Home » Blog » FRANCIS KARIOKO MURUATETU

FRANCIS KARIOKO MURUATETU

Authored By: Joy Adhiambo

Catholic University of Eastern Africa

FRANCIS KARIOKO MURUATETU

Francis Muruatetu & another v Republic; Katiba Institute & 5 others (Amicus Curiae) Petition 15 & 16 of 2015 (Consolidated) [2017] KESC 2 (KLR) Supreme court of Kenya Judges: DK Maraga CJ & P, PM Mwilu DCJ & VP, JB Ojwang, SC Wanjala, N Ndungu & I Lenaola, SCJJ decided on December 14, 2017.

Introduction

The decision in this case is a landmark decision of the supreme court of Kenya that marked a significant development in Kenya’s constitutional and criminal justice jurisprudence. The case concerned the constitutionality of the mandatory death penalty prescribed for the offence of murder under section 204 of the Penal Code. The petitioners challenged the mandatory death sentence, arguing that it deprived courts of the discretion to consider the individual circumstances of an offender and therefore infringed fundamental rights guaranteed under the 2010 Constitution of Kenya.

The Supreme Court considered whether mandatory nature of the sentence was consistent with constitutional rights particularly the right to a fair trial, human dignity and protection against cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, and whether mandatory sentencing interfered with judicial discretion and separation of powers.

The Court’s determination had far-reaching implications for sentencing as it affirmed the importance of judicial discretion and individualized sentencing while reshaping the approach to mandatory sentences. [1]

Facts of the case

The petitioners, Francis Karioko Muruatetu and Wilson Thirimbu Mwangi, were convicted of murder contrary to section 203 of the Penal Code and sentenced to death under section 204 of the Penal Code, which prescribed the death penalty as the mandatory sentence for murder.

The petitioners therefore appealed against both their conviction and their sentence to the Court of Appeal. The judgement of the Court of Appeal was given on 11th July 2014 in Civil Appeal No. 93 of 2014 and the court of the Appeal dismissed their appeal and their convictions and sentences were subsequently upheld by the Court of Appeal.

The petitioners later filed two separate petitions before the Supreme Court which were later consolidated. The petitioners were in custody for approximately sixteen years before there matter was taken to the Supreme court. They challenged the constitutionality of the mandatory nature of the death sentence before the Supreme Court. They argued that the mandatory sentence prevented the trial court from considering the circumstances of the offence and the individual circumstances of the offender before imposing sentence. They further contended that the mandatory death penalty violated various rights and freedoms protected by the Constitution, including the right to a fair trial and the right to dignity.

The central complaint was therefore not that the death penalty could never be imposed for murder, but that making it mandatory was unconstitutional.

Legal Issues

The issues before the Supreme Court were:

  1. Whether the mandatory death sentence under section 204 of the Penal Code was unconstitutional.
  2. Whether mandatory sentencing violated the rights to human dignity and protection against cruel, inhuman or degrading punishment and right to a fair trial by preventing courts from considering mitigating circumstances.
  3. Whether the provision infringes the separation of powers and whether the petitioners were entitled to re-sentencing hearings.
  4. Whether the sentencing policy guidelines regarding the mandatory death sentence were operative.
  5. Whether the Supreme Court could declare section 46 of the Prisons Act unconstitutional because it excluded prisoners serving life sentences from being considered for remission.[2]

Arguments Presented

Petitioners’ Argument

The petitioners argued that the mandatory death sentence violated the right to a fair trial under Article 50 of the Constitution because it prevented courts from considering mitigating factors, individual culpability and the circumstances of the offence.

They further contended that it interfered with the Judiciary’s sentencing function by removing judicial discretion. They argued that the mandatory sentence was also inconsistent with Articles 28 and 29(f), and limited the right to appeal under Article 50(2)(q) because appellate courts could not review or alter the mandatory sentence.

Eventually, the petitioners sought immediate release, a definite substitute sentence, or remittal to the High Court for resentencing, alongside damages for prolonged detention on death row.

The Petitioner relied on comparative authorities including: Mithu v State of Punjab, Susan Kigula & 417 Others v Attorney General and Patrick Reyes v The Queen, which addressed the constitutional problems associated with mandatory capital punishment.

