disputes.33

8.2.2 For the National Industrial Court: The decision preserves the NICN’s specialised character, preventing it from being overwhelmed by a flood of general civil claims.34

8.2.3 For State High Courts: The decision affirms the continued relevance and jurisdiction of State High Courts over tortious claims, even where such claims have some connection to employment.35

8.2.4 For the Development of Labour Law: The decision encourages the development of a coherent body of labour jurisprudence by ensuring that core labour and employment matters are determined by the specialised court with expertise in this area.36

8.3 Critical Evaluation

8.3.1 Strengths of the Reasoning: The Court’s application of the ejusdem generis rule provides a principled basis for interpretation, avoiding the extremes of both a rigid literal approach and an overly expansive approach.37 The detailed historical analysis of the NICN’s evolution strengthens the persuasive force of the Court’s reasoning.38 The “inextricably intertwined” test offers a practical, workable framework that can be applied by lower courts in future cases.39

8.3.2 Potential Weaknesses: While the “inextricably intertwined” test is conceptually sound, its application in practice may prove challenging, requiring a fact-intensive inquiry that may itself give rise to litigation.40 Additionally, the decision may incentivise claimants to frame their claims in tort rather than employment law in order to access the State High Courts, though the Court’s emphasis on examining the substance rather than the form of the claim mitigates this risk.41

IX. CONCLUSION

Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors is a landmark decision of the Supreme Court of Nigeria that definitively resolves the jurisdictional conflict between State High Courts and the National Industrial Court regarding claims in defamation arising in employment contexts.42 The Court’s core holding is that a claim founded on defamation as a principal claim does not fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the NICN merely because it bears some factual connection to employment.43 The NICN may assume jurisdiction over a defamation claim only where the defamation arises as an ancillary claim to a labour or employment matter and is inextricably intertwined with the main claim.44

The decision is significant for its principled application of the ejusdem generis rule, its detailed historical analysis of the NICN’s evolution, and its practical framework for determining jurisdiction.45 The lasting impact of this decision will be felt across the Nigerian legal system, providing much-needed certainty for litigants and legal practitioners, preserving the integrity of the specialised labour court system, and maintaining the constitutional balance in the allocation of judicial powers.46

X. BIBLIOGRAPHY

Primary Sources

  1. Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors (2026) SC/CV/899/2025 (Supreme Court of Nigeria) available at <https://www.supremecourt.gov.ng/judgment-delivered/273> accessed 29th August 2026.
  2. Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended)

Secondary Sources

  1. Babalakin and Co Legal Practitioners, ‘Defamation and Employment Law: Supreme Court Clarifies the Jurisdiction of The National Industrial Court in Emmanuel Elegbe & Anor. V. HP International Schools Limited Ors.’ (Blog, 16 April 2026) <https://blog.babalakinandco.com/category/articles/page/3/> accessed 27 August 2026
  2. Banwo & Ighodalo, ‘Supreme Court resolves jurisdictional conflicts over employment-related torts: Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors’ (Grey Matter, 24 March 2026) <https://www.banwo-ighodalo.com/grey-matter/supreme-court-resolves-jurisdictional-conflicts-over-employment-related-torts-emma-elegbe-anor-v-hp-international-schools-limited-3-ors/> accessed 27 August 2026
  3. Esher & Makarios Law, ‘Case Review: Emma Elegbe & Anor v HP International Schools Limited & Ors. – Appeal No. SC/CV/899/2025’ (23 April 2026) <https://www.esherandmakarioslaw.com/resources/case-review-emma-elegbe-anor-v-hp-international-schools-limited-ors-appeal-no-sc-cv-899-2025> accessed 27 August 2026
  4. Lexology, ‘Supreme Court resolves jurisdictional conflicts over employment-related torts: Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors’ (24 March 2026) <https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=c34e739f-413f-431a-86a4-bd9953bfd880> accessed 27 August 2026
  5. Olaniwun Ajayi LP, ‘Case Alert: The Supreme Court Clarifies the Jurisdictional Boundary Between Employment Disputes and Defamation Claims’ (March 2026) <https://www.olaniwunajayi.net/blog/case-alert-the-supreme-court-clarifies-the-jurisdictional-boundary-between-employment-disputes-and-defamation-claims/> accessed 27 August 2026
  6. Stephen Legal, ‘Elegbe v. HP Intl Schools Ltd: Supreme Court Decides Jurisdiction of the National Industrial Court in Defamation Cases’ (Case Law, 21 March 2026) <https://stephenlegal.ng/> accessed 27 August 2026
  7. The Guardian, ‘Supreme court sets limits for NIC’s jurisdiction in defamation cases’ (3 March 2026) <https://guardian.ng/news/supreme-court-sets-limits-for-nics-jurisdiction-in-defamation-cases/> accessed 27 August 2026
  8. The HR Anchor, ‘Supreme Court Clarifies Industrial Court’s Role in Defamation Claims’ (4 March 2026) <https://thehranchor.ng/> accessed 27 August 2026

