Home » Blog » The Republic of Philippines v. The People’s Republic of China

The Republic of Philippines v. The People’s Republic of China

Authored By: Shivam Bansal

Bhai Gurdas College of Law, Sangrur

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES v. PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF CHINA

(The South China Sea Arbitration), ICGJ 495 (PCA 2016)

In the Permanent Court of Arbitration; PCA Case No. 2013-19

Award of July 12, 2016

Before Judge Thomas A. Mensah, Judge Jean-Pierre Cot, Judge Stanisław Pawlak, Professor Alfred H.A. Soons, and Judge Rüdiger Wolfrum

INTRODUCTION

The South China Sea Arbitration, as the name suggests, revolves around the dispute between China and the Philippines over maritime entitlements in the South China Sea and the lawfulness of the two countries’ activities in its waters. It was important to litigate the matter because, although the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea had established the legal basis governing maritime rights and jurisdiction, the absence of judicial interpretation on crucial matters such as historic rights and the legal status of maritime features allowed competing theories to persist, which in turn fuelled conflict between the two countries over their maritime rights. The case thus paved the way for future interpretations of maritime entitlements under UNCLOS.

FACTS OF THE CASE

The South China Sea is a strategic location in the Pacific Ocean, to the south of China and to the west of the Philippines. It is an important shipping lane, a rich fishing ground, a home to biodiverse coral reef ecosystems, and is believed to hold extensive oil and gas resources. The epicentre of the dispute is the 1982 Convention on the Law of the Sea. The Convention was adopted as a “constitution for the oceans” in order to settle all issues relating to the law of the sea, and both parties to the dispute have ratified it. After the adoption of UNCLOS, maritime rights had to be determined according to the maritime zones established by the Convention, but China asserted historic rights within an area represented by its “nine-dash line”. The central dispute therefore concerned the source and extent of China’s claimed maritime rights in the sea. There was also considerable confusion regarding the legal status of several maritime features in the sea. A further part of the dispute concerned China’s allegedly unlawful activities in the disputed maritime areas, which included interference with Philippine fishing and petroleum exploration, and large-scale land reclamation and construction. These activities interfered with the enjoyment of the Philippines’ maritime rights under UNCLOS and also caused serious harm to the marine environment. Aggrieved by China’s actions, the Philippines therefore brought the matter before the Permanent Court of Arbitration under Part XV and Annex VII of the Convention, which provide for compulsory dispute settlement through arbitration. Although China did not participate in the proceedings, the Tribunal proceeded with the case.

Legal Framework Involved

The legal framework applicable to the dispute is the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, 1982, which lays down detailed rules on maritime rights and jurisdiction. UNCLOS recognises a coastal State’s sovereignty over its Territorial Sea under Article 3 (up to 12 nautical miles), and confers rights over the Contiguous Zone under Article 33 (up to 24 nautical miles) and, most relevant to this case, sovereign rights over natural resources in the Exclusive Economic Zone under Articles 56 and 57 (up to 200 nautical miles). These provisions stand in direct contrast to China’s vast “nine-dash line” assertion, which has no basis in the Convention. Another important provision was Article 121, which provides that rocks which cannot sustain human habitation or economic life of their own do not generate an EEZ or a continental shelf. The Tribunal therefore had to decide the legal status of several maritime features in the sea. The dispute also involved the protection of the marine environment under Part XII of UNCLOS, particularly Articles 192 and 194.

LEGAL ISSUES

The issues raised before the Tribunal fall broadly into three categories. The central issue was the source of maritime rights and entitlements in the South China Sea, that is, whether these rights and entitlements are based on the Convention or on historic rights. Secondly, the Tribunal had to decide the legal status of the maritime zones that Scarborough Shoal and certain other maritime features could generate under the Convention, and in particular whether they could generate an exclusive economic zone or an entitlement to a continental shelf. Thirdly, the Philippines asked the Tribunal to rule on the lawfulness of China’s actions in the South China Sea.

ARGUMENTS

ON THE ISSUE OF HISTORIC RIGHTS

China rejected the arbitration and adopted a position of “non-acceptance and non-participation”, but it communicated its position through public statements and diplomatic correspondence. Through these, China claimed sovereign jurisdiction over the water, seabed and marine features of the South China Sea beyond the jurisdiction given to it under UNCLOS. It defended its claims on the basis of “historic rights” to these areas, and it has drawn an imaginary dashed line, composed of nine segments, that encloses most of the waters of the sea. According to China, its historic rights came into existence long before the Convention and are not subject to its provisions. This, it argued, entitles China to sovereign rights even in areas within 200 nautical miles of the Philippines’ coast. The Philippines opposed the claim, contending that the Chinese claims extend beyond the islands per se and their adjacent waters to the relevant waters, seabed and subsoil within the Philippines’ own maritime zones, and thereby interfere with the Philippines’ exercise of its rights to exploit the living and non-living resources of the area. The Philippines further argued that China’s claim has no legal, historical or factual basis and is therefore null and void.

ON THE LEGAL STATUS OF MARITIME FEATURES

The Philippines also presented arguments on the nature and maritime entitlements of features in the sea that are claimed by both parties but occupied or controlled by the PRC. These features include Scarborough Shoal in the northern sector of the sea and eight insular features in the Spratly Islands in the southern sector. The Philippines claimed that these features are rocks or groups of rocks under Article 121(3), low-tide elevations, or submerged banks, but not islands, and thus argued that none of them generates an entitlement to an EEZ or a continental shelf, as China claims for them.

