Home » Blog » FRN v. KANU by Kalu Grace

FRN v. KANU by Kalu Grace

Authored By: Kalu Grace Onyinyechi

FRN v. KANU by Kalu Grace

FEDRAL REPUBLIC OF NIGERIA

V

NNAMDI KANU

(2024) 11NWLR (231).

SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

SC/CR/1361/2022.

Kudirat Motonmori Olatokunbo Kekere-Ekun, J.S.C (presided)

Mohammed Lawal Garba, J.S.C (reading the leading judgment)

Ibrahim Mohammed Musa Saulawa, J.S.C

Emmanuel Akomaye Agim, J.S.C

December 15, 2023

The Federal Republic of Nigeria appealed the Court of Appeal’s judgment quashing terrorism charges against Nnamdi Kanu following his unlawful extraordinary rendition from Kenya. In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court unanimously allowed the appeal and ordered the trial to proceed at the Federal High Court. The Court established that while executive abduction violates fundamental rights, it does not divest a trial court of its statutory subject-matter jurisdiction. This judgment has become a guiding principle in Nigerian jurisprudence, reinforcing the strict legal separation between executive misconduct and judicial jurisdiction. It establishes that fundamental rights violations committed during arrest cannot serve as a procedural shield to invalidate criminal prosecutions. Instead, executive lawlessness must be addressed through separate civil suits for damages rather than the dismissal of valid criminal charges.

FACTS

The respondent was arraigned before the federal high court in 2015 on a 4 count amended charge of conspiracy, treasonable felony, and publication of defamation matter and improper importation of goods, to which he pleaded not guilty and was granted bail. The court revoked his bail on the 28th of March, 2019, when he repeatedly failed to attend court despite several adjournments to enable him appear. The reason attached to his failed appearance in court was that his ancestral home at Afaraukwu ibeku, umuahia, Abia state was invaded by a joint team of Nigerian security agents, code named “Operation Python Dance” with the intent of murdering him extra judicially. It was alleged that this intentional attack led to the deaths of several members of the community, the respondents parents included. The respondent said that he didn’t jump bail but had to flee out of fear for his life. He was apprehended at the Jomo Kenyatta Airport, Nairobi, Kenya and returned to Nigeria on the 27th June, 2021.on the 19th of January, 2022, he was re-arraigned on 15-count amended charge which he pleaded not guilty to.

A preliminary objection was filed on behalf of the respondent seeking to quash the charges against him on various grounds including the fact that he was brought back from Kenya to Nigeria in an extra ordinary way which is in disregard to the provision of the Extradition act, Cap. A9, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria (LFN) 2004 and also some international laws which are regarded as binding on Nigeria like the African Charter on Human and Peoples Rights (Ratification and Enforcement) Act, and some others. It was contended that the failure of the appellant to comply with all or any of the laws that was stated, conventions and guidelines in the manner in which the respondent was brought back to Nigeria and produced before the court has deprived the court of jurisdiction to try him. Also, the validity of the charges brought against him was challenged through the preliminary objection. After hearing all the arguments, the trial court in its rulings struck out counts 6, 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14 for the failure of the appellant to disclose an offence or for duplication. On the other hand, the court retained counts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 15 and ordered that the trail proceed on these retained counts.

On appeal to the Court of Appeal, the court held that the unique rendition of the respondent to Nigeria had the effect of depriving the court of jurisdiction to try him. The appeal was permitted and the charges against him were squashed. He was discharged accordingly. Aggrieved, the appellant appealed to the Supreme Court. In determining the appeal brought before them, the Supreme Court considered the provisions of section 12, 251 (1) (s) and (3) of the constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended); section 122 of the Evidence Act, 2011; sections 194, 195, 196(1), 220 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, 2015 (ACJA); section 32(1), Federal High Court Act, 2001, section 47(2) (a) of the Customs Excise and Management Act Cap C45, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria, 2004; sections 2 and 16 Terrorism Prevention Amendment Act, 2013; section 15 of the Extradition Act; Resolution 55/25 and Article 21 of the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crimes, (The Palermo Convention).

