Home » Blog » MILITARY GOVERNOR, LAGOS STATE & ORS (APPELLANT) V CHIEF EMEKA ODUMEGWU OJUKWU (RESPONDENT) (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt. 18) 621

MILITARY GOVERNOR, LAGOS STATE & ORS (APPELLANT) V CHIEF EMEKA ODUMEGWU OJUKWU (RESPONDENT) (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt. 18) 621

Authored By: AROYEHUN, BARAKAT AYOMIDE

University of Ilorin

CASE Name: AROYEHUN, BARAKAT AYOMIDE MILITARY GOVERNOR, LAGOS STATE & ORS (APPELLANT)

V

CHIEF EMEKA ODUMEGWU OJUKWU (RESPONDENT)

(1986) 1 NWLR (Pt. 18) 621

Division: Supreme Court of Nigeria

Date of Judgment: 14th February 1986

Case Number: (SC. 241/1985)

Before: Andrews Otutu Obaseki, J.S.C. (Presided)

             Kayode Eso, J.S.C. (Read the Lead Judgment)

             Muhammadu Lawal Uwais, J.S.C. 

             Saidu Kawu, J.S.C. 

             Chukwudifu Akunne Oputa, J.S.C.

INTRODUCTION

Of what use is the law in a country where the government itself refuses to obey the order of a court and thereby outrightly neglecting the rule of law? This was a major question in the case of Military Governor of Lagos state v Ojukwu, therefore, the decision of the court in answering this question would go ahead to set the standard for the practice of rule of law in Nigeria. This case came on appeal before the supreme court of Nigeria. It started at the Lagos State High Court, and the mater involved a dispute over the possession of a residential property. Though simple, this matter eventually gave way for the court to make one of the most groundbreaking decisions on rule of law on Nigeria.

FACTS OF THE CASE

In this case, the respondent, Chief Emeka Odumegwu Ojukwu’s family occupied a property at No. 29, Queens drive Ikoyi, Lagos. Initially, he was the applicant at the High Court of Lagos where he sought an interim injunction to halt the efforts of the Military Government of Lagos State, the Commissioner of Police Lagos State, and the Attorney-General Lagos state, from ejecting him as well as the members of his family from No. 29, Queen’s Drive, Ikoyi.

The trial judge refused to grant the injunction on the grounds that the respondent has no legal right to or interest in the property because during the trial, it was discovered that the house belonged to Ojukwu transport company owned by his late father. And it was based on this fact that the learned trial judge concluded that the house was abandoned and therefore refused to grant the injunction.[1]

Chief Ojukwu then proceeded to the Court of Appeal with Ojukwu transport company having joined the suit as an interested party. The Court of Appeal ruled against the Government of Lagos State and the Commissioner of Police Lagos State Command. It must be noted that while the case was pending in the High Court, the Lagos State Government, without an order of Court, forcibly ejected Chief Ojukwu from the property in dispute (29, Queens Drive, Ikoyi.) meanwhile, The Court of Appeal had earlier granted an interim injunction to stop the ejection of the respondent.

The Lagos State government and the commissioner of police, Lagos Command then filed for an appeal to the Supreme Court against the order of the court of appeal without carrying out the order of the Court of Appeal to return the possessory right of the property to the respondent. And then sought an order of the Supreme Court praying for a stay of the execution of the decision of the Court of Appeal pending the determination of the suit at the Supreme Court.

ISSUES

The Supreme Court identified and addressed the following issues:

Issue 1

Whether a party (particularly a government) in breach of an order of Court can be granted a stay of execution of Court decision.

Issue 2

Whether a government can resort to self-help while the subject matter of the self-help is still pending in a Court of law.

ARGUMENTS

The appellants argued that an order of interlocutory injunction or stay of execution cannot be given to reverse an action that had already been done.  This argument was backed with the fact that the ejection had been done prior to the institution of the case at the Court of Appeal during the hearing at The High Court. They also argued for a return to the status quo ante litem (the situation before the lawsuit) while contending that the property was an abandoned property given the fact that during the civil war, Ojukwu had left the country and had only returned to the house after receiving a full pardon from the government.  The appellant informed the court that they were not aware of the respondents’ occupation of the property for about 10 months after his return and that is the reason the letter that was written to eject him was written after 10 months.

On the other hand, the respondents contended that the state’s appeal and application for stay of execution were purely delay tactics and the ground for appeal was manifestly unarguable. Also, the respondent counsel argued that the executive arm of the government used force to ‘resolve’ a matter that was already in pending determination in court. The learned counsel asserted that the government could not utilize force in creating for itself, a favourable situation and then turn around to ask equity and the Supreme Court to protect that unlawfully created situation as ‘he who comes to equity must come with clean hands. The respondent also claimed that he was in peaceful occupation of the property for a period of 10 months which he paid 90,000 as the cost incurred for the period the property remained unoccupied.

