Home » Blog » Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru & Ors. v. State of Kerala & Anr.

Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru & Ors. v. State of Kerala & Anr.

Authored By: Unnati Singh

Raja Mahendra Pratap university, Aligarh

  1. CASE CITATION AND BASIC INFORMATION 

Full Case Name: Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru & Ors. v. State of Kerala & Anr. Citation: (1973) 4 SCC 225; AIR 1973 SC 1461 

Court: Supreme Court of India 

Case Number: Writ Petition (Civil) No. 135 of 1970 and connected petitions Date of Judgment: 24 April 1973 

Bench: 13-Judge Constitution Bench 

Chief Justice: S.M. Sikri, C.J. 

Majority: 7:6 

Subject: Constitutional Law, Fundamental Rights, Power of Constitutional Amendment and Basic Structure Doctrine 

  1. INTRODUCTION 

The case of Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru v. State of Kerala is one of the most important constitutional decisions in Indian legal history. The judgment fundamentally changed the understanding of the power of Parliament to amend the Constitution. The central question before the Supreme Court was whether Parliament possessed an unlimited power to amend the Constitution under Article 368 or whether there were constitutional limitations on that power. 

The case arose in the background of land reform legislation in Kerala and a continuing conflict between Parliament’s power to pursue socio-economic reforms and the protection of constitutional rights. During the proceedings, the validity of the Constitution (Twenty-Fourth), Twenty-Fifth and Twenty-Ninth Amendment Acts was challenged.

The Supreme Court, by a narrow majority of seven judges to six, held that Parliament has wide power to amend the Constitution, including Fundamental Rights, but this power does not extend to destroying or altering the Constitution’s basic structure. This principle came to be known as the Basic Structure Doctrine. The judgment therefore attempted to maintain a balance between constitutional flexibility and constitutional supremacy. 

  1. FACTS OF THE CASE 

The dispute originated from land reform legislation enacted by the State of Kerala. Kesavananda Bharati was the head of the Edneer Mutt, a religious institution in Kerala. The Mutt owned considerable property, and certain provisions of the Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1963 affected the rights and interests connected with that property. 

Kesavananda Bharati challenged the constitutional validity of the Kerala Land Reforms Act and its amendments. The petition was filed under Article 32 of the Constitution, which provides a remedy for the enforcement of Fundamental Rights. He relied upon several constitutional rights, including Articles 25, 26, 14, 19(1)(f) and 31. 

While the petition was pending, the Kerala Legislature enacted further amendments to its land reform legislation. These amendments increased the importance of the constitutional questions before the Supreme Court. 

At the national level, there had already been a long-running disagreement between Parliament and the judiciary concerning the relationship between Fundamental Rights and constitutional amendments. Earlier decisions such as Shankari Prasad v. Union of India and Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan had taken a broad view of Parliament’s amending power. However, in I.C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab, the Supreme Court had taken the view that Parliament could not amend Fundamental Rights in a manner that amounted to their abridgment. 

The political and constitutional situation changed further with the passage of the Constitution (Twenty-Fourth Amendment) Act, 1971. This amendment expressly stated that Parliament could amend the Constitution in exercise of its constituent power. It also attempted to make clear that Article 13 would not apply to constitutional amendments. 

The Twenty-Fifth Amendment introduced Article 31C and attempted to give greater protection to laws implementing certain Directive Principles from challenges based on specified Fundamental Rights.

The Twenty-Ninth Amendment placed two Kerala land reform laws in the Ninth Schedule of the Constitution. By placing them in the Ninth Schedule, Parliament attempted to protect them from judicial review based on Fundamental Rights. 

Therefore, the original dispute concerning land reforms developed into a much larger constitutional question: Could Parliament use its power under Article 368 to change any part of the Constitution, including provisions that formed its essential identity? 

The Supreme Court therefore had to examine not only the Kerala land reform laws but also the extent of Parliament’s constitutional amending power. 

