Authored By: Sara Jamil
Punjab College
Case Details
Case: Jadhav (India v. Pakistan), Judgment, I.C.J. Reports 2019, p. 418.[1]
Date of Decision: July 17, 2019
Bench Composition: The 16 judges who comprised the bench for the final judgment were Abdulqawi Ahmed Yusuf (President), Xue Hanqin (Vice-President), Peter Tomka, Ronny Abraham, Mohamed Bennouna, Antônio Augusto Cançado Trindade, Joan Donoghue, Giorgio Gaja, Julia Sebutinde, Dalveer Bhandari, Patrick Lipton Robinson, James Richard Crawford, Kirill Gevorgian, Nawaf Salam, Yuji Iwasawa, and Tassaduq Hussain Jillani (Judge ad hoc).
Consular Access: Consular access is the legal right of a country’s diplomatic and consular officials to communicate with, visit, and provide legal assistance to their citizens who have been arrested, detained, or imprisoned in a foreign country. This right is codified globally under Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations (VCCR) 1963,[2] a multilateral treaty ratified by most nations, including India and Pakistan.
1. Introduction
Kulbhushan Sudhir Jadhav is an Indian national. The Pakistani government alleges that he was arrested in the Pakistani province of Balochistan on charges of terrorism and of spying for India’s intelligence agency, the Research and Analysis Wing (RAW). On April 10, 2017, India’s Foreign Minister said he had been “kidnapped last year from Iran and his subsequent presence in Pakistan has never been explained credibly”. The Pakistani government stated that he was a serving commander in the Indian Navy who was involved in subversive activities inside Pakistan and was arrested on March 3, 2016, during a counterintelligence operation in Balochistan. The Indian government recognised Jadhav as a former naval officer but denied any current links with him, and maintained that he had taken premature retirement and was abducted from Iran.
On April 10, 2017, Jadhav was sentenced to death by a Field General Court Martial in Pakistan. On May 18, 2017, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) stayed the execution pending its final judgment.[3] On July 17, 2019, the Court rejected India’s request for Jadhav’s release and held that Pakistan must keep the execution suspended pending an effective review of the conviction and sentence, and must provide consular access.
The ruling establishes that domestic security claims or counter-terrorism measures do not exempt a state from fulfilling baseline international treaty obligations regarding fair consular notification. The case highlighted international legal skepticism regarding the use of military courts to try foreign civilians for capital offenses without full adherence to due process standards. It also demonstrated how adversarial neighbours can use the ICJ to de-escalate immediate flashpoints (such as an imminent execution) and shift a high-stakes geopolitical conflict into a formalised legal framework.
2. Facts
The facts of the case were disputed by India and Pakistan. According to Pakistan, Jadhav was in possession of an Indian passport bearing the name “Hussein Mubarak Patel”, a claim denied by India. In support of its allegations, Pakistan released a video in which Jadhav appeared to confess to involvement in espionage and terrorism in Pakistan at the behest of RAW (para. 22). On March 25, 2016, the same day the video was released, India requested consular access to Jadhav at the earliest date. India sent more than ten Notes Verbales to Pakistan in which it identified Jadhav as an Indian national and sought consular access to him. The Court declined to admit the video on procedural grounds, but it did not say that the video was fake.
Jadhav’s trial began on September 21, 2016, before a Field General Court Martial. On January 23, 2017, Pakistan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs sent a letter to the High Commission of India in Islamabad seeking support in obtaining evidence for the criminal investigation. In response, India requested consular access to Jadhav, but Pakistan’s Foreign Ministry explained that India’s request would be considered only in light of India’s response to Pakistan’s request for assistance in the investigation and the early dispensation of justice. On March 31, 2017, India replied that consular access to Jadhav was an essential prerequisite to verify the facts and understand the circumstances of his presence in Pakistan. Less than two weeks later, on April 10, Pakistan announced that Jadhav had been sentenced to death.
On May 8, 2017, India instituted proceedings against Pakistan before the ICJ under Article 36, paragraph 1, of the Statute of the Court and Article I of the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations concerning the Compulsory Settlement of Disputes (Optional Protocol), alleging violations of the VCCR by Pakistan.[4] In assessing its jurisdiction, the ICJ observed that India and Pakistan have been parties to the VCCR since December 28, 1977, and May 14, 1969, respectively. Both were also parties to the Optional Protocol at the time the Application was filed, and remain so at the time of writing, and neither had made any reservation or declaration.
3. Legal Issues and Arguments Presented
3.1 Applicability of the Vienna Convention vs. Bilateral Agreements
India argued that Article 36 of the VCCR provides an unconditional right to consular access, and that no domestic law or bilateral treaty can override this multilateral obligation. Pakistan argued that the VCCR does not automatically apply to cases involving espionage and terrorism. It relied heavily on the 2008 India-Pakistan Bilateral Agreement on Consular Access,[5] which contains a clause allowing either state to handle matters involving national security on their political merits rather than on legal mandates.
3.2 Customary International Law Exceptions for Espionage
Pakistan contended that, under customary international law, individuals accused of espionage are excluded from consular assistance because of national security thresholds. India maintained that the text of the VCCR is absolute and makes no explicit exception for spy or terror suspects.