FOOTNOTE(S):

1 See Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors (2026) SC/CV/899/2025 (Supreme Court of Nigeria) available at <https://www.supremecourt.gov.ng/judgment-delivered/273> accessed 29th August 2026.; Babalakin and Co Legal Practitioners, ‘Defamation and Employment Law: Supreme Court Clarifies the Jurisdiction of The National Industrial Court in Emmanuel Elegbe & Anor. V. HP International Schools Limited Ors.’ (Blog, 16 April 2026) available at <https://www.banwo-ighodalo.com/grey-matter/supreme-court-resolves-jurisdictional-conflicts-over-employment-related-torts-emma-elegbe-anor-v-hp-international-schools-limited-3-ors/> accessed 27 August 2026.

2 Banwo & Ighodalo, ‘Supreme Court resolves jurisdictional conflicts over employment-related torts: Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors’ (Grey Matter, 24 March 2026) <https://www.banwo-ighodalo.com/> accessed 27 August 2026.

3 Lexology, ‘Supreme Court resolves jurisdictional conflicts over employment-related torts: Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors’ (24 March 2026) < https://www.lexology.com/> accessed 27 August 2026.

4 Stephen Legal, ‘Elegbe v. HP Intl Schools Ltd: Supreme Court Decides Jurisdiction of the National Industrial Court in Defamation Cases’ (Case Law, 21 March 2026) < https://stephenlegal.ng/ > accessed 27 August 2026.

5 Ibid

6 Ibid

7 Ibid (n 4) see conflicting decisions from Dr. Emmanuel Sebastian Akpan v. University of Calabar (2016) LPELR-41242(CA); Bisong v. University of Calabar (2016) LPELR-41246(CA) and Medical and Health Workers Union of Nigeria (MHWUN) v. Dr. Alfred Ehigiegba (2018) LPELR-44972(CA)

8 Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors (2026) SC/CV/899/2025 (Lead Judgment of Adah, JSC) see (n 1).

9 Babalakin and Co Legal Practitioners (n 1)

10 Ibid

11 Ibid

12 Banwo & Ighodalo (n 2)

13 Ibid

14 Stephen Legal (n 4).

15 Banwo & Ighodalo (n 2).

16 Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors (2026) SC/CV/899/2025 (Supreme Court of Nigeria) available at <https://www.supremecourt.gov.ng/judgment-delivered/273> accessed 29th August 2026.

17 Emma Elegbe (n 14).

18 The Guardian, ‘Supreme court sets limits for NIC’s jurisdiction in defamation cases’ (3 March 2026) < https://guardian.ng/news/supreme-court-sets-limits-for-nics-jurisdiction-in-defamation-cases/ > accessed 27 August 2026

19 Ibid

20 Emma Elegbe (n 14).

21 The Guardian (n 18).

22 Emma Elegbe (n 14).

23 The Guardian (n 18).

24 Emma Elegbe (n 14).

25 The Guardian (n 18).

26 Emma Elegbe (n 14).

27 Emma Elegbe & Anor v. HP International Schools Limited & 3 Ors (2026) SC/CV/899/2025 (Supreme Court of Nigeria) available at <https://www.supremecourt.gov.ng/judgment-delivered/273> accessed 29th August 2026.

28 The Guardian (n 18).

29 Banwo & Ighodalo (n 2).

30 ibid

31 The Guardian (n 18). The Guardian (n 18). The Guardian (n 18).

32 ibid

33 Babalakin and Co Legal Practitioners (n 1).

34 The Guardian (n 18). The Guardian (n 18). The Guardian (n 18). The Guardian (n 18).

35 Banwo & Ighodalo (n 2).

36 Babalakin and Co Legal Practitioners (n 1).

37 Emma Elegbe (n 14).

38 ibid

39 The Guardian (n 18).

40 ibid

41 Banwo & Ighodalo (n 2).

42 The Guardian (n 18).

43 Ibid

44 Ibid

45 Emma Elegbe (n 14).

46 Babalakin and Co Legal Practitioners (n 1).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top