  1. LEGAL ISSUES 

The principal legal issues before the Supreme Court were: 

Issue 1: Whether Parliament’s power under Article 368 to amend the Constitution was unlimited and extended to every provision of the Constitution, including Fundamental Rights. 

Issue 2: Whether the Constitution (Twenty-Fourth Amendment) Act, 1971, which expressly recognised Parliament’s constituent power to amend the Constitution, was constitutionally valid. 

Issue 3: Whether the Constitution (Twenty-Fifth Amendment) Act, 1971, particularly Article 31C, was valid. 

Issue 4: Whether the Constitution (Twenty-Ninth Amendment) Act, 1972, which placed certain Kerala land reform laws in the Ninth Schedule, was valid. 

Issue 5: Whether there were certain fundamental features or principles of the Constitution that Parliament could not destroy even through the constitutional amendment procedure. 

These questions required the Court to determine the meaning and scope of the word “amendment” in Article 368. 

  1. ARGUMENTS PRESENTED 

5.1 Petitioners’ Arguments

The petitioners argued that Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution was not unlimited. They accepted that constitutional amendments were necessary because society changes with time, but argued that an amendment could not destroy the essential identity of the Constitution. 

The petitioners relied heavily on the idea that the Constitution was created by the people and that Parliament was only one constitutional organ. Parliament therefore could not exercise unlimited constituent power to destroy the fundamental principles on which the Constitution was based. 

The petitioners argued that Fundamental Rights were not ordinary statutory rights. They were fundamental guarantees intended to protect individual liberty and dignity. If Parliament could completely remove these rights through an amendment, constitutional protection would become meaningless. 

Nani A. Palkhivala, who argued for the petitioners, advanced the argument that the word “amendment” could not reasonably mean the destruction or abolition of the Constitution itself. The judgment records the argument that an amendment could improve or modify the Constitution while preserving its essential features. 

The petitioners therefore requested the Court to recognise limitations on Parliament’s amending power and to protect the fundamental character of the Constitution. 

5.2 Respondents’ Arguments 

The respondents argued that Article 368 provided Parliament with a broad constituent power to amend the Constitution. 

According to this argument, the Constitution itself provided the procedure for amendment and Parliament was required to follow that procedure. If the Constitution-makers had intended to place certain provisions completely beyond amendment, they could have expressly stated so. 

The respondents also argued that constitutional amendments were fundamentally different from ordinary legislation. Therefore, restrictions applicable to ordinary laws should not automatically be applied to constitutional amendments. 

The State and Union authorities further argued that social and economic reform required constitutional flexibility. Land reform was considered important for reducing inequality and implementing social justice policies.

A rigid limitation on Parliament’s amending power, according to the respondents, could prevent future generations from changing the Constitution according to their needs. 

  1. COURT’S REASONING AND ANALYSIS 

The Supreme Court’s reasoning was extremely detailed because the case involved a fundamental question concerning the relationship between Parliament, the Constitution and the judiciary. 

The Court first examined the history of constitutional amendments and earlier Supreme Court decisions. The earlier cases demonstrated that the Court’s understanding of Article 368 had developed over time. 

The Court considered Shankari Prasad, Sajjan Singh and Golaknath. These decisions reflected different approaches to Parliament’s power to amend Fundamental Rights. 

A major question was the meaning of the word “amendment.” The Court considered whether amendment could include complete destruction or replacement of the Constitution. 

The majority concluded that Parliament does possess constituent power under Article 368 and therefore can amend even Fundamental Rights. In this respect, the Court did not completely follow Golaknath. 

However, the majority simultaneously held that the power to amend is not unlimited. Parliament cannot use the amendment power to destroy the basic structure or basic features of the Constitution. 

The Court therefore created a middle position. 

On one side, Parliament was given substantial power to change the Constitution. On the other side, the Constitution retained an essential identity that could not be destroyed. 

The Court examined the nature of the Constitution as a whole, including the Preamble, Fundamental Rights, democratic principles, separation of powers and the constitutional system of government. 

