Authored By: Babarinde Esther Adetola
Adeleke University
CASE NAME: Oluwadamilola Banire v NTA-Star Tv Network Limited
CASE NO: CA/A/345/2017
COURT: COURT OF APPEAL
DATE OF DECISION: 3 February,2021
BENCH COMPOSITION: Mohammed Baba Idris, JCA delivered the lead judgement
Peter Olabisi Ige, JCA
Yargata Byenchit Nimpar, JCA
1.0 INTRODUCTION
This case,Banire v NTA-Star Tv Network Limited(CA/A/345/2017) is significant in Nigeria’s legal landscape on protection of image rights in a photograph where copyright is claimed by another party. It is noteworthy because image rights is a novel concept in Nigeria and the Court sought to address whether image rights can be independent of copyright.Additionally, this case established that image rights may be protected under the passing-off tort as long as the necessary conditions are met.
2.0 FACTS OF THE CASE
In 2012, the Appellant,Ms. Oluwadamilola Banire, was a muse in a photo shoot which was shot by Orisun TV, a subsidiary of Virtual Media Network Limited (VMNL) and then later became a presenter for the company.
NTA-Star TV Network Limited, the Respondent, is a broadcaster of Virtual Media Network Limited Channels on its Digital Television Platform.
In 2013, the Respondent displayed the Appellant’s images on billboards in Akure and Abeokuta pursuant to a Channel License Agreement between the Respondent and Virtual Media Network Limited.This agreement requires Virtual Media Network Limited to provide promotional materials for the advertisement of its channels, Nigezie and Orisun Television, on the Respondent’s platform.
The Appellant filed a lawsuit at the Federal High Court in Abuja, asserting that the Respondent’s use of her images without her explicit consent constituted a breach of her image and intellectual property rights, and she sought compensation for this infringement. In response, the Respondent contended that the images were provided by Virtual Media Network Limited under a Channel License Agreement that is in place between the Respondent and Virtual Media Network Limited (VMNL).
The Trial court dismissed the suit on the grounds that the Respondent’s use of the Appellant’s images was not a violation of the Appellant’s right under the Copyright Act.
The Appellant appealed to the Court of Appeal.
Virtual Media Network Limited will be referred to as ‘VMNL’.
3.0 LEGAL ISSUES
The Court adopted the Appellant’s issues in determining the Appeal
- Whether from the facts and totality of the processes filed in this matter, the learned trial judge was right in holding that the Appellant had sued a wrong party and that the Respondent was exonerated from liability for wrongful use of the Appellant’s images because of the Channel License Agreement.
- Whether from the pleadings and evidence adduced before the trial Court, the issue of copyright is applicable in this case and if yes, whether the learned trial judge was right to have held that the ownership of the copyright in the Appellant’s photographs belong to Virtual Media Network Limited and not the Appellant.
5.0 ARGUMENTS
5.1 APPELLANT’S ARGUMENTS
On the first issue,the Counsel argued that the Respondent was exonerated of liability for the wrongful use of the Appellant’s images because of the Channel License Agreement.He stated that certain clauses in the Agreement did not authorize the use of 3rd Party images, and relying on the Doctrine of Privity of Contract, contended that Appellant should not be bound by the Agreement
The Counsel contended that it was the Respondent who utilized the Appellant’s images,and therefore had the responsibility of joining VMNL as a party to the suit and where it fails to do so, they will bear the sole liability.Total (Nigeria) Plc v Delmar Petroleum Company Limited.[1] Where collusion exists between the Respondent and VMNL,the Appellant can sue either or both of the parties with neither being deemed a wrong party.
Regarding the second Issue, the Counsel argued that the Appellant’s claim was on image rights, as the Respondent used the Appellant’s images for promotions without consent, creating an impression of endorsement which constituted a claim of passing off in Tort. He asserted that Section 10(1)(2)(3) of the Copyright Act, 2004 were inapplicable because the images were not taken during her term of employment with VMNL.[2]
5.2 RESPONDENT’S ARGUMENT
On Issue one, the Respondent’s Counsel contended that the Channel License Agreement between the Respondent and VMNL allowed the Respondent to use the images for promotional purposes, as VMNL conducted the photo session and thus is the author of the images. He argued that the Respondent’s activities were based on a valid contract between it and VMNL.He argued further that the Appellant’s omission to sue or join VMNL rendered the suit incompetent relying on Cotecna International Ltd v Church Gate Nig. Ltd & Anor.[3] He asserted that VMNL provided the images for advertising its Orisun TV channel on StarTimes.
On issue two, the Counsel argued that the Appellant did not establish image rights under the categories of Intellectual Property Rights in Nigeria. He argued that Copyright is applicable and by virtue of Section 10(1)(2) of the Copyright Act, 2004,VMNL was the author and provided the images for promoting its channels.[4]
6.0 COURT’S REASONING AND ANALYSIS
On the first issue,the Appellant’s argument was that the trial Court was wrong in exonerating the Respondent’s wrongful act based on the Channel License Agreement, to which the Appellant was not privy and which included no clause authorizing the Respondent or VMNL to use her images.
The Court examined the trial court’s decision and noted that the trial judge did not make the Appellant a party to the Channel License Agreement but rather ruled that VMNL conducted the photoshoot and owned the images. Thus,VMNL had to be sued or joined for the Appellant’s claim to succeed.
