Home » Blog » MANOHAR LAL SHARMA VS UNION OF INDIA (PEGASUS SPYWARE CASE)

MANOHAR LAL SHARMA VS UNION OF INDIA (PEGASUS SPYWARE CASE)

Authored By: Kamireddy Sai Nikhitha

Sri Padmavathi Mahila Visvavidyalayam, Department of Law, Tirupati

  1. TITLE OF THE CASE : 

MANOHAR LAL SHARMA VS UNION OF INDIA (PEGASUS SPYWARE CASE)

       2. CITATION : 

(2021) 6 SCR 1066 

  1. COURT AND BENCH : 

Supreme Court of India, held by three judge bench . The three judge honourable bench is by Chief  Justice N.V.Ramana , Justice Surya Kant and Justice Hima Kohli . 

  1. DATE OF JUDGEMENT: 

The judgement held on 27th October, 2021 

  1. AREA OF INTEREST :

The present judgment falls within the interdisciplinary fields of Constitutional Law, Cyber Law, Privacy Law, and Information Technology Law. It primarily examines the scope of the  fundamental right to privacy under Article 21 in the context of digital surveillance and the use of  sophisticated spyware by the State. The case explores the constitutional balance between  individual privacy, freedom of speech and expression, national security, and the Government’s  surveillance powers. It also highlights the importance of judicial oversight, transparency, and  accountability in the exercise of surveillance powers. In an era where digital communication and  online platforms have become an integral part of daily life, this judgment is of immense legal and  contemporary significance as it reinforces constitutional safeguards against arbitrary State  surveillance while recognizing the legitimate interests of national security. 

  1. REASONS FOR SELECTION : 

The Pegasus Spyware Case (Manohar Lal Sharma v. Union of India & Ors.) was selected  because it is one of the most significant constitutional cases addressing digital privacy and State  surveillance in India. The case raises important legal questions regarding the extent of the  Government’s surveillance powers, the protection of citizens’ fundamental right to privacy under Article 21, and the constitutional limits on the use of advanced surveillance technologies. It also  examines the delicate balance between national security and individual liberty, which is a recurring  issue in modern constitutional jurisprudence. The judgment reaffirms the principles laid down in  Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India (2017) and emphasizes that surveillance  measures must satisfy the tests of legality, necessity, proportionality, and procedural safeguards.  The case was further chosen because of its continuing relevance to contemporary legal debates on  digital privacy, government traceability, encrypted communications, data protection, and judicial  oversight in the digital era. Its implications extend beyond the Pegasus allegations and contribute  significantly to the development of privacy and cyber law in India 

  1. FACTS OF THE CASE: 

∙ In 2019, it was alleged that the Pegasus spyware developed by NSO Group was used to  surveil WhatsApp users, including Indian journalists, activists, and public figures.  ∙ In July 2021, the Pegasus Project published reports alleging that several Indian citizens,  including journalists, politicians, and constitutional functionaries, were potential targets of  Pegasus spyware.  

∙ Multiple writ petitions were filed before the Supreme Court seeking an independent  judicial investigation into the alleged surveillance by the Union of India.  

∙ The petitioners argued that the alleged use of Pegasus violated the right to privacy under  Article 21, freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), and could have a  chilling effect on democratic freedoms.  

∙ The Union of India filed only a limited affidavit, denying the allegations but refusing to  disclose whether Pegasus had been used, citing national security concerns.  ∙ The Supreme Court held that the government’s refusal to provide a clear response prevented  effective judicial review and that national security cannot be used as a blanket shield  against judicial scrutiny.  

∙ On 27 October 2021, the Supreme Court constituted an independent Technical Committee,  supervised by Justice R.V. Raveendran, to investigate the allegations. This appointment  formed the core outcome of the case.

  1. BACKGROUNDS FACTS OF THE CASE: 

∙ Facebook’s 2019 lawsuit against NSO Group in the United States.  

∙ NSO Group’s claim that Pegasus is sold only to governments.  

