Home » Blog » Mst Mamataz Begum v Anowar Hossain

Mst Mamataz Begum v Anowar Hossain

Authored By: Most Sumaiya Afrin

University of Rajshahi

Case citation and Basic Information :

Case name :Mst Mamataz Begum v Anowar Hossain

Citation : Civil Appeal No. 139 of 2003; reported in 1 LNJ (AD) (2012) 41.

Court : Appellate Division, Supreme Court of Bangladesh

Date of Decision : 21 june & 31july 2011.

Bench Composition :

Mr. Surendra Kumar Sinha J.

Madam Nazmun Ara Sultana J.

Mr. Syed Mahmud Hossain J.

Mr. Muhammad Imman Ali J.

Mr. Muhammad Mamtaz Uddin Ahmed J.

Mr.Md.Shamsul Huda J.

Introduction:

In Bangladesh, registering every Muslim marriage is compulsory under Section: 03 of ‘ The Muslim Marriages and Divorces (Registration) Act, 1974’.[1] However, the landmark case  Mst. Mamataz Begum v. Anowar Hossain went a step further than just this statutory provision . By combining the principles of Islamic law with Section 50 of the Evidence Act, 1872, the court presumed a marriage to be legally valid setting a vital precedent in the process. This case is significant because the Appellate Division of High Court, Bangladesh, considered a Muslim  marriage without registered kabinnama. The Appellate Division held that,  in the absence of formal proof of a valid marriage, a marriage can be presumed by evidence of conduct and reputation, and the question of consummation forms often an important element in the status of valid marriage.

III. Facts of the case:

In this case appellant and respondent  lived together as a husband wife without a registered kabinanama. Appellant instituted a suit against the respondent for dower and maintenance in the Family Court. She claimed that though their marriage was solemnized according to Mohammedan Law, the Kabinnama was not registered. Respondent contested the suit denying the marriage. Besides the evidence of the appellant, the family court on assessment of the evidence of witnesses decreed the suit. The Court of Appeal below affirmed the judgment next a single bench of the High Court division in exercise of revolutionary jurisdiction reversed the judgments of the court below and dismissed the suit.[2]

Legal Issues

The Appellate Division identified three issues for determination :

(1) Whether non-registration of the marriage under Mohammedan Law makes the marriage illegal or irregular or non-existent, [3]

(2) Whether continuous co-habitation by the appellant and the respondent over a period of three years as husband and wife coupled with their conduct infer a presumption as to the legal marriage, and

 (3) whether the High Court Division is justified in interfering with the concurrent findings of fact arrived at by the Courts below on proper assessment of the evidence on record as to the solemnization of a legal marriage between the appellant and the respondent in exercise of revisional jurisdiction the solemnization of a legal marriage between the appellant and the respondent in exercise of revisional jurisdiction.[4]

 Arguments presented

Appellants Argument : Dr. Rabia Bhuiyan, learned counsel contended that the view of the High Court Division in drawing adverse presumption against the appellant merely on the ground of absence of kabinnama is based on misconception of law. According to the learned counsel, in view of the concurrent findings that the appellant and the respondent had lived together as husband and wife over a period of three years which suggested the presumption of legal marriage, the High Court Division erred in law in interfering with the said concurrent findings of fact.[5]

Respondents Argument : Mr. Wadud Bhuiyan, learned counsel submitted that the plaint is totally silent as to the date, place and presence of witnesses of the marriage and the appellant having failed to prove the essentials of a   marriage under Mohammedan Law, the High Court Division is perfectly justified in dismissing the suit. In support of his contention the learned counsel has referred to the cases of Khorshed Alam @ Shah Alam V. Amir Sultan Ali Hyder and another, 38 DLR (AD) 133, Debendra Mohan Rai V. Sona Kunwar, (1904) 36 Allahbad 295, Abdool Razack V. Aga Mahomed Jaffer Bindaneem, 21 Indian Appeal 56 and some other decisions.[6]

