Authored By: Muhammad Kamran
National University of Sciences & Technology (NUST)
I. Case Citation and Basic Information
Full Case Name: Hammad Saeed Dar v. Federation of Pakistan, Shariat Petition No.03/I of 2023, connected with Muhammad Azam Malik and Muhammad Kashif Sulehri v. Federation of Pakistan, Shariat Petition No.01/I of 2025
Court: Federal Shariat Court of Pakistan, Islamabad (Original Jurisdiction)
Dates of Institution: 27 February 2023 (Shariat Petition No.03/I of 2023); 7 January 2025 (Shariat Petition No.01/I of 2025)
Date of Hearing: 14 April 2026
Date of Judgment: 18 May 2026
Bench: Mr. Justice Iqbal Hameedur Rahman, Chief Justice; Mr. Justice Dr. Syed Muhammad Anwer; Mr. Justice Ameer Muhammad Khan (judgment authored by Justice Dr. Syed Muhammad Anwer)
Citation Note: This judgment had not been published in the official law reports at the time of writing. It is cited here as Shariat Petition No.03/I of 2023, connected with Shariat Petition No.01/I of 2025 (Federal Shariat Court, 18 May 2026), with pinpoint paragraph references given in the footnotes below, pending formal publication in PLD or SCMR.
II. Introduction
This case concerns the power of the Federal Shariat Court to test ordinary criminal legislation against the Injunctions of Islam under Article 203D of the Constitution of Pakistan, and its practical effect on the country’s approach to suicide and mental health. In 2022, Parliament removed Section 325 of the Pakistan Penal Code, which had punished attempted suicide with imprisonment or fine, and replaced punishment with a stated policy of treatment. The reform was welcomed internationally and cited by the World Health Organization as a model for other states to follow. Less than four years later, the Federal Shariat Court held that the repeal was repugnant to Islamic law and restored the offence. The decision is significant because it reopens a question many had assumed settled, namely whether criminal punishment is a necessary response to a suicide attempt or whether the state’s duty to preserve life is better served through medical care alone.
III. Facts of the Case
Section 325 of the Pakistan Penal Code, 1860, a provision inherited from the colonial era, made an attempt to commit suicide punishable with simple imprisonment for a term extending to one year, a fine, or both.1 Persons who acted under a genuine unsoundness of mind were already excused from criminal liability under the general exception in Section 84 of the Code, and under Section 470 and Chapter XXXIV of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898.2
In September 2021, Senator Shahadat Awan introduced a bill in the Senate to remove Section 325 from the Code. It passed the Senate in May 2022 and the National Assembly in October 2022, and received presidential assent on 23 December 2022, becoming the Criminal Laws (Amendment) Act, 2022. The Bill’s Statement of Objects and Reasons described attempted suicide as always resulting from depression or mental illness, and recommended treating it as a disease rather than a crime.3
The 2022 Act was then challenged before the Federal Shariat Court. Advocate Hammad Saeed Dar filed Shariat Petition No.03/I of 2023 on 27 February 2023, naming the Federation of Pakistan, the Government of Pakistan, and the Law and Interior Ministries as respondents. A connected petition, Shariat Petition No.01/I of 2025, filed on 7 January 2025 by Muhammad Azam Malik and Muhammad Kashif Sulehri, raised the same challenge and additionally impleaded the Council of Islamic Ideology. Both petitions argued that the 2022 Act was repugnant to the Injunctions of Islam.4
The Federation, defending the Act through the Deputy Attorney General and the Law and Interior Ministries, argued that decriminalisation did not legalise suicide but shifted the state’s response from punishment to treatment. After hearing the parties on 14 April 2026, the Federal Shariat Court delivered its judgment on 18 May 2026, allowing both petitions, holding the omission of Section 325 repugnant to the Quran and Sunnah, and restoring the section with immediate effect.5
IV. Legal Issues
Issue 1: Whether the omission of Section 325 of the Pakistan Penal Code, 1860, by the Criminal Laws (Amendment) Act, 2022, is repugnant to the Injunctions of Islam within the meaning of Article 203D of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973?
Issue 2: Whether existing exemptions for persons of unsound mind under Section 84 of the Pakistan Penal Code and Chapter XXXIV of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, are sufficient to address the concerns underlying the 2022 reform, such that a general criminal penalty for attempted suicide is unnecessary?
Issue 3: Whether the removal of Section 325 has the effect of leaving the abetment or instigation of another person’s suicide without criminal consequence, and if so, whether that consequence bears on the question of repugnancy?
