Home » Blog » Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India

Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India

Authored By: Aryaman Bandi

MS Ramaiah College of Law

1) Case Citation and Basic Information

  • Full case name: Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India1
  • Citation: AIR 2020 SC 1308
  • Court: Supreme Court of India
  • Date of decision: 10 January 2020
  • Bench composition: Justice N. V. Ramana, Justice R. Subhash Reddy and Justice B. R. Gavai

2) Introduction

The case of Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India arose from the extensive restrictions imposed on communication, movement and internet services in Jammu & Kashmir (J&K) in August 2019. The petitioners challenged these restrictions before the Supreme Court of India (SC), arguing that the Government had infringed their Fundamental Rights, mainly the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) and the freedom to practise any profession under Article 19(1)(g). Furthermore, the case raised important questions about the Government’s power to restrict internet access in the interests of public order and national security, and whether the restrictions imposed were reasonable.

3) Facts of the Case

The parties to this case were as follows.1 The petitioners were (1) Anuradha Bhasin, the Executive Director of the Kashmir Times, who mainly looks after the publication of its Srinagar edition, and (2) Ghulam Nabi Azad, a Member of Parliament. The respondents were the Union of India, represented by (1) Mr. K.K. Venugopal, then Attorney General for India, and (2) the State of Jammu & Kashmir, represented by Mr. Tushar Mehta, then Solicitor General.

Ms. Bhasin submitted that the internet is a necessity in today’s era and that, because of the shutdown, she was unable to publish her newspaper. She went on to argue that the internet suspension orders were not based on any material grounds and had been passed only because of a perceived threat to law and order.

Mr. Ghulam Nabi Azad, as stated above, was a Member of Parliament. He mainly argued that the Government cannot claim privilege to resist producing administrative orders before the Court. He also argued that an “emergency” can be declared only under certain specific conditions. In the present case, there was no evidence of any internal disturbance in the country or of external aggression from neighbouring countries, and hence the suspension of the internet on the ground of public emergency was unjustified.

The Attorney General, Mr. K.K. Venugopal, placed before the Court the background of the ongoing terrorism in J&K, which had to be taken into account. He argued that, before the order was passed, the problems of the State had been taken into consideration, and that it would have been foolish not to take preventive measures to cool down the situation.

The Solicitor General, Mr. Tushar Mehta, submitted that the first and foremost duty of the State is to protect its citizens and that, keeping the history of J&K in mind, the internet suspension measures had to be taken.

4) Legal Issues

The main legal issues raised in Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India were as follows.

  1. Whether the Government’s action of prohibiting access to the internet in J&K was legally valid.
  2. Whether the Government could claim exemption from producing the orders passed under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) and the Telecom Suspension Rules.
  3. Whether the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), and the freedom to practise any profession or carry on any trade or business under Article 19(1)(g), through the internet constitute fundamental rights.
  4. Whether the restrictions imposed on the petitioner violated the freedom of the press.

5) Arguments Presented

I) Petitioner’s Arguments

Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1031 of 2019 was filed by Ms. Anuradha Bhasin. She pleaded that neither public order nor law and order was in any danger, and that the orders were therefore unconstitutional and irrelevant.

The petitioner argued that the restrictions under Section 144 fail the constitutional test of “reasonableness and proportionality”, as no evidence supports the claimed threat to law and order. She also submitted that the internet suspension was procedurally flawed and too broad, and that it violated fundamental rights without adopting less restrictive measures.

The petitioner further contended that the suspension of the internet was not in accordance with the Temporary Suspension of Telecom Services (Public Emergency or Public Safety) Rules, 2017 (the “Telecom Suspension Rules”). The Government had not provided any reasons for the suspension, and hence it infringed those rules.

The other petitioner, Mr. Ghulam Nabi Azad, pleaded that the suspension of the internet was unjustified and wrong. An order under Section 144 of the CrPC can be issued only in cases of a breach, or an apprehension of a breach, of law and order. In the present case, there was no such breach or apprehension of danger. What the Government should have done was to impose restrictions on the people likely to disturb public order and peace. Instead, it imposed blanket restrictions on the entire State, which violated the Fundamental Rights of many citizens.

Mr. Azad further argued that the restrictions on communication had prevented him from travelling to J&K and from communicating with the people there.