Respondent’s Arguments

The Director of Public Prosecutions conceded that the mandatory aspect of death penalty under Section 204 of the Penal Code was unconstitutional however, the State maintained that death penalty itself remained a lawful statutory maximum penalty under Kenyan law and was not per se prohibited by the 2010 Constitution. The prosecution agreed that trial judges should have the discretion to weigh mitigating factors before passing sentences.

They opposed the petitioners’ claims for immediate release or damages, arguing that their murder convictions remained lawful.

The Attorney-General further contended that the sentences had been lawfully imposed under the former Constitution before the 2010 Constitution came into force so the petitioners could not apply new constitutional guarantees to invalidate their original sentences. [3]

Court’s reasoning and analysis

Infringement on the Right to a Fair Trial (Article 50)

The Court held that sentencing is an essential component of a fair trial. A mandatory sentence deprives a trial judge of the ability to consider mitigating factors such as: the offender’s background, age, level of culpability or circumstances surrounding the offense. Therefore, forcing a blanket punishment which renders any evidence or arguments presented in mitigation completely meaningless and denying the accused a meaningful hearing during sentencing. The justices emphasized that mitigation is a critical component of trial proceedings under Sections 216 and 329 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which the mandatory death penalty effectively nullified.

Violation of Separation of Powers (Article 160)

The judiciary holds exclusive constitutional authority over the judicial process, which includes exercising of discretion in passing sentence. By pre-determining a singular outcome for all murder convictions, the Legislature effectively overthrew the judicial function, violating the independence of the courts.

Right to equality and human dignity before the law (Articles 27 & 28)

The Court found that treating different offenders and degrees of murder with the same finality is arbitrary and fails to respect human dignity. The court found support in the case of Woodson v North Carolina, which condemned mandatory sentencing for failing to individualize punishment and the Privy Council’s decision in Reyes v. The Queen.

Offenders convicted of murder were treated differently from convicts who were allowed sentencing mitigation, creating an unjustifiable distinction in law.

Restriction on the Right to Appeal (Article 50(2)(q))

The mandatory nature of the sentence stripped appellate courts of their statutory power to review sentences. Since the sentence was automatically set by law, a convicted person could only appeal their conviction leaving higher courts legally unable to adjust a disproportionate or inappropriate sentence.

Distinction between mandatory and discretionary death penalty

The Court clarified that death penalty itself is not unconstitutional, as Article 26(3) allows the deprivation of life to the extent permitted by law. Instead, it declared unconstitutional mandatory death, turning capital punishment from an automatic sentence into a maximum penalty to be used at a judge’s discretion.

Judgement and ratio decidendi

The court ruled that Section 204 of the Penal Code is unconstitutional since it imposes a mandatory death penalty for murder denying a judge the discretion to consider mitigating factors before passing a sentence. This violates the offender’s fundamental right to a fair trial (Article 50) and human dignity (Article 28) while overstepping the judiciary’s exclusive authority to determine punishment. The death penalty remains in law, but only as a maximum penalty applied at the judge’s discretion.

The Court ordered fresh sentencing hearings for offenders affected by the mandatory death penalty, allowing mitigating factors such as age, remorse, first-offender status and prospects of rehabilitation to be considered.

The petitioners’ cases were then remitted to the High Court for re-sentencing. The Court declined to award damages and directed the relevant State agencies to review the Penal Code in light of the judgment given.

Ratio decidendi: A statutory provision that prescribes a mandatory sentence depriving the courts the discretion to consider mitigating factors and individual circumstances before passing a sentence violates the constitutional right to a fair trial, human dignity, equality before the law and the principle of separation of powers.

Critical analysis

Significance of the decision.

The decision in the case transformed the sentencing jurisprudence in Kenya by declaring mandatory death sentence unconstitutional. The ruling entrenched the right to present mitigating evidence as an important component of a fair trial ensuring punishments are tailored to individual culpability rather than imposed uniformly. The judgment also had a practical impact on prison reform by granting thousands of death-row inmates fresh re-sentencing hearings while effectively reducing capital punishment from an arbitrary obligation to an exceptional discretionary maximum.