The precise list of basic features was not treated as a closed or exhaustive list. Different judges identified different features in their separate opinions. Features recognised in the case and subsequent constitutional jurisprudence include the supremacy of the Constitution, republican and democratic government, secularism, separation of powers, federalism, judicial review, rule of law and the protection of constitutional identity. 

The important point was that not every constitutional provision was automatically immune from amendment. Instead, the Court had to examine whether an amendment damaged or destroyed an essential feature of the Constitution. 

This distinction between amendment and destruction became the foundation of the Basic Structure Doctrine. 

The Court also considered the challenged constitutional amendments. The Twenty-Fourth Amendment was largely upheld because Parliament did possess the power to amend the Constitution. However, the Court imposed the basic-structure limitation on the exercise of that power. 

The Twenty-Fifth Amendment was partly upheld and partly restricted. The Court did not accept an interpretation that would completely remove judicial review or permit Parliament to place constitutional amendments beyond all judicial scrutiny. 

The Twenty-Ninth Amendment and the Kerala land reform laws were also considered within the framework established by the Court. 

The decision therefore attempted to reconcile two competing constitutional values: constitutional adaptability and constitutional continuity. 

  1. JUDGMENT AND RATIO DECIDENDI 

The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 24 April 1973. The case was decided by a very narrow majority of 7:6. The judgment consisted of multiple separate opinions from the thirteen judges. 

The central holding was that Parliament has broad power under Article 368 to amend the Constitution, including Fundamental Rights, but Parliament cannot alter the basic structure of the Constitution. 

Thus, the Court rejected both extreme positions. 

It rejected the argument that Fundamental Rights could never be amended. At the same time, it rejected the argument that Parliament could amend the Constitution without substantive limitation.

Ratio Decidendi 

The ratio decidendi of Kesavananda Bharati is that: 

The power of Parliament to amend the Constitution under Article 368 is wide, but it is subject to an implied limitation: Parliament cannot amend the Constitution in a manner that destroys or damages its basic structure or essential features. 

This principle means that constitutional amendments can be reviewed by the judiciary to determine whether they violate the Constitution’s basic structure. 

The decision therefore established a constitutional limitation on Parliament’s amending power. 

The Basic Structure Doctrine does not mean that the Constitution is frozen. Amendments can still change constitutional provisions, adapt institutions and respond to changing social circumstances. What Parliament cannot do is destroy the constitutional identity itself. 

The Supreme Court’s later decisions have repeatedly relied on this principle. In Waman Rao v. Union of India, the Court expressly referred to Kesavananda Bharati and stated that Parliament cannot amend the Constitution so as to damage or destroy its basic or essential features. 

  1. CRITICAL ANALYSIS 

8.1 Significance of the Decision 

The most important contribution of Kesavananda Bharati is the Basic Structure Doctrine. Before this judgment, there was uncertainty about whether Parliament possessed an unlimited power to amend the Constitution. 

The judgment established that constitutional supremacy is more important than parliamentary supremacy. Parliament derives its authority from the Constitution and therefore cannot use constitutional amendment power to destroy the constitutional framework itself. 

The judgment also strengthened judicial review. Courts became the institution capable of examining whether constitutional amendments crossed the basic-structure limitation. 

This was particularly important because constitutional amendments require a special majority and, in certain cases, ratification by the States. Even so, the Court held that the procedure itself could not authorise destruction of the Constitution’s essential features.

8.2 Implications and Impact 

The decision has had a lasting influence on Indian constitutional law. 

One major consequence is that later constitutional amendments have been examined through the basic-structure framework. 

The doctrine has also protected important constitutional principles such as democracy, judicial review, separation of powers, federalism and constitutional supremacy. 

The doctrine became especially significant during constitutional conflicts involving the scope of Parliament’s power and the independence of constitutional institutions. 

Later cases strengthened the principle. For example, the Supreme Court has continued to treat the basic structure as a limitation on constitutional amendments. The Court has also applied the doctrine while examining amendments affecting the Ninth Schedule and Fundamental Rights. 