V. Arguments Presented
5.1 Petitioners’ Arguments
The petitioners contended that suicide is prohibited under the Quran and Sunnah as a major sin, and that human life is a trust from Allah that a person may not extinguish by choice. Mr Dar argued that Section 325 existed to deter self-harm and protect society, and that its repeal was inconsistent with Islamic teaching. Malik and Sulehri added that, since suicide is prohibited, an attempt to commit it falls within conduct punishable under Ta’zir, so the legislature lacked competence to decriminalise it under Article 227. They argued that removing criminal liability effectively created a right to suicide contrary to Article 4 of the Constitution, invoking the maxim that what cannot be done directly cannot be done indirectly to argue the Act had indirectly legalised suicide. They warned the same reasoning could extend to justify euthanasia or assisted suicide, noted that other Muslim-majority states still criminalise the attempt, and argued that mental illness cannot be the sole justification for the reform since not every attempt arises from psychological distress.
5.2 Respondents’ Arguments
The Federation, through the Deputy Attorney General and the Law and Interior Ministries, argued that although suicide is condemned in Islam, no rule of Islamic jurisprudence requires the state to treat an attempt as a criminal offence, and that punishing it aggravates distress rather than relieving it. They relied on World Health Organization data on suicide as a public health problem and argued criminal penalties had not proved effective. They submitted that a person who attempts suicide is also its victim, that instigating suicide online was already punishable under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016, and that decriminalisation would reduce the stigma discouraging families from seeking help. They maintained that the Council of Islamic Ideology’s opinion was only recommendatory, so the legislature had acted within its competence in treating attempted suicide within the discretionary category of Ta’zir.
VI. Court’s Reasoning and Analysis
The Federal Shariat Court began by testing the premise behind the 2022 Act, that an attempt to commit suicide is always the product of depression or mental illness. It held this premise too broad, listing other circumstances in which an attempt might occur without any mental illness present, including attempts linked to terrorism, hunger strikes for political ends, self-immolation as protest, easing the financial burden of a loved one’s medical care, and psychological manipulation through online activity, naming the Blue Whale Challenge specifically.6 The Court reasoned that a single blanket exemption could not fairly cover causes as different as these, particularly since the severity of any genuine mental illness itself varies from case to case.
The Court then held that the existing exemption for unsoundness of mind under Section 84 of the Penal Code, reinforced by Section 470 and Chapter XXXIV of the Code of Criminal Procedure, already provided complete protection for persons genuinely incapable of understanding their acts, so a wholesale repeal was unnecessary.7 It supported this with the Islamic law concept that criminal responsibility is lifted from a sleeping person until waking, a child until adulthood, and a person of unsound mind until recovery, a principle it treated as already built into Pakistan’s ordinary criminal law.8 The Court also noted that the Council of Islamic Ideology had proposed only a narrower fix, a mental illness proviso within Section 325 itself. It found it self-contradictory for the Senate Committee to have rejected that proposal as illogical on the very ground that mentally unwell persons were already exempt, since that same reasoning showed the wider repeal was unnecessary.9
Turning to the substantive Islamic law question, the Court described the protection of life as one of the core objectives of Shariah and held that Islamic law treats any act adversely affecting a person’s life, direct or indirect, as conduct the state must prevent.10 It found decriminalisation created two further problems. Because liability for abetment under Section 109 of the Penal Code depends on the underlying act being an offence, removing Section 325 meant a person who facilitated another’s suicide, or who instigated a child through harmful online activity of the kind seen in the Blue Whale, Momo, and Blackout challenges, could no longer be prosecuted.11 Central to the Court’s conclusion was the principle of Sadd al-Dharai, blocking the means, under which the state must close off any path that may lead to loss of life rather than wait for it to occur.12
VII. Judgment and Ratio Decidendi
The Decision: The Federal Shariat Court accepted both petitions and declared the Criminal Laws (Amendment) Act, 2022, to the extent it omitted Section 325 of the Pakistan Penal Code, “against the principles of the Holy Quran and Sunnah.”13 The impugned Act would have no legal effect from the date of judgment, Section 325 stood restored with immediate effect, and a connected miscellaneous application in the second petition was disposed of as infructuous.
Ratio Decidendi: A legislative repeal that removes all criminal consequence for an act Islamic law requires the state to prevent, through Sadd al-Dharai, is repugnant to the Injunctions of Islam under Article 203D, and an exemption for unsound mind does not by itself justify removing liability for the wider class who attempt suicide for other reasons. The Court’s remarks on specific alternative causes and online instigation illustrate this principle rather than form part of it.
VIII. Critical Analysis
8.1 Significance of the Decision
This decision is significant because it reverses a reform that had, until this judgment, been presented internationally as good practice. The World Health Organization’s 2023 policy brief on decriminalising suicide named Pakistan, alongside Guyana and Singapore, as a state that had recently moved away from punishing suicide attempts.14 The 2026 judgment returns Pakistan to a shrinking group of states that still treat a suicide attempt as a criminal act, at a time when other jurisdictions, including India through its Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, have moved in the opposite direction, towards decriminalisation.