ON THE LAWFULNESS OF CHINA’S ACTIONS

The Philippines further contended that China has violated the Convention and the rights of the Philippines by:

  1. unlawfully interfering with the enjoyment and exercise of sovereign rights with respect to the living and non-living resources of the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone and continental shelf;
  2. failing to protect and preserve the marine environment through the harvesting of endangered species and the use of harmful fishing methods at Scarborough Shoal and Second Thomas Shoal;
  3. inflicting severe harm on the marine environment through the construction of artificial islands and extensive land reclamation at seven reefs in the Spratly Islands; and
  4. unlawfully aggravating and extending the dispute by preventing the rotation and resupply of Philippine personnel and interfering with the Philippines’ rights of navigation in the waters, among other things.

TRIBUNAL’S REASONING AND ANALYSIS

In general, the Tribunal relied upon UNCLOS, prior international law and the 1958 Conventions on the Law of the Sea in reasoning its way through the dispute. According to the judges, the Convention establishes a comprehensive system for determining the limits of maritime entitlements and lays down the rights and duties of States within the maritime zones. For the interpretation of the Convention, the Tribunal relied upon Article 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties1, which provides that a treaty “shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning to be given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in the light of its object and purpose.” The Tribunal also emphasised that China’s non-participation did not prevent it from proceeding, and that it independently examined the evidence and the applicable law before reaching its conclusions.

To decide the issue of historic rights, the Tribunal considered it necessary first to examine the relationship between the Convention and other possible sources of international law. For this purpose, it took notice of Articles 293(1) and 311 of the Convention, from which it interpreted that any source of international law that is incompatible with the provisions of the Convention is not applicable. The Tribunal was of the view that the text and context of the Convention supersede any historic rights that a State may once have had in the areas that now form part of the EEZs and the continental shelf. The Tribunal further relied upon the decision in the Gulf of Maine dispute2 between the United States and Canada, declared as customary law, to confirm its own interpretation of the provisions of the Convention.

The Tribunal further took notice of Articles 13 and 121(1) and (3) of the Convention to determine whether the various maritime features in the sea could generate an EEZ and a continental shelf. It focused on the natural capacity of each feature, as per Article 13, and disregarded any human modification made to them by China. The Tribunal therefore used the best available evidence of the previous status of these features to arrive at its decision, since, according to it, artificial modifications cannot change the legal character of a maritime feature.

With respect to the environment, the Tribunal took notice of the Preamble and Articles 192 and 194 of UNCLOS as imposing obligations upon States to protect and preserve the marine environment. It also considered scientific and expert evidence concerning China’s construction and land reclamation activities.

JUDGMENT AND RATIO DECIDENDI

The Tribunal delivered its final award on July 12, 2016. On the first issue, the Tribunal held that, as between the disputing parties, China’s claims to historic rights in the South China Sea encompassed by the “nine-dash line” are contrary to the Convention and without lawful effect to the extent that they exceed the limits of China’s maritime rights under the Convention. The ratio decidendi is that the Tribunal believes UNCLOS alone defines the scope of maritime entitlements in the South China Sea and supersedes any other source of international law.

On the second issue, the legal status of maritime features, the Tribunal held that none of the contested features, even those that are high-tide features, is capable of sustaining human habitation or an economic life of its own in its natural form. Therefore, they are legally “rocks” under Article 121(3) and cannot generate entitlements to an EEZ or a continental shelf, and hence there is no possible entitlement by China.

On the third issue, the Tribunal recorded the following findings:

  1. That China, through the operation of marine surveillance vessels and by promulgating its fishing moratorium, breached Articles 56 and 77 of the Convention and thus interfered with the Philippines’ sovereign rights over the living and non-living resources.
  2. That China, through its fishing vessels engaged in harmful harvesting of endangered species and through its island-building activities, caused significant damage to the marine environment.
  3. That China, in the course of these proceedings, aggravated and extended the disputes between the parties through its dredging, artificial island-building and construction activities.

CRITICAL ANALYSIS

The South China Sea Arbitration is significant because it attempted to clarify the relationship between historic maritime claims and the maritime regime established by UNCLOS. With its decision, the Tribunal laid the groundwork for future interpretations of maritime entitlements under UNCLOS. However, its treatment of historic rights has attracted considerable criticism. The Tribunal’s decision that incompatible historic rights were superseded by the UNCLOS regime is significant, but the precise relationship between the two remains a complex question. Overall, the Award represents a major development in the law of the sea, maritime features and environmental obligations.

CONCLUSION

The South China Sea Arbitration is a landmark decision in international maritime law, particularly for clarifying the relationship between historic rights and UNCLOS-based maritime entitlements. The Tribunal’s interpretation of maritime features and environmental obligations strengthened the rules governing the use and protection of marine waters. Although the Award did not resolve questions of territorial sovereignty and faces challenges of enforcement owing to China’s rejection of the decision, it still remains an important authority demonstrating the role of UNCLOS and international arbitration in resolving complex maritime disputes.

REFERENCE(S):

  1. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, 1982.
  2. The Republic of the Philippines v. The People’s Republic of China, 33 R.I.A.A. 153 (PCA 2016).
  3. Stefan Talmon, The South China Sea Arbitration: Observations on the Award on Jurisdiction and Admissibility, 15 Chinese J. Int’l L. 309 (2016), https://doi.org/10.1093/chinesejil/jmw025.
  4. Warwick Gullett, The South China Sea Arbitration’s Contribution to the Concept of Juridical Islands, QIL (September 12, 2026, 9:29 PM), https://www.qil-qdi.org/south-china-sea-arbitrations-contribution-concept-juridical-islands/.

FOOTNOTE(S):

1 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 1969, art. 31

2 Delimitation of the Maritime Boundary in the Gulf of Maine Area (Canada v. United States), (1984) ICJ Rep 246

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top