Authored By: Jan Maric Malaylay
I. Case Citation and Basic Information
Vedanta Resources PLC and another (Appellants) v Lungowe and others (Respondents) [2019] UKSC 20, Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, 10 April 2019, Lady Hale (President), Lord Wilson, Lord Hodge, Lady Black, Lord Briggs
II. Introduction
In the case of Vedanta Resources PLC v Lungowe,[1] the judgment represents a pressing issue regarding the standards of environmental, social, and governance (ESG): how a parent company can be held accountable for its foreign subsidiary’s negligence and environmental harm in a foreign jurisdiction.
Normally, a parent company would not be held responsible for owing a duty of care, as they are both separate legal entities. However, the principle in Vedanta made a distinction by understanding that the parent company can potentially owe a duty of care based on its own conduct. This case is significant especially in the development of international ESG regulations, where, as a result of globalism and multinational economic development, companies can now have a business in countries outside of their domicile or legal home country, but regulations holding them accountable for their own conduct or their subsidiaries have only recently started to develop.
III. Facts of the Case
Starting from 2005, the Nchanga Copper Mine in the Chingola District of Zambia have been emitting toxic gas that was damaging the health and farming activities of about 1,800 Zambian citizens who live in the same district as the mine. The mine’s owner is Zambia-based Konkola Copper Mines plc (KCM), which is a subsidiary of Vedanta Resources plc (Vedanta), which is based in the United Kingdom. While Vedanta is not a full owner or parent of KCM, as the Zambian government owns a part of it, different publication materials by Vedanta state that KCM is under their full control, which means that they should be treated as a whole owner of the Zambian subsidiary.
In a case before the appeal in the Supreme Court, the Zambian citizens raised a claim against both companies for common law negligence and breach of statutory duty. For KCM, the reason for the claim against them is that they are the sole operator of the mine. For Vedanta, the reason is that they have a very high level of control and direction over KCM’s operation, and as such are responsible for its subsidiary’s compliance with health, safety, and environmental standards.
The company defendants argued against the claim, stating that the English courts had no jurisdiction to hear the cause because the claimants, the mine, and the damage caused by the mine’s toxic emissions were in Zambia, thus concluding that the case should be heard in Zambian courts. However, the High Court found that the claims against the UK-domiciled Vedanta can be brought to the English court, because the case could not be fairly heard in Zambia. Additionally, the case was triable as the claim or concerns relating to negligence and duty of care of Vedanta as KCM’s parent company are legitimate, and both defendants were tried under one case as both of the claims against them were closely similar. The defendants appealed against the High Court judgment in the Court of Appeal, which was rejected. The defendants then appealed the case by bringing it to the Supreme Court.
IV. Legal Issues
The legal issues of the case were as follows:
Whether Vedanta owed the claimants a duty of care for the harm that its subsidiary, KCM, caused?
Does the claim against Vedanta count as a triable claim?
Can the claims against KCM be heard in the English court, despite the harm occurring in Zambian jurisdiction?
V. Arguments Presented
Appellant’s Arguments
Vedanta argued that it does not owe a duty of care to the Zambian citizens, asserting that KCM is a separate legal entity despite being a parent company for it. They also argued that they, Vedanta, were only being sued not for a valid claim, but for the claimants to use the company to be an ‘artificial anchor’ for KCM to be brought onto the English courts through Article 4 of the Recast Brussels Regulation, asserting that the claimants are abusing the Regulation for this reason. Additionally, both defendants argued that England does not have the jurisdiction to hear the claims, citing forum non conveniens. They maintained that since the damage occurred in Zambia, and the claimants are Zambian, the case should be heard in the Zambian courts.
Respondent’s Arguments
The Zambian citizens argued that Vedanta does owe a duty of care because the company has a high level of control and direction over KCM. They also contended the point of EU law abuse, stating that the claim against Vedanta is for the company’s own negligence due to its management of KCM, and only when the English court accepted jurisdiction for the claim against Vedanta would KCM be included in the same claim as a ‘necessary and proper party’. They also argued against using the Zambian courts as the forum for the claim, because they expected that they could not receive substantial justice considering that they were extremely poor, there is a lack of legal aid, and that the Zambian courts themselves lack resources to tackle such a complex legal issue.
VI. Court’s Reasoning and Analysis
The judgment, delivered by Lord Briggs, was divided into three sections based on the legal issues of the case: parent company liability, jurisdiction, and substantial justice.
Usually, a parent company would not be liable for any legal infractions of its subsidiary, no matter if they are an indirect or direct shareholder of the subsidiary company.[2] Vedanta argued with this, stating that the case will have to involve or create a new category of common law negligence liability outside of the case in Chandler v Cape,[3] a case that the claimants chose to submit against the defendants, further contending that Vedanta’s case is not at all similar to the case in Chandler. However, it was reasoned that while it is not the same, the four-part test in Chandler is not to be considered as a strict legal test; rather it acts as an example in proving how much control does the parent company have over its subsidiary.[4] Furthermore, a parent company may incur a duty of care through implementation of its group-wide policies or if it provides specific management of the subsidiary itself.[5]
The court also addressed the issue of jurisdiction. Vedanta argued that the claimants abused EU law by bringing the claim against the company only to create a necessary pathway for KCM to be brought into English courts. It was reasoned otherwise, stating that the claimant has the right to sue Vedanta in England not only because Vedanta is domiciled there,[6] but because they have a genuine claim against the company, as shown through the negligence claim.