8.3 Critical Evaluation 

The greatest strength of the judgment is that it protects the Constitution from being legally destroyed by an amendment procedure. A Constitution that could be completely dismantled by the government through amendments would have little practical value as a limitation on governmental power. 

The doctrine therefore provides constitutional continuity. It allows necessary change while preserving foundational principles. 

Another strength is its protection of democracy. Democracy is not simply majority rule. It also involves constitutional limits, individual rights, judicial independence and institutional checks and balances. The Basic Structure Doctrine protects these principles against excessive concentration of power. 

However, the doctrine has also attracted criticism. 

The Constitution does not expressly use the words “basic structure.” Critics therefore argue that the Supreme Court effectively created a limitation that was not clearly written in the constitutional text.

Another criticism concerns judicial subjectivity. Since the Constitution does not provide an exhaustive list of basic features, judges must determine whether a particular amendment damages the basic structure. Different judges may have different views about what constitutes an essential constitutional feature. 

There is therefore a potential tension between judicial review and democratic decision-making. 

Nevertheless, the doctrine can be defended on the ground that the Constitution is not merely an ordinary law. Its purpose is to establish the framework within which all organs of government operate. If an amendment could destroy that framework, constitutional government itself could disappear. 

The doctrine therefore represents a compromise. It permits substantial constitutional change while preventing constitutional destruction. 

  1. CONCLUSION 

Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru v. State of Kerala remains one of the most significant judgments of the Supreme Court of India. The decision resolved a major constitutional controversy concerning the extent of Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution. 

The Supreme Court held that Parliament has extensive power under Article 368 and can amend many constitutional provisions, including Fundamental Rights. However, that power is not unlimited. Parliament cannot destroy or damage the basic structure of the Constitution. 

The Basic Structure Doctrine has therefore created a balance between constitutional flexibility and constitutional stability. It allows the Constitution to develop according to changing social, political and economic conditions while preserving its essential identity. 

The case is also important because it strengthened judicial review and constitutional supremacy. The judiciary was recognised as having the responsibility to ensure that constitutional amendments remain within the limits of the Constitution. 

Although the doctrine has been criticised because the phrase “basic structure” is not expressly defined in the Constitution, its importance in protecting constitutional democracy cannot be underestimated. 

The lasting lesson of Kesavananda Bharati is that constitutional amendment and constitutional destruction are not the same thing. Parliament may change the Constitution, but it cannot use the Constitution’s amendment procedure to destroy the fundamental principles that give the Constitution its identity. 

For this reason, the judgment continues to be regarded as a foundation of Indian constitutional law and an important safeguard against the excessive exercise of constitutional power. 

  1. REFERENCES(S):

Primary Sources 

  1. Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru & Ors. v. State of Kerala & Anr., (1973) 4 SCC 225; AIR 1973 SC 1461. 
  2. Constitution of India, arts. 13, 14, 19, 21, 25, 26, 31, 32 and 368. 3. Constitution (Twenty-Fourth Amendment) Act, 1971. 
  3. Constitution (Twenty-Fifth Amendment) Act, 1971. 
  4. Constitution (Twenty-Ninth Amendment) Act, 1972. 

Other Cases 

  1. Shankari Prasad Singh Deo v. Union of India, AIR 1951 SC 458. 7. Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1965 SC 845. 
  2. I.C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab, AIR 1967 SC 1643. 
  3. Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain, 1975 Supp SCC 1. 
  4. Minerva Mills Ltd. v. Union of India, (1980) 3 SCC 625. 
  5. Waman Rao v. Union of India, (1981) 2 SCC 362. 
  6. I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2007) 2 SCC 1.

Online Legal Sources 

  1. Supreme Court of India, Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru & Ors. v. State of Kerala & Anr., Judgment dated 24 April 1973. 
  2. Indian Kanoon, Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru & Ors. v. State of Kerala & Anr., 24 April 1973. 
  3. Indian Kanoon, Waman Rao & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., 9 May 1980.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top