COURT ANALYSIS

The Court defined status quo as the state of the property prior to the institution of the action at the High Court of Lagos. The court however did not specifically agree or disagree with the Court of Appeal on whether there was a peaceable status quo of the property prior to the suit. While adding that preserving any property in status quo presupposes the existence of an actual, peaceable, uncontested status quo and therefore, a trespasser cannot create a status quo in respect of a property as held in Thompson v. Park[2]. However, the court held that since the lower court did not find the respondent to be a trespasser nor did he break and enter the property the status quo to be preserved is the peaceable possession of the property by Ojukwu pending the determination of the substantive suit at the high court

The concept of self-help was then examined and following the Black’s law dictionary, was defined as: – “Taking an action in person or by a representative with legal consequences, whether the action is legal or not; for example, a “self-help eviction” may be a landlord’s removing the tenant’s property from an apartment and locking the door against the tenant.”

The court opined that under Sections 4,5 and 6 of the Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1979[3], ‘the Executive, the Legislature and the Judiciary are equal partners in the running of a successful Government. None of the three organs of Government must exist in sabotage of the other or else there is chaos or there may be no Federal Government and executive lawlessness tantamount to a deliberate violation of the Constitution, and it is much more serious and profound if such lawlessness takes place in a Military Administration. The fact that Section 6 of the 1979 Constitution is left extant by the Military Administration is the clearest indication against rule by tyranny. The court was guided by the judgement in Daniel v. Ferguson.[4] 

JUDGEMENT AND RATIO DECIDENDI

The Supreme Court held that with the contempt of the court of appeal still subsisting, it will be inequitable for the court to give consideration to the application of the applicants and so, the application was dismissed and the government was ordered to seek possession at a competent court if it so wishes.[5]

The court per Obaseki, J.S.C. went further to condemn the rule of self-help by force stating that once a matter has arisen and it’s been brought to a court, it is the duty of the government to allow the court to run its full course and the court expects utmost respect of the law from the government itself.

Finally, Uwais, J.S.C. adds that it should be stressed that it is matter of grave concern that the Military Governor of Lagos should be seen to disregard a lawful order by a Court of Law. Such attitude towards court orders by the government can lead to a loss of trust in courts by the citizens and that would result in anarchy in replacement of rule of law.

CRITICAL ANALYSIS

This case is significant as Nigeria’s foundational authority on the rule of self-help and disregard for orders given by the court with emphasis on the fact that the government itself is not above the law.

It has influenced the court in another case[6] where, a state Governor tried to rely on his statutory power of revocation under the Land Use Act to reclaim land and hand it to another party, using force to take possession. The Supreme Court, drawing on the case of Ojukwu, held that even a valid legal power cannot be enforced through coercion, a party must still go through the courts rather than act unilaterally

Its major impact has been seen on the issue of self-help especially by bodies of authority as numerous cases have relied on the decision of the court in Ojukwu’s case. Additionally, the obiter made by Eso J.S.C. on rule of law: To use force to effect an act and while under the marshall of that force, seek the Court’s equity, is an attempt to infuse timidity into Court and operate a sabotage of the cherished rule of law. It must never be!”[7]  has not only been relied upon in courts but has also become a staple in Nigerian Legal Education in depicting the true essence of the rule of law and checks and balances within the organs of government.

This decision is doctrinally sound however; the real question lies in whether the principle has had real enforcement teeth as there are still numerous cases of parties flouting court orders with little to no consequence. This is a classic case of ‘the law as it is and the law as it should be’.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the key takeaway from this case is that the order of the law is supreme over all citizens and the government. The lasting impact of this is that it remains a go to authority for testing peoples conduct against the rule of law, the fact that it is applicable beyond public disputes to even disputes between private entities as seen in Osho’s case[8]. Looking ahead, its value lies in repeatedly invoking it by the civil societies, courts and legislature, since a law cannot enforce itself, the gap between the law as it is and as it ought to be can only be bridged by the continuous effort of courts and legal practitioners to ensure that it remains a benchmark against disregard of court order, self-help and anarchy.

BIBLIOGRAPHY 

Table of Cases

Daniel v. Ferguson (1891) 2 Ch 27 

Governor of Lagos State v Ojukwu (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt 18) 621 (SC)

Osho v Foreign Finance Corporation (1991) 4 NWLR (Pt 184) 157 (SC)

Thompson v. Park (1944) 2 All E.R. 477 .

Legislation

Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1979

Secondary Sources

Nigeria Legal Information Institute, ‘Military Governor, Lagos State & Others V Chief Emeka Odumegwu Ojukwu (Sc. 241/850) [1986] NGSC 13 (14 February 1986) https://nigerialii.org/akn/ng/judgment/ngsc/1986/13/eng@1986-02-14 accessed 28 August 2026.

[1] Nigeria Lepal Information Institute, ‘Military Governor, Lagos State & Others V Chief Emeka Odumegwu Ojukwu (Sc. 241/850) [1986] NGSC 13 (14 February 1986) https://nigerialii.org/akn/ng/judgment/ngsc/1986/13/eng@1986-02-14 accessed 28 August 2026.

[2] Thompson v. Park  (1944) 2 All E.R. 477 .

[3] Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1979.

[4] Daniel v. Ferguson (1891) 2 Ch 27  (per Kay, LJ. at 30). 

[5]Governor of Lagos State v Ojukwu (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt 18) 621 (SC).

[6]Osho & Anor v. Foreign Finance Corporation & Anor (1991) 4 NWLR (Pt. 184) 157.

[7] Ojukwu (n 5).

[8] Osho (n 6).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top