On the issue of collusion by the Respondent and VMNL and the trial judge’s decision that the Appellant sued the wrong party, the Court held that the party seeking declaratory reliefs must succeed on the strength of its own case and not the weakness of the other party.Mohammed v Wammako & Ors [5]and Emenike v P.D.P.[6] The Appellant had the burden of suing or joining the party liable to establish her claim. The Court further examine the Channel License Agreement and found that VMNL supplied the promotional materials and had copyright in these materials
On issue two, the Appellant Counsel maintained that the claims brought before the Court relate to image rights/publicity rights and the tort of passing off. The Counsel challenged that the trial court’s attribution of authorship and ownership of her photographs was based on Section 10 (1)(2)(3) , Copyright Act Cap 28 LFN 2004.
The court defined Image Rights/Publicity rights
‘A person’s right against misappropriation of his name, likeness, physical appearances, nicknames, pictures, personal slogans etc’.
The Court observed that while Passing off was originally limited to goods and services; however, Irvine v Talksport Ltd[7] and Robyn Rihanna Fenty v Aracadia Group Brands Ltd (T/a Topshop) & Anor,[8]established that it encompasses unauthorized use of individuals’ images.
The Court reasoned that for Passing Off to protect the Appellant’s images,the Appellant must prove goodwill or reputation, misrepresentation by the defendant to the public and damage suffered or likely to be suffered. She failed to prove these elements.The Court observed that image rights lack legal protection in Nigeria, although The 1999 Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria guarantees the Right to Privacy.[9]
The Court emphasized that image rights must be considered alongside the copyright of a photograph, with Section 10 Copyright Act,2004 attributing authorship to the photographer, even under an employment contract, unless otherwise agreed.
The Court concurred that Section 10 Copyright Act,2004 applied, as the photoshoot occurred before the Appellant’s employment as a presenter. It held that VMNL was the author and owner because it captured the images as opposed to the Lower Court’s decision.The Court also determined that image rights and the Tort of Passing off protecting images are new concepts in Nigeria. Images are safeguarded by copyright law, and the presented evidence and pleadings demonstrated that the matter was covered under copyright law.
7.0 JUDGEMENT AND RATIO DECIDENDI
On the first issue,the Court upheld the trial court’s judgement exonerating the Respondent on the basis of the Channel License Agreement, holding that the Appellant’s failure to sue or join Virtual Media Network Limited to the suit made the suit susceptible to failure.
On the second issue, Copyright is applicable and the claims regarding image rights and the tort of passing cannot be applied and the copyright owner of the Appellant’s photograph Virtual Media Network Limited.
The Appeal was dismissed with no cost
7.1 RATIO DECIDENDI
The Judgment’s Ratio Decidendi is as follows:
If the claimant does not join or sue the party responsible for liability, the claim will be unsuccessful. To establish a tort of passing off for the protection of image rights, the necessary elements of passing off must be proven. The legal framework that safeguards photographs is the Copyright Act of 2004, which gives copyright to the photographer. In the context of image rights, it is important to consider the copyright associated with a photograph.
8.0 CRITICAL ANALYSIS
The case of Banire v NTA-Star TV Network Ltd is significant regarding the legal landscape of photographs copyright and image rights in Nigeria. The Court of Appeal ruled that image rights is not an independent right in Nigeria but must be considered vis-a-vis copyright of a photograph.
A significant strength of this decision lies in the interpretation of Section 10 and Section 51 of the Copyright Act 2004, which defines an author as the individual who captured the photograph. Furthermore, if a photograph is commissioned or taken as part of employment, the authorship will be attributed to the commissioner or employer.
This ruling consolidated ownership and authorship in Virtual Media Network Limited. While the Copyright Act grants first ownership to the author, copyright is classified as a movable property that can be transferred through Assignment, License, or Testamentary Disposition.[10]
Furthermore, the Court did not adequately address the Appellant’s Right to Privacy,by being a muse in the photograph.Although the court acknowledged that an individual’s image rights are comparable to the Right to Privacy protected under the Constitution of The Federal Republic of Nigeria, it may also take into account the provisions of the Nigerian Data Protection Act, which identifies a person’s image as a personal identifier that requires safeguarding.[11] This decision has limited the pursuit of image rights as an independent category of Intellectual Property Rights, suggesting instead that it should be viewed within the framework of copyright pertaining to photographs.
However, in Ubom v. Globacom (Nig) Ltd , the Supreme Court recognized the legitimacy of image rights, as the claimant’s claim was founded on the unauthorized commercial exploitation of her image and likeness.The Court therefore emphasized that the lower courts had erred by merging copyright protection with the distinct right of an individual to control the commercial use of their identity. [12]
9.0 CONCLUSION
This case shows the difficulty in protecting image rights in Nigeria where it’s not recognized as a category of Intellectual Property. Hence, there is no legal framework specifically protecting these rights.The Court of Appeal confirmed that the Appellant’s claims could not succeed because Virtual Media Network Limited, the rightful owner of the copyright for the photographs, was not adequately joined, and the necessary elements of passing off were not demonstrated. This decision highlights the need for image rights to be recognized in Nigeria to protect common individuals and celebrities.
Reference(S):
[1] [2002] LPELER – 7170 (CA).
[2] Copyright Act Cap 28 LFN 2004, S10(1)(2)(3)
[3] [2010] 18 NWLR (PT. 1225) 346 SC
[4] Copyright Act Cap 28 LFN 2004, S10(1)(2)
[5] [2017] LPELR – 42667
[6] [2012] 50 NSCQR 94 at 130
[7] [2002]F.S.R. 60
[8] [2012] EWHC 2310 (CH)
[9] Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999, s37
[10] Copyright Act 2022, s30
[11]Nigeria Data Protection Act (NDPA) 2023,s65
[12][2024] LPELR – 79933 (SC)