3.3 Evidentiary Value of the Confession and Abuse of Process
Pakistan argued that India’s application was an “abuse of process” because India refused to assist in the criminal investigation and did not clarify Jadhav’s citizenship or his possession of an allegedly fake passport bearing a Muslim alias. India challenged the validity of Jadhav’s trial by a military tribunal, asserting that the recorded confession was coerced under duress and lacked legal credibility under international due process standards.
3.4 Definition of “Effective Review and Reconsideration”
India argued that a review by Pakistani military courts would be biased, and requested restitutio in integrum (restoration to the original state), meaning annulment of the death sentence, Jadhav’s release, and his safe passage back to India. Pakistan argued that its domestic judicial system already offers High Court and Supreme Court constitutional appeal routes that are sufficient to review military trial decisions.
4. The Court’s Reasoning and Decision
The Jadhav case is consistent with the ICJ’s earlier jurisprudence on Article 36 of the VCCR in LaGrand (Germany v. United States)[6] and Avena and Other Mexican Nationals (Mexico v. United States),[7] where the Court held that Article 36 obliges states parties to provide consular communication, access, and visitation to detained nationals of other VCCR states parties without delay. The broader importance of Jadhav is that it makes clear that these obligations apply to all nationals of VCCR states parties in the territory of another state party, including those accused of terrorism and espionage, even where nationality is disputed by one of the parties.
The ICJ announced its verdict, ruling that Jadhav must be allowed consular access immediately and directing Pakistan to ensure “the effective review and reconsideration of his conviction and sentence”.
The ICJ, however, did not order the annulment of the military court decision convicting Jadhav, an outright bar on executing the sentence, his release, or his return to India. It did hold that a continued stay of execution is an indispensable condition for effective review and reconsideration.
5. My Analysis
The Court’s decision was 15 to 1 in favour of India. However, both countries appear to be claiming the ruling as a victory. Fahd Husain, executive editor of the Express Tribune, termed the ruling “not too bad for Pakistan” and “pretty bad for India”. Similarly, Indian media claimed victory.
In my opinion, the main question was about Jadhav: hanged or freed. Yet, amid all the headlines, he remains in a Pakistani prison. Pakistan began providing consular access to Jadhav on September 2, 2019, respecting the decision.[8] In May 2020, Pakistan offered Jadhav the right to file a review petition in court, but disputes arose over who should represent him: an international lawyer, an Indian lawyer, or someone else. Pakistan then invited India to pursue the case of the man it alleges to be a spy in the Islamabad High Court, in line with the ICJ judgment.[9] Why, then, has no decision yet been made?
I ask this question: if the countries were not Pakistan and India, what could have been the fate of Jadhav? Why can an Indian national not visit Lahore, and why is a Pakistani national not given a visa for India? The answer is that, although the UK was the reason for our partition, it is we who hate each other, not them. That rightly explains our collective fragile ego, which separated two brothers, caused riots over languages, and shaped the fate of Jadhav as well.
6. Conclusion
It is not entirely clear what will happen next. The ICJ stated that Pakistan may decide how best to provide an “effective review” of Jadhav’s conviction and sentence, but it seemed to suggest that a review by a civilian High Court would be suitable. The case is a major issue in Pakistan, where it is seen as evidence that India supports militant separatist groups in places like Balochistan province. Pakistani authorities want this allegation to receive the kind of prominence and international attention attached to more widely known claims that Pakistan supports anti-Indian jihadist groups.
However, the question remains the same: what about Jadhav? He is still in a Pakistani prison, while India and Pakistan each claim leverage, proof of innocence, and terrorism allegations against the other. What is left for a common man like Jadhav?
References
[1] Jadhav (India v. Pak.), Judgment, 2019 I.C.J. Rep. 418 (July 17).
[2] Vienna Convention on Consular Relations art. 36, Apr. 24, 1963, 596 U.N.T.S. 261.
[3] Jadhav (India v. Pak.), Provisional Measures, Order of May 18, 2017, 2017 I.C.J. Rep. 231.
[4] Statute of the International Court of Justice art. 36, ¶ 1, June 26, 1945, 59 Stat. 1055, T.S. No. 993; Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations Concerning the Compulsory Settlement of Disputes art. I, Apr. 24, 1963, 596 U.N.T.S. 487.
[5] Agreement on Consular Access, India-Pak., May 21, 2008.
[6] LaGrand (Ger. v. U.S.), Judgment, 2001 I.C.J. Rep. 466 (June 27).
[7] Avena and Other Mexican Nationals (Mex. v. U.S.), Judgment, 2004 I.C.J. Rep. 12 (Mar. 31).
[8] Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Islamabad, Pakistan, [specific statement and date to be supplied by author].
[9] Delhi Invited to Pursue Jadhav Case in IHC, Express Trib., https://tribune.com.pk/story/2253927/delhi-invited-to-pursue-jadhav-case-in-ihc.
Bibliography
(a) Usman Hameed et al., Kulbhushan Jadhav Case: A Mystery of a Win-Win Situation for Pakistan and India, 8(4) Multicultural Educ. 233 (2022).
(b) Jadhav Case (India v. Pakistan), 113 Am. J. Int’l L. [volume, page and year to be supplied by author], https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-journal-of-international-law/article/jadhav-case-india-v-pakistan.
(c) Defence Journal, [article title, author, date and full URL to be supplied by author] (www.defencejournal.com).
(d) The Ultimate Current Affairs for CSS (2024) [author and publisher to be supplied by author].