∙ The publication of the Pegasus Project by an international consortium of media  organizations and Amnesty International.  

∙ Parliamentary debates during the 2021 Monsoon Session and statements made by the  Information Technology Minister.  

∙ The names of all alleged surveillance targets and petitioners.  

∙ The detailed composition of the Technical Committee and the dates of its hearings,  extensions, and submission of its report.  

  1. THE CORE LEGAL ISSUE:

Whether the alleged use of the Pegasus spyware by the Union of India for surveillance of  journalists, activists, politicians, and other citizens violates the fundamental right to privacy  guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India?  

Whether the alleged surveillance using Pegasus has a chilling effect on the freedom of  speech and expression and the freedom of the press guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) of  the Constitution?  

Whether the Union of India can refuse to disclose information regarding the alleged use of  Pegasus by invoking the ground of national security, without providing sufficient  justification to the Court?  

Whether the Supreme Court, in the exercise of its powers under Article 32 of the  Constitution, should constitute an independent technical committee to investigate the  allegations of unlawful surveillance?  

Whether the surveillance, if conducted without adherence to the procedure established by  law under the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885, the Information Technology Act, 2000, and  constitutional safeguards, is arbitrary and unconstitutional? 

     10. JUDGEMENT ANALYSIS: 

Applications of laws in case :

  1. Constitution of India

 Article 14 – Right to Equality 

∙ Guarantees equality before the law and protection against arbitrary State  action 

∙ The Court held that any surveillance measure must not be arbitrary and must  satisfy constitutional standards. 

 Article 19(1)(a) – Freedom of Speech and Expression 

∙ Protects the freedom of speech and the freedom of the press. 

∙ The Court observed that unlawful surveillance of journalists, activists,  lawyers, and political opponents could create a chilling effect on free speech  and democratic participation. 

 Article 21 – Right to Life and Personal Liberty 

∙ Protects the fundamental right to privacy as recognised in Justice K.S.  Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017). 

∙ The Court held that digital surveillance directly interferes with an individual’s  privacy and must satisfy constitutional safeguards 

.Article 32 – Right to Constitutional Remedies 

∙ Empowers the Supreme Court to enforce fundamental rights’ 

∙ Exercising this power, the Court constituted an independent Technical  Committee to investigate the Pegasus allegations.

  1.  Indian Telegraph Act, 1885

 Section 5(2) 

∙ Permits lawful interception of communications only in the interests of: o Sovereignty and integrity of India, 

o Security of the State, 

o Friendly relations with foreign States, 

o Public order, or 

o Preventing incitement to an offence. 

∙ Such interception must follow the procedure established by law and cannot  be exercised arbitrarily. 

  1.  Information Technology Act, 2000 

 Section 69 

∙ Authorises the Central or State Government to intercept, monitor, or decrypt  electronic information for specified public purposes, including national  security and public order. 

∙ The exercise of this power is subject to statutory procedure and constitutional  limitations. 

 Information Technology (Procedure and Safeguards for Interception,  Monitoring and Decryption of Information) Rules, 2009 

∙ Prescribe the procedure, authorisation, review mechanism, and safeguards  governing electronic surveillance under Section 69. 

∙ These Rules were relevant in assessing whether any alleged surveillance  complied with due process. 

  1. Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 

Although not directly challenged in the Pegasus proceedings, these Rules were referred to in the  wider context of digital governance and surveillance. 

∙ The Government relied on existing statutory mechanisms to argue that adequate legal  safeguards already existed.

Key Judicial Precedents:

Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India (2017) 

∙ Recognised privacy as a fundamental right under Article 21. 

∙ Established the four-part test of legality, legitimate aim, necessity and proportionality, and  procedural safeguards, which guided the Court’s approach in Pegasus. 

People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL) v. Union of India (1997) 

∙ The Supreme Court upheld the validity of telephone interception under Section 5(2) of the  Telegraph Act but prescribed procedural safeguards against arbitrary surveillance. ∙ The Pegasus judgment relied upon these principles while examining the legality of digital  surveillance. 