Lastly, the court addressed the issue of substantial justice, whether the claimants can receive it in the Zambian courts where it is supposed to be the natural forum of the case. Initially, if the case against Vedanta were to be dismissed, the hearing for the claim against KCM would have no ties with Vedanta, thus having the case fall back to the jurisdiction of the Zambian courts. Furthermore, if the claimants can receive substantial justice through the local jurisdiction, then there was no need to bring KCM into the English courts.[7] On the contrary, it was proven that the claimant could not receive substantial justice even if the local court could hear the case because of lack of legal aid and resources.[8] Through this, the claim against KCM was able to be heard in the English court, alongside Vedanta’s case as both are very similar and to prevent fragmented litigation.[9]
VII. Judgement and Ratio Decidendi
The courts ruled in favour of the Zambian citizens, granting them the right to pursue the claims of negligence against both defendants under English jurisdiction. The ratio decidendi of the case concerns both the doctrine of parent company liability and jurisdiction. Whether the parent company owe a duty of care over the subsidiary’s operations is determined by the company’s degree of control or supervision over the subsidiary, rather than assuming that a parent company will not always be at fault for their subsidiary’s operations. Additionally, the English courts can assert jurisdiction over a foreign subsidiary alongside its parent company if domiciled in the UK, if there is a real risk that the claimants cannot obtain substantial justice if the case is heard back in their local jurisdiction.
VIII. Critical Analysis
Significance of the Decision
The decision in Vedanta is significant because it answers the question of whether a company can potentially owe a duty of care to others in a foreign jurisdiction. In times when globalisation is natural, and businesses create branches in foreign countries, this decision is critical because it shows that despite being a separate legal entity from a subsidiary, especially if it is foreign, a parent company could still be held accountable for its subsidiary’s actions, even in foreign jurisdictions. Furthermore, the decision showed that English courts could accept jurisdiction over cases of UK-domiciled companies from foreign jurisdictions, as long as there is a valid reason to do so, like lack of substantial justice.
Implications and Impact
The decision has a huge impact in terms of the economic, social, and governance (ESG) sector. With the goals of the SDGs still far from being achieved, this decision could be a foundation for new regulations regarding foreign-owned subsidiaries and their potential environmental impact, further strengthening ESG-related laws. It is significant because parent companies often , which is especially common for companies domiciled in the UK. This decision also made the English courts a top court for handling ESG-related litigation, with ESG-related cases expected to become more common.[11]
Critical Evaluation
While the decision remains crucial, especially for the ESG sector, the case happened before the UK left the EU through Brexit. This drastically changed how the English courts would treat jurisdictional hearings. As an EU law, the Recast Brussels Regulation would still remain persuasive, but no longer binding, leading to English courts being able to assess whether they can accept or decline a case’s jurisdiction. However, the ratio decidendi and reasoning of the court regarding the point of lack of substantial justice is still applied post-Brexit,[12] which meant that Vedanta’s case will still retain its significance, especially for multinational parent companies with foreign subsidiaries.
IX. Conclusion
To conclude, the judgment and decision of the case reiterate that parent companies are not always protected by the corporate veil, which expands the parent company liability doctrine in the tort of negligence. Specifically, the Supreme Court expanded on the test in Chandler, stating that the four parts it outlined acted merely as an example, not as a strict legal test. It also provides a foundation for future cases revolving around jurisdictional issues, especially when it concerns parties of foreign nationalities. Despite the judgment being passed pre-Brexit, it remains a strong case law in terms of litigating against multinational companies in the English court, especially in the area of ESG when issues surrounding human rights and environmental impacts are becoming a common point in such litigation.
Bibliography
Primary Sources:
Case Law
Vedanta Resources PLC v Lungowe [2019] UKSC 20
Chandler v Cape plc [2012] EWCA Civ 525
EU Legislation
Regulation (EU) 1215/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2012 on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters (Recast) [2012] OJ L351/1
Secondary Sources:
Books
Barnali Choudhury & Martin Petrin, Corporate Duties to the Public (Cambridge University Press 2019)
Websites & Blogs
Climate disputes – Parent company and supply chain risk’ (Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer, 14 November 2023) <https://www.hsfkramer.com/notes/esg/2023-11/climate-disputes-parent-company-and-supply-chain-risk> accessed 1 August 2026
Curle J and others, ‘The Vedanta decision and Eu law: a post-brexit outlook on parent company liability’ (DLA Piper, 25 April 2019) <https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=0538bd23-96ad-4dae-80c8-87f61de83c75> accessed 1 August 2026
Sibley M, ‘Parent Company Liability Post-Vedanta’ (Ashurst Perkins Coie, 5 February 2026) <https://www.ashurstperkinscoie.com/en/insights/parent-company-liability-post-vedanta/> accessed 1 August 2026
[1] [2019] UKSC 20.
[2] Barnali Choudhury & Martin Petrin, Corporate Duties to the Public (Cambridge University Press 2019), p 94.
[3] [2012] EWCA Civ 525.
[4] Vedanta, para 49-51.
[5] para 53.
[6] para 79.
[7] para 87.
[8] para 88-90.
[9] para 69.
[10] ‘Climate disputes – Parent company and supply chain risk’ (Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer, 14 November 2023) <https://www.hsfkramer.com/notes/esg/2023-11/climate-disputes-parent-company-and-supply-chain-risk> accessed 1 August 2026.
[11] Melissa Sibley, ‘Parent Company Liability Post-Vedanta’ (Ashurst Perkins Coie, 5 February 2026) <https://www.ashurstperkinscoie.com/en/insights/parent-company-liability-post-vedanta/> accessed 1 August 2026.
[12] Jamie Curle and others, ‘The Vedanta decision and Eu law: a post-brexit outlook on parent company liability’ (DLA Piper, 25 April 2019) <https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=0538bd23-96ad-4dae-80c8-87f61de83c75> accessed 1 August 2026.
https://www.hsfkramer.com/notes/esg/2023-11/climate-disputes-parent-company-and-supply-chain-risk