8.2 Implications and Impact
For individuals, the practical effect is that a person who survives a suicide attempt, along with the family or hospital staff who assist them, may again face a police case rather than only medical treatment. Commentators who supported the 2022 reform had argued that this very risk previously discouraged people from seeking help and encouraged families to disguise suicide deaths as accidents, a concern this judgment does not address.15 The matter is not yet settled. The Pakistan Psychiatric Society has filed for leave to appeal before the Shariat Appellate Bench, arguing that abolishing a discretionary Ta’zir punishment for reasons of public policy is a matter for Parliament rather than religious repugnancy, relying by analogy on the Supreme Court’s holding in Hakim Khan v Government of Pakistan that Islamic provisions of the Constitution do not automatically override Parliament’s ordinary legislative competence.16
8.3 Critical Evaluation
The Court’s reliance on Sadd al-Dharai has a long pedigree in Federal Shariat Court jurisprudence and is not an invented justification, and its treatment of the abetment gap is a genuine point, since the 2022 Act left that area unaddressed. At the same time, the judgment does not engage with medical evidence on how criminalisation affects survivors’ willingness to seek treatment, despite that evidence forming a central part of the case for the original reform. Whether a religious jurisdiction under Article 203D was the right forum to weigh that evidence, rather than Parliament acting on ordinary criminal policy grounds, is likely to be the central question on appeal.
IX. Conclusion
This case addressed whether Pakistan’s 2022 decision to stop punishing attempted suicide could survive scrutiny under the Federal Shariat Court’s jurisdiction to test laws against the Injunctions of Islam. The Court held that it could not, restoring Section 325 of the Pakistan Penal Code on the ground that Islamic law requires the state to block the path to loss of life, and that existing exemptions for unsoundness of mind did not make that protection unnecessary. The single most important point to take from the case is that a repugnancy finding under Article 203D can reach ordinary criminal policy choices, not only laws with an obvious religious character, provided the underlying conduct engages a recognised Islamic legal principle. The judgment’s lasting significance will depend heavily on the pending appeal before the Shariat Appellate Bench of the Supreme Court, which has been asked to decide whether this was truly a question of repugnancy at all, or one of ordinary legislative policy falling outside the Federal Shariat Court’s proper reach.
X. Reference(S):
Legislation
- Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan 1973
- Pakistan Penal Code 1860 (Act XLV of 1860)
- Code of Criminal Procedure 1898
- Criminal Laws (Amendment) Act 2022 (Act XXXVII of 2022)
Cases
- Hakim Khan v Government of Pakistan PLD 1992 SC 595
- Hammad Saeed Dar v Federation of Pakistan, Shariat Petition No.03/I of 2023, connected with Muhammad Azam Malik v Federation of Pakistan, Shariat Petition No.01/I of 2025 (Federal Shariat Court, 18 May 2026) (unreported)
Secondary Sources
- Nasir Iqbal, ‘Psychiatrists Challenge FSC Ruling on Suicide Attempts’ Dawn (Islamabad, 24 June 2026)
- Mekaiel Zia and Taha Sabri, ‘A Win for Mental Health’ Dawn (Islamabad, 28 December 2022)
- World Health Organization, ‘WHO Launches New Resources on Prevention and Decriminalization of Suicide’ (WHO, 12 September 2023)
Footnote(S):
1 Pakistan Penal Code 1860, s 325 (as it stood before its omission in 2022).
2 Pakistan Penal Code 1860, s 84; Code of Criminal Procedure 1898, s 470 and ch XXXIV.
3 Hammad Saeed Dar v Federation of Pakistan, Shariat Petition No.03/I of 2023, connected with Muhammad Azam Malik v Federation of Pakistan, Shariat Petition No.01/I of 2025 (Federal Shariat Court, 18 May 2026) (‘the Judgment’) para 7.
4 The Judgment (n 3) (case heading and procedural history).
5 The Judgment (n 3) para 33.
6 The Judgment (n 3) para 15.
7 The Judgment (n 3) paras 17 to 19.
8 The Judgment (n 3) paras 20 to 22.
9 The Judgment (n 3) paras 9, 10 and 23.
10 The Judgment (n 3) paras 26 to 28.
11 The Judgment (n 3) paras 29 and 30.
12 The Judgment (n 3) para 31.
13 The Judgment (n 3) paras 33 and 34.
14 World Health Organization, ‘WHO Launches New Resources on Prevention and Decriminalization of Suicide’ (WHO, 12 September 2023).
15 Mekaiel Zia and Taha Sabri, ‘A Win for Mental Health’ Dawn (Islamabad, 28 December 2022).
16 Hakim Khan v Government of Pakistan PLD 1992 SC 595; Nasir Iqbal, ‘Psychiatrists Challenge FSC Ruling on Suicide Attempts’ Dawn (Islamabad, 24 June 2026).