Application of the Privacy Principles Established in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of  India (2017) 

The Supreme Court relied heavily on the principles laid down in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.)  v. Union of India (2017), which recognised the Right to Privacy as a fundamental right under  Article 21 of the Constitution.The Court observed that Pegasus spyware is capable of gaining  complete access to an individual’s mobile device, including messages, emails, photographs,  contacts, microphone, camera, and location data. Such surveillance has the potential to intrude into 

every aspect of an individual’s private life and therefore constitutes a serious interference with  personal liberty and human dignity. 

Referring to the principles in Puttaswamy, the Court reiterated that any restriction on the right to  privacy must satisfy the constitutional requirements of: 

∙ Legality – there must be a valid law authorising surveillance; 

∙ Legitimate State Aim – surveillance must pursue a lawful objective, such as national  security; 

∙ Necessity and Proportionality – the measure adopted must be necessary and  proportionate to the objective sought to be achieved; and 

∙ Procedural Safeguards – adequate safeguards must exist to prevent arbitrary or excessive  surveillance. 

The Court held that these constitutional safeguards continue to apply even where surveillance is  claimed to be necessary for national security.

Limits of the Government’s National Security Defence 

The Government argued that further disclosure was not possible because it would affect national  security. The Supreme Court accepted that national security is a legitimate constitutional concern, but clarified that it cannot be used as a blanket defence against judicial review. The Court observed  that if every allegation involving surveillance could be rejected solely on the basis of national  security, executive actions affecting fundamental rights would become immune from  constitutional scrutiny. Such an approach would be inconsistent with constitutional  democracy.The Court therefore held that while sensitive operational details need not always be  disclosed publicly, the Government must still provide sufficient material to enable the Court to  determine whether surveillance has been carried out in accordance with the Constitution and the  law. Mere assertions of national security cannot substitute constitutional accountability.

  1. OBITER DICTA : 

Appointing an Independent Technical Committee 

The Court found that the Government’s limited affidavit failed to answer the central allegations  raised in the petitions. Since the allegations were directed against the executive itself, the Court  considered that an investigation conducted solely by the Government would not inspire public  confidence.The Court also noted that the allegations involved complex issues of cybersecurity and  digital forensics requiring specialized technical expertise. Therefore, an independent Technical  Committee consisting of cybersecurity experts was constituted under the supervision of Justice  R.V. Raveendran, a retired Judge of the Supreme Court.The Committee was directed to  investigate whether Pegasus spyware had been used on the devices of Indian citizens, whether any  laws governing surveillance had been violated, and whether sufficient safeguards existed to protect  citizens against unlawful digital surveillance.The appointment of the Committee reflected the  Court’s commitment to ensuring an impartial, credible, and technically competent investigation  while preserving public confidence in the administration of justice. 

  1. PERSONAL REFLECTION ON THE JUDGEMENT: 

 I believe the Pegasus spyware case is a significant constitutional law matter because it reinforces  that national security cannot be used as a blanket justification to avoid judicial scrutiny. The  Supreme Court’s decision to appoint an independent expert committee reflected its commitment to  the rule of law, accountability, and the protection of the fundamental right to privacy under Article  21. Although the Court did not conclusively determine whether Pegasus was used by the  government, the judgment established that executive actions affecting fundamental rights must  remain subject to constitutional oversight. In my opinion, the case marks an important step towards  balancing national security with individual privacy and democratic values in the digital age. 

  1. CONCLUSION:

The Pegasus Spyware Case is an important constitutional decision that reinforces the protection  of digital privacy in India. Although it did not create a new fundamental right or invalidate any  statute, it emphasized that State surveillance must always comply with constitutional requirements  and remain subject to independent judicial scrutiny. The judgment remains highly relevant to  contemporary debates on government surveillance, digital privacy, data protection, and traceability  of online communications.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top