Implications and impact

The decision reshaped Kenya’s criminal justice system by granting thousands of long-serving death-row inmates fresh mitigation hearings which resulted to numerous capital sentences being reduced to fixed prison terms or immediate release. By permanently establishing a mandatory two-stage trial process, the ruling ensured that judges must evaluate mitigating factors and individual culpability before determining a punishment. Although the decision caused widespread legal confusion as lower courts attempted to apply its logic to other offenses, the Supreme Court’s 2021 clarification in Muruatetu(ii) strictly confined the precedent to murder charges. The case significantly advanced Kenya’s progress as a de facto abolitionist state by making capital punishment an exceptional, discretionary maximum penalty rather than an automatic requirement. [4]

Critical evaluation

An evaluation of the decision reveals a constitutional achievement damaged by judicial hesitation and operational challenges. While the ruling successfully reclaimed sentencing authority for the judiciary and firmly established mitigation as an essential component of a fair trial, the Supreme Court stopped short of declaring the death penalty inherently unconstitutional leaving capital punishment as a discretionary maximum penalty. Furthermore, the Court faced criticism for its 2021 clarification in Muruatetu(ii) which arbitrarily restricted the ruling strictly to murder cases creating an illogical legal contradiction where mandatory sentences continue to violate fair trial rights for some crimes like robbery with violence but not others. Ultimately, while the judgment advanced human rights in Kenya, its initial lack of a clear implementation framework caused severe administrative chaos and inconsistent sentencing across lower courts.

Conclusion.

The Supreme Court’s decision represents a landmark development in Kenya’s constitutional and sentencing jurisprudence. By declaring the mandatory nature of the death sentence for murder unconstitutional, the Court affirmed the importance of judicial discretion and individualized sentencing. The decision conclusively established that mandatory sentencing violates fundamental human rights, judicial independence and fair trial by taking away a judge’s ability to hear mitigating evidence. While the Supreme Court preserved capital punishment as an exceptional maximum penalty, the ruling transformed Kenyan criminal justice by institutionalizing individualized sentencing, triggering thousands of re-sentencing reviews and affirming that no punishment can be imposed automatically without regard for human dignity.

Ultimately, the case strengthened the constitutional principle that punishment should not be imposed mechanically. It affirmed the judiciary’s responsibility to ensure that sentencing is fair, proportionate and responsive to the individual circumstances of each case therefore contributing significantly to the development of a more rights-conscious criminal justice system in Kenya.

Reference(S):

Table of cases

Attorney General v Susan Kigula & 417 others [2009] UGSC 6.

Bachan Singh v State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684.

Mithu v State of Punjab [1983] 2 SCR 690.

Muruatetu & another v Republic; Katiba Institute & 5 others (Amicus Curiae) (Petitions 15 & 16 of 2015 (Consolidated)) [2017] KESC 2 (KLR) (SC).

Muruatetu & another v Republic; Katiba Institute & 5 others (Amicus Curiae) (Petitions 15 & 16 of 2015) [2021] KESC 31 (KLR).

Reyes v The Queen [2002] 2 AC 235.

Woodson v North Carolina 428 US 280 (1976).

Table of legislation

Constitution of Kenya 2010.

Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 75).

Penal Code (Cap 63).

Prisons Act (Cap 90).

Bibliography

Secondary source

The Judiciary of Kenya, Sentencing Policy Guidelines (2016).

[1][1][1] Francis Karioko Muruatetu & another v Republic; Katiba Institute & 5 others (Amicus Curiae) (Petitions 15 & 16 of 2015 (Consolidated)) [2017] KESC 2 (KLR) (SC) (14 December 2017).

Penal Code (Cap 63), s 204.

Constitution of Kenya 2010, arts 25(c), 27, 28 and 50.

[2][2][2][2][2] Constitution of Kenya 2010, arts 25(c), 27, 28, 48 and 50.

Penal Code (Cap 63), s 204.

Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 75), ss 216 and 329.

Constitution of Kenya 2010, arts 159 and 160.

Prisons Act (Cap 90), s 46.

[3][3][3][3][3][3] Constitution of Kenya 2010, art 50(1).

Constitution of Kenya 2010, art 50(2)(q).

Constitution of Kenya 2010, arts 28 and 29(f).

Mithu v State of Punjab [1983] 2 SCR 690.

Attorney General v Susan Kigula & 417 others [2009] UGSC 6.

Reyes v The Queen [2002] 2 AC 235.

[4] Muruatetu & another v Republic; Katiba Institute & 5 others (Amicus Curiae) (Petitions 15 & 16 of 2015) [2021] KESC 31 (KLR) (SC).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top