ISSUES

  1. Whether the manner in which the respondent was taken to court can hinder the trial court for having jurisdiction to try the offence upon which the respondent is standing trial in view of relevant provision of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, 2015?
  2. Whether the court of appeal was not in grave error when it accorded binding force and over-riding effects to intentional treaties, conventions and foreign judgments that are inconsistent with extant Nigerian legislations?
  3. Whether or not the Court of Appeal in its lead judgment to pronounce the competence of paragraphs 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 28, 29, 30, 33 and 36 of the respondent affidavit in support of his preliminary objection is not a breach of the appellants right to fair hearing?
  4. Whether the learned justice of the Court of Appeal were right relying on paragraphs 21, 22, 23, 24 and 25 of the affidavit in support of the respondents preliminary objection, which affidavit contains extraneous matters inclusive of objections prayers, legal arguments and conclusions to reach the finding that the respondent was illegally brought back to Nigeria?
  5. Whether the learned Justices of the Court of Appeal had jurisdiction to entertain the respondents interlocutory appeal filed without leave of court?
  6. Whether the learned justices of the court of appeal were right to rely on the alleged non-compliance with the provisions of the extradition act to reach the conclusion that the respondent was unlawfully brought into Nigeria and consequently robbed the trial court of the jurisdiction to continue his trial?
  7. Whether the learned Justice of the Court of Appeal had jurisdiction to entertain the respondents appeal when the decision of the trial court was made in breach of section 396(2) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act?

HELD (Unanimously allowing the appeal):

On Jurisdiction vs. Mode of Arrest (Male Captus, Bene Detentus):

The Supreme Court held that the mode, manner, or location of an accused person’s arrest—including unlawful abduction or extraordinary rendition from a foreign sovereign state—does not strip, extinguish, or divest a trial court of its statutory subject-matter jurisdiction. Grounded in the long-standing common law doctrine of male captus, bene detentus (bad capture, good detention), judicial jurisdiction is strictly a constitutional and statutory creation determined by the nature of the alleged criminal offenses and the court’s enabling statutes, rather than extrajudicial illegalities preceding trial initiation.

On Remedies for Executive Lawlessness and Fundamental Rights Violations:

The apex court declared that while extraordinary rendition constitutes a severe breach of international law, human rights conventions, and executive decorum, such executive misconduct cannot serve as a procedural shield to quash valid criminal charges. The legal remedy for fundamental rights violations committed by state security agents lies in independent civil proceedings for damages or constitutional enforcement of rights, rather than the complete dismissal of criminal prosecutions.

On Judicial Restraint Regarding Executive Misconduct:

The Supreme Court affirmed that while courts must sternly condemn state illegalities and executive high-handedness, the judiciary cannot usurp prosecutorial powers vested in the executive or invalidate lawful criminal charges due to extrajudicial acts occurring prior to court proceedings.

On Validity of Bail Revocation:

The Court upheld the revocation of the Respondent’s bail by the trial court. It held that the Respondent breached his bail conditions by fleeing the jurisdiction in 2017, regardless of the military intervention at his residence. Consequently, the trial court acted within its statutory powers in issuing an arrest warrant.

On Disposition:

The Supreme Court set aside the Court of Appeal judgment and ordered that the remaining 7 counts against the Respondent be remitted back to the Federal High Court, Abuja, for the immediate continuation of his trial.

MAIN JUDGMENT EXTRACTS (AGIM, J.S.C.):

“The statutory jurisdiction of a court to try a criminal offense is conferred by law and activated by the charge filed before it. The mode or manner in which an accused person is brought before the court, no matter how illegal, irregular, or objectionable, does not strip the court of its subject-matter jurisdiction. Executive lawlessness during arrest cannot operate as an absolute bar to criminal prosecution.”

“While the court must not condone executive lawlessness, civil remedies exist for the enforcement of fundamental rights and recovery of damages. It is an error in law to equate executive misconduct with judicial lack of jurisdiction.”

STATUTES AND CASES REFERRED TO:

  • Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended), Sections 6, 35, 36, and 251
  • Terrorism (Prevention) Act, 2011 (as amended)
  • Administration of Criminal Justice Act, 2015
  • Madukolu v. Nkemdilim (1962) 2 SCNLR 341
  • Abacha v. Fawehinmi (2000) 6 NWLR (Pt. 660) 228
  • United States v. Alvarez-Machain, 504 U.S. 655 (1992)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top