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

Marriage under the Mohammedan Law is a civil contract requiring no ceremony or special formality.  But both on principle and authority, it would seem that the agreement alone is sufficient to consummate a common law marriage, and that the subsequent cohabitation is important only as evidence of the agreement.Moreover, it is clear on the authorities, in the States where formal solemnization is not necessary, that although there is no proof of an actual written or oral contract, the agreement necessary to the formation of a common-law marriage may be inferred solely from the conduct of the parties.[7]

The parties may have purported to contract a marriage and lived together, but the agreement at the time it is entered into may be void because of some disability unknown to both parties. If, subsequently, the disability is removed, a new contract is in strictness.[8]

The Court explained that marriage may be proved directly through witnesses or documentary evidence, but it may also be proved presumptively through the conduct and reputation of the parties.[9]

The Court particularly referred to section 50 of the Evidence Act 1872. Under section 50, when a court has to form an opinion regarding the relationship of one person to another, evidence of conduct by a person having special means of knowledge of that relationship may be relevant. Illustration (a) specifically concerns the question whether two persons were married and recognises the relevance of evidence that they were ordinarily received and treated as husband and wife.[10]

Thus, the Court treated the conduct of the parties and their social recognition as husband and wife as legally relevant evidence.

VII .Judgement and Ratio Decidendi

The Appellate Division allowed the appeal and set aside the judgment of the High Court Division. The Court held that the evidence sufficiently established the existence of a legal marriage between the parties and the court  also awarded costs of Tk 10,000 against the respondent.[11]

A Muslim marriage may be established by circumstantial  evidence including prolonged and continuous cohabitation as husband and wife, reputation and party’s conduct. Where the evidence establishes prolonged cohabitation and other circumstances consistent  with marriage a presumption in favor of marriage arise, the absence of a registered kabinnama  does not by itself establish that a Muslim marriage is non-existent.[12]

VIII. Critical Analysis

Firstly, it protects individuals who may otherwise be denied recognition of a marital relationship merely because formal documentary evidence is unavailable. This is particularly important in circumstances where a Kabinnama has not been registered or cannot be produced.

Secondly, the judgment demonstrates the importance of evidence of conduct and reputation in family-law disputes. Marriage is not always capable of being proved through a single document. The court may consider the  circumstances and the manner in which the parties conducted themselves.

Thirdly, the decision provides an important illustration of the interaction between Mohammedan law and the Evidence Act 1872. The Court did not treat Muslim personal law and evidentiary principles as separate spheres; instead, it used section 50 of the Evidence Act to explain how a marital relationship may be established through evidence of conduct.[13]

Finally, the judgment is significant because it rejected a moralistic approach to the parties’ cohabitation and instead insisted that the dispute must be resolved according to applicable law and evidence. The Appellate Division criticised the High Court Division for failing to assess the evidence in accordance with established principles of Mohammedan law.[14]

Conclusion

Mst.Mamataz Begum v Anowar Hossain case remains  presumption of Muslim marriage in Bangladesh. The case established that the absence of the  registered kabinama  does not necessarily defeat a claim of marriage, Where the parties have lived together continuously as husband and wife and their conduct, reputation and other evidence support that they are married.  As a result of this judgement , even if either party to a marriage denies the marriage by destroying the registered Kabinama or through any other means, a valid marriage can still be presumed based on the conduct of the parties. This will ultimately play a crucial role in safeguarding the rights of both sides.

Reference(S):

[1] The Muslim Marriages and Divorces (Registration) Act, 1974,s 03.

[2] Mst Momtaz Begum v Anowar Hossain Civil Appeal No 139 of 2003 (Appellate Division, Supreme Court of Bangladesh, 31 July 2011) 2–4 (S K Sinha J).

[3] Ibid 4-5

[4] Ibid 4-5

[5] Ibid 5-8

[6] ibid 5-8

[7] Ibid 8-15

[8] Ibid 20-24

[9] Ibid 20-24

[10] Ibid 18-22

[11] Ibid 36

[12] Ibid 20-24

[13] Evidence Act 1872, s 50; Mst Momtaz Begum (n 1) 18–20.

[14] Mst Momtaz Begum v Anowar Hossain Civil Appeal No 139 of 2003 (Appellate Division, Supreme Court of Bangladesh, 31 July 2011)35-36  (S K Sinha J).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top