Authored By: Abhiya Khan
University of Nottingham
Case Citation and Basic Information
Case Name: Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Foundation Trust v. Yates & Gard
Citation: [2017] EWCA Civ 410; [2017] Fam.331
Court: Court of Appeal (Civil Division), England & Wales
Date of Decision: May 23rd 2017
Bench Composition: Lord Justice McFarlane, Lady Justice Kind and Lord Justice Sales
Introduction
The case revolves around a medical law decision which is centred on the court’s jurisdiction over the welfare of a sick infant while balancing parental autonomy against the welfare of the child. In English law, the case concerns family and medical law relating to the withdrawal of life-saving treatment.
III. Facts of the case
Charlie Gard was born with a severe mitochondrial condition which caused him to have progressive damage to his brain. The condition had left him unable to do basic functions; he was unable to hear, move or breathe without the use of machines. His condition was not curable, and the doctors found that removing him from life support would be best for Charlie. However, his parents did not agree, and they wanted to take him abroad to pursue experimental treatment. Without any form of agreement between the doctors and Charlie’s parents, the hospital decided to seek an order to stop the life support treatment. Charlie’s parents argued that their autonomy as parents should be interfered with only if it would cause significant harm to Charlie.
Legal Issues
The legal issue at hand was whether the court should override Charlie’s parents’ wishes regarding the use of experimental treatment for the child’s best interests to be considered.
The court must assess whether intervention is necessary when parents and medical professionals disagree about treatment.
Arguments Presented
Appellant Argument:
Charlie’s parents were the appellants who had argued 5 grounds of appeal when the case was taken to the Court of Appeal. The court rejected two grounds of appeal from the start and heard three. The appeals heard were the 1st, 2nd, and 4th grounds of appeal. The first ground concerned the significant harm test. It argued that the court applied the wrong legal framework and lacked authority to override a decision by two fit, capable, loving parents regarding their child’s care. Their choice to travel to the United States for experimental treatment did not meet the significant harm threshold. The second ground of appeal concerned the court’s jurisdiction, and the judge did not have the power to stop them when a separate medical team in the United States had stated its professional judgement in recommending this treatment. The fourth ground of appeal concerned rights under the European Convention on Human Rights, specifically Articles 2, 5 & 8. Forcing a child to die in a hospital while blocking the use of viable and alternative care violated fundamental rights.
Respondent Argument:
The respondent was the Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Foundation Trust. In response to the first ground of appeal, the respondents argued that the appellants were attempting to re-establish UK family law, specifically under the Children Act 1989. They argued that the best interests of the child is the sole paramount consideration in medical disputes, meaning there is no alternative significant harm threshold to consider. On the second ground of appeal, the respondents argued that bringing Charlie to America was not a viable treatment option because they found no alternative viable option. By bringing Charlie to America, it would prolong the harm which he is going through, with not enough information regarding the results of treatment. Finally, on the 4th ground of appeal, the respondents argued that the courts considered the child’s best interests, in compliance with the requirements of both Article 2 and Article 8 of the ECHR.
Court’s Reasoning and Analysis
The Court of Appeal emphasised the importance of a child’s welfare under English family law principles. It is working to uphold the welfare principle above all. The court has also reviewed expert medical advice and evidence to find that the experimental treatment in the United States would not be in the interest of the child, as the experts had found Charlie’s brain damage to be irreversible. Furthermore, the courts assessed and concluded that parental rights must yield to the child’s welfare and best interests when conflict arises. In their reasoning, the courts acknowledged how difficult the situation was for the family and sympathised with them. This sympathy did not, however, affect their decision; they ensured the parents understood that the principles of the law are there to protect Charlie. They understood that the decision would mean that Charlie would pass away, but it would be better for him to go peacefully as opposed to being in pain and on life support. Ultimately, continuing treatment to even arrive in the United States would cause Charlie more ongoing pain without any sort of benefit or foreseeable result, which fails to acknowledge the child’s best interest and welfare.
VII. Judgment and Ratio Decidendi
Judgment
Lord Justice McFarlane led the judgment, in which the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the High Court’s decision. This was because it was in Charlie’s best interests to withdraw from life-sustaining treatment.
Ratio Decidendi
The ratio Decidendi is that courts ultimately have the jurisdiction to determine whether the ca child’s interests and welfare are being considered when there is a disagreement between parents and medical professionals.
VIII. Critical Analysis
The Charlie Gard case is important in English law because it reinforces the child’s best interests and how medical law clarifies the judge’s role in end-of-life care disputes. The case serves as vital precedent for future medical law cases, especially those involving the withdrawal of life-saving treatment, by clarifying the standard required to evaluate medical concerns and the sustainability of life. Furthermore, this case can be seen as controversial because the law intervened in a family’s life, as the primary focus was on the child’s well-being and suffering. The courts focused on the child and did not take the family’s decision-making into consideration, which might have sparked controversy; however, in this situation, it proved beneficial. Although Charlie’s parents were unable to decide, in circumstances in which a child is ill, decisions are often made from one’s heart as opposed to their head. Charlie’s parents wanted to save his life, and they wanted to get him help; although it wasn’t guaranteed, they were acting with any hope possible to cling to their son. This hope is what would make any reasonable parent forget that, at the end of the day, experimental treatment could potentially cause the child harm, and that harm is more than the child would face passing away naturally. Ultimately, the court’s decision stems from the perspective of being the logical solution when emotions can take overdecision-making,g which is why they heavily relied on
Conclusion
The case remains an important legal precedent that illustrates the court’s boundaries between family law, medical law, and parental consent. The judgement effectively illustrates that when parental hope collides with medical law, the English legal system prioritises the child’s welfare above all other considerations.
Reference(S):
Children Act, “Children Act 1989” (legislation.gov.uk, 1989)
<https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1989/41/contents> accessed September 13, 2026
Yates and Another v Great Ormond Street Hospital and Another (Court of Appeal (Civil Division))