II) Respondents’ Arguments

The Attorney General, Mr. K.K. Venugopal, argued that the background of terrorism in J&K had been taken into account, and that the problems of the State had been considered before the order was passed. If the order had not been passed, it would have led to large-scale violence affecting many people and disturbing public order. Hence, the action was justified.

The Solicitor General, Mr. Tushar Mehta, argued that such measures had to be taken as the State was suffering from both physical and digital cross-border terrorism. He also stated that individual movements were never restricted, and that the suspension of the internet was gradually relaxed rather than imposed as a permanent ban.

He further submitted that the internet was never fully restricted in J&K. It was suspended only because social media, which relies on the internet, allows a large number of messages to be sent to a large number of people at once, which can incite violence and anger. These messages, which relied on the internet, were mostly fake news and false images. He also contended that the dark web is used to buy and sell illegal weapons, which may then be distributed to aggrieved parties who start a conflict.

6) Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Court held that the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), and the freedom to practise any profession or carry on any trade, business or occupation under Article 19(1)(g), are protected over the internet.2 Any restriction placed on these Fundamental Rights must satisfy a four-pronged test of proportionality, which requires that the restriction:

  1. must serve a legitimate aim;
  2. must have a rational connection to that aim;
  3. must be the least restrictive means, that is, there must be no equally effective but less restrictive alternative available; and
  4. must not have a disproportionate impact on the right-holder.

On the freedom of the press, the Court recognised the chilling effect that communication blackouts can have on the press. However, it did not find that press freedom was violated in this specific case, as there was no factual evidence directly showing that media operations were targeted.

The Court referred to prior cases such as:

  1. Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India, (2017) 10 SCC 1
  2. Babulal Parate v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1961 SC 884

7) Judgment and Ratio Decidendi

The Supreme Court directed the Government to publish all orders imposing restrictions, including those affecting internet access, so that individuals can challenge them before the appropriate legal forums.

The Government has wide powers, including the power to suspend internet services, but only temporarily and not permanently. Furthermore, the Court held that restrictions under Section 144 of the CrPC cannot be used to stifle legitimate dissent. It also established that the freedom of speech and expression and the right to pursue a profession or business online, enshrined in Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, can be limited only where the restrictions pass the proportionality test. While indefinite internet shutdowns are impermissible, restrictions must be temporary, proportionate and subject to judicial review.

Ratio Decidendi

The ratio decidendi of Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India is that the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), and the freedom to practise any profession or carry on any trade or business under Article 19(1)(g), are fundamental rights that extend to the internet.

8) Critical Analysis

Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India is an important judgment because it placed constitutional limits on the Government’s power to impose internet restrictions while recognising the importance of the internet to Fundamental Rights. A major strength of the judgment is its emphasis on necessity, proportionality and the least restrictive measure. The Supreme Court made it clear that the State cannot impose restrictions merely because it finds them convenient, and that the extent and duration of a suspension must correspond directly to the actual threat being addressed. It also prohibited indefinite internet shutdowns and required suspension orders to be published and subjected to judicial review.

However, the judgment has also been criticised for its limited remedial relief. Even though the Court recognised the constitutional importance of internet-based freedoms, it did not order an immediate restoration of internet services in J&K. Many critics have argued that this weakened the practical impact of the Court’s otherwise strong constitutional principles.

Another limitation is that the Court did not recognise access to the internet as an independent Fundamental Right in this case. Instead, it protected the exercise of existing fundamental rights through the internet. While this approach provides constitutional protection against arbitrary shutdowns, a stronger recognition of internet access could have provided clearer protection in an increasingly digital society.

9) Conclusion

In conclusion, Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India is a landmark judgment that strengthened the constitutional protection of digital freedoms in India. The Supreme Court recognised that the freedom of speech and expression and the freedom to carry on a profession through the internet are protected under Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g), subject to constitutionally permissible restrictions. Any such restriction must be proportionate, temporary, published and open to judicial review. Although the judgment stopped short of declaring internet access an independent fundamental right or ordering immediate restoration of services, it remains a key safeguard against arbitrary internet shutdowns.

Footnote(S):

1 Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India & Ors,(2020) 3 SCC 637, Supreme Court of India, judgment dated 10 January 2020.

1 https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/28817/28817_2019_2_1501_19350_Judgement_10-Jan2020.pdf

2 https://blog.ipleaders.in/anuradha-bhasin-v-union-of-india-case-analysis/

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top