Home » Blog » Dred Scott v. John Sandford

Dred Scott v. John Sandford

Authored By: Reem Adnan Albar

1- Case citation and Basic Information:

Dred Scott v. John F. A. Sandford, 60 U.S. (19 How.) 393 (1857) , (Supreme Court of the United States), (7-2 Decision, Chief Justice Roger B. Taney writing the majority opinion) Decided on March 6, 1857

2- Introduction:

 Dred Scott is an enslaved African American man who filed a lawsuit against his owner’s widow, seeking his freedom as a person, but she refused. Then again, Scott sued the executor of the owner’s estate, John Sandford, seeking his freedom in front of the Federal Court. He asked for his freedom because one day his owner took him from the state of Missouri to another territory (Wisconsin) where slavery is prohibited, and everyone is a free human being. He filed the case in different states, which he lost in all of them; then he filed in the Federal Court, which eventually reached the Supreme Court. But due to the Missouri Compromise of 1820, slavery is prohibited above the 36*0 30’ latitude line in the remainder of the Louisiana Territory, excluding Missouri, where slavery is allowed. Even though Mr. Scott asked for his freedom, the court refused to go further in the case, reasoning that he is an enslaved man who does not have the right to sue as an American citizen because slaves are not citizens under federal law.

3- Facts of the case:

Dred Scott is an African American enslaved man who was once owned by an American doctor named Emerson, Dred Scott came with his owner from Missouri state to Illinois State and then they went to Wisconsin, a state which is slavery is prohibited by law; therefore, it made him a free man. So after he came back to Missouri, he filed his first lawsuit arguing for freedom that he was once a free man, but the court rejected his claim.

Afterward, Dred Scott filed against the executor’s owner John Sandford (a resident of New York), so he again filed a lawsuit for the same claim in the Federal Court, but it went to the Supreme Court of the United States.

4- Legal Issues:

Issue 1: The Supreme Court did not consider the plaintiff’s claim from the start because, under civil law, African Americans do not have the right to file a lawsuit in the United States because they are not citizens.

Issue 2: Under civil law and according to Congress, the plaintiff does not gain freedom for just going to a territory that prohibits slavery.

Issue 3: The Supreme Court did not solve the slavery problem, which eventually at that time escalated the issue to civil war between the North and the South of America.

5- Argument Presented:

From the side of Dred Scott argument, which led him to file the lawsuit, is that he went to a country that prohibits slavery; therefore, that made him a free man, and that is why he made this claim asking for his freedom.

And from the side of the defendant’s argument, he argued by saying that slaves are a property and have property rights that made him mention the congress could not prohibit slavery in the territories.

6- Court’s Reasoning and Analysis:

  • Chief Justice Taney said that African Americans were “so far inferior, that they had no rights which the white man was bound to respect,” and African Americans are not citizens, so they can not sue in the United States, because at that time they were considered a lower class of society and they had no right to sue.
  • Enslaved people are recognised as property according to the Constitution of the United States, and Chief Justice Taney applied that the court can not exercise authority over the property. And due to the 5th Amendment of the constitution the congress can not deprive any citizen of “life, liberty, or property, without due process of law”.
  • And The Court checked the territorial regulations that the plaintiff went to and claimed his freedom from going there, considering that they can prohibit slavery in these territories.
  • There were 2 judges who were opponents of the reasoning and the judgment, Mr Benjamin Curtis and Mr John McLean, and they saw that the judgment should be reversed.

7- Judgment:

The Court ruled that enslaved people are not citizens of the United States to even have protection from the courts of the United States. Also, it stated that Congress had no authority to ban slavery from a federal territory.

8- Critical Analysis:

This judgment is a cruel decision and not well reasoned; actually, it was a formal ruling more than a descriptive ruling. Even if the regulation of the country was against what the plaintiff asked for, that does not mean they do not make an effort to rewrite the rules of civil law. All people are free citizens or residents, and for the judge’s reasoning that they only accept legal cases from citizens, Dred Scott had the right to file a lawsuit not just for living in their country but, even more to mention, that he was born in the United States.

The consequences of this decision were major to civil law that made them reconsider and actually change their rules. Even when the society at that time pressured the court for their awful decision, not to mention this judgment came from the Supreme Court, the highest court that should make a well-structured decision, the rules did not change while the plaintiff filed his lawsuit, but afterwards.

9- Conclusion:

Dred Scott (a slave) sued his owner seeking his freedom, but he did not win the case. The court ruled that slaves were property at that time, and they were not citizens to file a claim. This decision was considered one of the worst decisions in the Supreme Court’s history of the United States.

This landmark judgment changed the Constitution of the United States of America through the 14th Amendment, and it concluded that any person who was born in the United States is a citizen, whether he is an African Person or native American. The 13th Amendment terminated slavery.

Reference(S):

1- Scott V. Sandford 1857  (no date) C-span landmark cases. Available at: https://landmarkcases.c-span.org/Case/2/Scott-v.-Sandford.

2- Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857) (2020) Cornell Law School. Available at: https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/dred_scott_v_sandford_%281857%29#1

3- Goodman, D. (2011) On Dred Scott v. Sanford, SSRN. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1974426.

4- Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857) (no date) National Archives and Records Administration. Available at: https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/dred-scott-v-sandford.

5- Missouri compromise (1820) (no date) National Archives and Records Administration. Available at: https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/missouri-compromise.

6- Magnusson , M. (2020) ‘no rights which the white man was bound to respect’: The Dred Scott Decision: ACS, American Constitution Society. Available at: https://www.acslaw.org/expertforum/no-rights-which-the-white-man-was-bound-to-respect/.

7- Lewis, T.T. (2022) Scott v. Sandford: Law: Research starters: EBSCO research, EBSCO. Available at: https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/law/scott-v-sandford.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top